Summary
When email open rates remain consistent across different Email Service Providers (ESPs) but click-through rates (CTR) are significantly lower than expected, it indicates that your deliverability is strong, but the content or call to action within your emails may not be compelling enough to drive recipient engagement. This scenario is a common challenge for email marketers and deliverability professionals alike, as it shifts the focus from inbox placement to message effectiveness. It means your emails are reaching the inbox, but they are failing to captivate or motivate recipients to take the next desired step, such as visiting a landing page or making a purchase. The goal then becomes to optimize the internal elements of your email to convert opens into clicks, ultimately improving campaign performance.
Key findings
- Deliverability Success: Consistent open rates across ESPs confirm your emails are successfully landing in the inbox, indicating good sender reputation and technical setup. This means issues like spam filtering or blocklisting are likely not the primary cause of low CTR.
- Content Gap: The disparity between high open rates and low CTR suggests a disconnect between the initial curiosity generated by your subject line and the value perceived within the email body itself.
- Engagement Metrics: While open rates indicate initial engagement, CTR is a more direct measure of how compelling your message is in driving desired actions. A high click-to-open rate (CTOR) is often a better indicator of content effectiveness than CTR alone, as it specifically measures clicks among those who actually opened the email.
- User Experience: Factors such as email design, mobile responsiveness, and the clarity of your call to action (CTA) play a significant role in influencing whether a recipient clicks. Even with good deliverability, a poor user experience can hinder clicks.
Key considerations
- Content Relevance: Ensure your email content directly addresses the expectations set by your subject line and preview text. Irrelevant or misleading content will quickly lead to disengagement.
- Clear Call to Action: Your primary call to action should be prominent, easy to understand, and singular in focus. Too many CTAs can overwhelm recipients.
- Mobile Optimization: A significant portion of emails are opened on mobile devices. Ensure your email is responsive, loads quickly, and has clickable elements that are easily tappable. You can find more about how to optimize email for mobile here.
- A/B Testing: Continuously test different elements of your email, such as CTA button color, placement, copy, and overall design, to identify what resonates best with your audience. For more insights on this, consider exploring how A/B testing can improve email click-through rates.
- Audience Segmentation: Highly segmented and personalized emails often lead to higher engagement because the content is more tailored to the recipient's specific interests or needs.
What email marketers say
Email marketers widely agree that once an email lands in the inbox and is opened, the responsibility for driving clicks shifts squarely to the content and overall user experience within the email. They often emphasize that deliverability specialists (or the ESP) can ensure the email reaches the recipient, but it's the marketer's job to make it engaging enough to compel a click. This perspective highlights the critical role of creative, compelling copy, effective design, and clear calls to action in translating an open into a click. Marketers frequently share experiences where strong deliverability (indicated by consistent open rates) still yields low CTR if the message fails to resonate or guide the recipient effectively.
Key opinions
- Content is King: Once an email is opened, its content, relevance, and presentation determine whether a recipient will click. Focus should be on crafting messages that provide immediate value or clear next steps.
- Marketing's Domain: The act of getting a click is fundamentally a marketing function, not a deliverability one. Deliverability ensures the email arrives, marketing ensures it converts.
- Beyond the Inbox: A high open rate with low CTR can indicate that while the subject line is effective, the content itself is not meeting the subscriber's expectations or guiding them to a clear action.
- CTA Optimization: Optimizing the call to action, its visibility, and its phrasing is crucial. A strong CTA can significantly impact click-to-open rates.
Key considerations
- Audience Expectation Management: Ensure your subject line and preview text accurately reflect the email's content to avoid disappointing recipients who open the email but find nothing relevant to click.
- Visual Hierarchy: Design emails with a clear visual hierarchy that draws the eye towards the main message and call to action. Clutter or lack of focus can dilute the impact.
- Segmentation and Personalization: Deeply segment your lists and personalize content to make emails more relevant to individual subscribers, thereby increasing the likelihood of clicks. This is a common strategy to improve overall email deliverability and open rates as well.
- Testing Variations: Regularly A/B test different elements within your email, such as imagery, button text, and copy length, to understand what drives the most clicks from your specific audience.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that their primary role is ensuring emails reach the inbox. They believe that once the mail is delivered, their job is done, and it's up to the marketing team to drive clicks. This highlights a clear division of responsibility: deliverability handles getting the email to the recipient, while marketing handles the engagement aspects.
Marketer view
A marketing specialist from Databox emphasizes the importance of a strong call to action (CTA) and compelling subject lines for improving email click-through rates. They advise focusing on value propositions within the email and segmenting the list to ensure relevance. These elements are seen as crucial for encouraging recipients to engage further with the content and convert opens into clicks.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts generally agree that their primary role is to ensure emails successfully reach the recipient's inbox, emphasizing that driving clicks falls largely outside their direct scope. While deliverability metrics (like open rates) are crucial for initial success, experts view low click-through rates, even with high opens, as a content and engagement problem that marketers must address. They often caution against artificial engagement strategies, such as using click bots, as these can ultimately harm sender reputation. The consensus is that authentic engagement comes from valuable content that genuinely resonates with the audience.
Key opinions
- Deliverability Scope: Experts believe their job is done once the email reaches the inbox. Click performance is a marketing metric influenced by content and strategy.
- Engagement vs. Deliverability: A consistent open rate across ESPs implies strong technical deliverability, suggesting that any low CTR is due to content quality or targeting, rather than inbox placement issues.
- Authenticity Matters: Generating false clicks or engagement can be detrimental to long-term sender reputation and should be avoided. Sustainable CTR comes from genuine interest.
- Domain Reputation Impact: While opens signify initial engagement, lack of subsequent clicks (or high bounces, spam complaints) can negatively impact domain reputation over time, even if initial open rates are good.
Key considerations
- Monitor Click-to-Open Rate (CTOR): This metric provides a clearer picture of how well your content converts opens into clicks, isolating the content's effectiveness from initial deliverability.
- Segment by Engagement: For subscribers who open but don't click, consider segmenting them for re-engagement campaigns with different content or offers. This can also help in diagnosing and improving overall email deliverability for unengaged users.
- Understand Bot Clicks: Be aware that some open rate data might be inflated by bot clicks, particularly in certain email environments. This can distort true engagement metrics, making CTR appear lower in comparison. Spamresource offers further insights on understanding bot behavior.
- Focus on Value: The most effective way to drive clicks is to consistently deliver value that meets or exceeds subscriber expectations, fostering trust and long-term engagement.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from Email Geeks humorously points out that they can't force recipients to click, underscoring the distinction between ensuring inbox delivery and driving user interaction. This statement reinforces the idea that clicks are a function of compelling content and user interest, rather than solely a technical deliverability outcome.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from Spamresource advises that high open rates with low click rates can sometimes be indicative of bot activity rather than genuine engagement. They suggest analyzing click patterns and other metrics to differentiate between real user interaction and automated opens/clicks, which can distort true engagement figures.
What the documentation says
Official email marketing and deliverability documentation frequently outlines the distinct roles of email delivery versus content engagement. While technical standards and guidelines, such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, are designed to ensure an email's authenticity and improve its chances of reaching the inbox, they do not prescribe content strategies that guarantee clicks. Documentation often implies that once the email has passed authentication checks and avoided blocklists, the onus is on the sender's content quality, audience targeting, and design effectiveness to prompt recipient action. This separation highlights that deliverability provides the foundation, but content provides the motivation for clicks.
Key findings
- Authentication vs. Engagement: Standards like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC primarily focus on sender authentication and preventing phishing/spoofing, which directly influence inbox placement. They do not dictate content strategy for click generation.
- Content Quality Importance: Post-delivery, content quality, relevance to the audience, and the clarity of the call to action are the main drivers of CTR, as emphasized by marketing best practices documentation.
- Recipient Behavior: Documentation on email engagement typically points to factors like personalized content, mobile optimization, and clear value propositions as key to converting opens into clicks.
- Feedback Loops: While not directly about CTR, feedback loops (e.g., from Google Postmaster Tools) provide insights into spam complaints and poor engagement, which can indirectly indicate issues with content relevance that lead to low clicks.
Key considerations
- Adhere to Best Practices: Beyond deliverability, follow documented best practices for email content, design, and call-to-action placement to maximize clicks. This includes optimizing for mobile responsiveness and clarity.
- Monitor CTOR: While documentation on technical email standards might not directly address CTR, marketing guides consistently recommend monitoring CTOR as a true indicator of content performance.
- Leverage Analytics: Utilize ESP analytics and marketing platforms to track granular click data, including click maps and individual link performance. This data helps refine content strategies. Understanding your Google Postmaster Tools data can also provide valuable context.
- Content Strategy Alignment: Ensure your content strategy (e.g., email frequency, messaging, offers) is aligned with subscriber expectations and lifecycle stages, as this significantly impacts willingness to click.
Technical article
Documentation from Campaign Monitor emphasizes that a good click-through rate typically ranges between 2-5%, depending on the industry. This statistical benchmark helps marketers assess their performance against industry averages, suggesting that if open rates are healthy but CTR falls below this range, it indicates a content or design issue that needs addressing.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailmunch states that optimizing email content, subject lines, and send times are critical strategies for increasing email open rates. While not directly about CTR, these factors lay the groundwork for potential clicks; an email must first be opened before it can be clicked. The guidance implicitly supports that strong initial engagement (opens) is a prerequisite for subsequent actions (clicks).
Related resources
15 resources
![Email Click-Through Rate: How To Increase CTR [2025]](https://moosend.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Email-click-through-rate.png)
Related pages
How to Increase Email Click Through Rate [Step By Step Guide]
How to diagnose and improve email deliverability and open rates?
How to combat spam filter and bot clicks on emails?
Why do all-image emails have higher open rates and are open rates a reliable KPI?
Why did my email open rates drop after a template redesign, but click rates remained the same?
Why Your Emails Fail: Expert Guide to Improve Email Deliverability [2025]
How to Run an Email Deliverability Test: A Proven Checklist
Boost Email Deliverability Rates: Technical Solutions from Top Performing Senders
Google Postmaster Tools Domain Reputation: The Ultimate Guide for Email Marketers
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
