Summary
Image-heavy emails present a nuanced challenge for email deliverability and accessibility, particularly for telecommunication companies. While not an immediate death knell for all senders, an over-reliance on images without corresponding text can flag spam filters. More critically, accessibility concerns, especially for B2C audiences, are paramount, with potential legal ramifications for non-compliance. Ensuring content is readable and usable by everyone, regardless of disability or viewing preferences (like dark mode), is a core responsibility that directly impacts both user experience and legal standing.
Key findings
- Deliverability risk: Image-heavy or image-only emails can trigger spam filters, as spammers often use them to hide malicious content or evade text-based detection. This can lead to your emails being marked as spam or even your domain being added to a blocklist.
- Accessibility issues: Without proper alt text, screen readers cannot interpret image content, making emails inaccessible to users with visual impairments. This extends to issues like poor contrast in dark mode, where image colors may not invert correctly.
- Legal exposure: Telecom companies face specific legal mandates, such as the Telecommunications Act, requiring all products and services, including emails, to be accessible. Failure to comply with accessibility standards like the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) can lead to significant lawsuits and fines.
- Impact on user experience: Emails that are difficult to read or navigate due to image reliance or poor dark mode compatibility can frustrate subscribers, leading to lower engagement and potential unsubscribes.
Key considerations
- Text-to-image ratio: While not a hard rule, maintaining a healthy text-to-image ratio is a best practice for better deliverability. Email clients prefer a balance of text and visuals.
- Alt text implementation: Always include descriptive alt text for all images. This ensures that even if images don't load or for users with screen readers, the content's meaning is conveyed.
- Modular email structure: Adopting a modular, templated email structure can simplify the creation of accessible emails, allowing non-coding teams to assemble content without compromising standards.
- Proactive testing: Regularly test emails for accessibility, including dark mode compatibility and image rendering across various clients.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often find themselves at a crossroads between creative design aspirations and the practicalities of email deliverability and accessibility. There's a common apprehension about image-heavy emails being caught by spam filters, especially when working with teams that rely on visual editors and lack coding expertise. While short-term image-heavy campaigns might seem like a quick fix, marketers recognize the need for careful consideration and testing to avoid long-term reputation damage and ensure effective communication.
Key opinions
- Deliverability fears: A primary concern among marketers is that emails with too many images and insufficient live text will lead to spam folder placement, impacting campaign performance.
- WYSIWYG limitations: Teams heavily reliant on What You See Is What You Get (WYSIWYG) editors often struggle to implement best practices for text-to-image balance, leading to image-dominant designs.
- Interim solutions: Image-based emails are sometimes considered a temporary workaround during transitions or when new creative assets are not yet templatized.
- Accessibility focus: Marketers acknowledge the importance of designing for accessibility, including considerations for dark mode, to ensure broad audience reach.
Key considerations
- A/B testing: Conducting A/B tests with small audience segments can help marketers understand the actual impact of image-heavy emails on their specific audience and deliverability metrics, addressing internal fears effectively.
- Internal education: Educating non-coding marketing teams about the nuances of image-based email best practices can bridge the knowledge gap and improve overall campaign quality.
- Long-term strategy: While short-term solutions may be necessary, marketers should prioritize establishing templated, accessible email designs for sustainable deliverability and user experience.
- Dark mode testing: Marketers need to test how their color schemes and images behave in dark mode to avoid contrast issues that impact readability.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks suggests that many companies are sending emails just fine, regardless of whether they are all text, a mix of text and images, or all images. The key factor for deliverability often lies elsewhere, such as overall sending reputation.
Marketer view
Marketer from Quora advises that emails containing only images are frequently flagged by spam filters. It is usually best to include a healthy mix of text and images to avoid deliverability issues.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts highlight that while image-heavy emails aren't inherently problematic, the core issues lie in the context of sending reputation and, critically, accessibility. They emphasize that spam filters are more sophisticated than simple text-to-image ratio checks. For telecommunication companies, the legal imperative for accessibility adds a significant layer of complexity, making robust, inclusive design a necessity rather than a mere best practice. Experts urge a holistic approach, considering both technical deliverability factors and broad user access.
Key opinions
- No simple ratio: It is a myth that a fixed text-to-image ratio guarantees deliverability. Spam filters evaluate a multitude of factors, with sending reputation being a primary driver.
- Accessibility as legal necessity: For specific industries like telecommunications, accessibility is not just a best practice but a legal requirement under acts such as the Telecommunications Act. Non-compliance can lead to legal action.
- Image-only red flag: Emails composed entirely of images (or nearly so) are indeed considered a significant red flag by many spam filters because this technique is often employed by spammers to bypass content analysis.
- Dark mode challenges: Experts acknowledge that image-based emails can pose significant issues in dark mode, as colors within images do not invert, potentially leading to inaccessible contrast ratios.
Key considerations
- Holistic deliverability approach: Focus on overall email sending practices, including list hygiene, authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), and engagement metrics, rather than isolating image content as the sole deliverability factor.
- Stakeholder education: Communicate the specific legal risks of inaccessible emails to stakeholders, highlighting potential fines and lawsuits as a strong incentive for compliance.
- Accessible design integration: Integrate accessibility best practices, such as proper alt text and semantic HTML structure, into all email templates from the outset. This ensures content remains legible even if images fail to load or are blocked by recipient email clients, or if a user is leveraging a screen reader.
- Testing and validation: Regularly validate email designs across various email clients and devices to ensure consistent appearance and functionality, including dark mode compatibility. You can use an email deliverability tester to get a preview of this.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that it is not solely about whether an email is all text, a text/image ratio, or all images that determines deliverability. Many companies successfully send in all three categories, emphasizing that other factors are more crucial.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource clarifies that while the conventional wisdom of a low text-to-image ratio affecting deliverability holds some truth, the primary concern for most email service providers is the overall sending reputation. A good reputation can often mitigate issues from image-heavy content.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and industry guidelines consistently emphasize that while images are crucial for engagement, their excessive use without adequate text can negatively impact deliverability by triggering spam filters. More importantly, documentation stresses the non-negotiable requirement for email accessibility to comply with legal standards such as ADA and WCAG, ensuring content is usable by everyone. This dual focus highlights that effective email campaigns must balance visual appeal with technical best practices and inclusive design principles.
Key findings
- Spam filter sensitivity: Documentation confirms that emails composed solely of images or with an extremely low text-to-image ratio are often considered suspicious by spam filters, increasing the likelihood of being marked as junk.
- Legal accessibility compliance: Guidelines (e.g., WCAG) specify that digital content, including emails, must be accessible to individuals with disabilities. This is often legally mandated, with failure leading to lawsuits and penalties.
- Improved deliverability: Accessible emails, which generally feature a balanced text-to-image ratio and proper HTML structure, are more likely to be recognized as legitimate by email clients, positively impacting inbox placement.
- Brand reputation: Accessible and well-structured emails contribute to a professional and reliable brand image, fostering customer loyalty and trust.
Key considerations
- Alt text requirement: All images must have descriptive alt text to ensure screen readers can convey the visual content to users with visual impairments.
- Textual content priority: Prioritize delivering key information via live text rather than solely through images, which ensures readability even if images are blocked or don't load. This is a crucial element when determining if images affect email deliverability.
- HTML structure: Employ semantic HTML structures in emails. This provides a robust fallback for content and aids accessibility tools in interpreting the email's layout and content. Additionally, consider how email code quality affects deliverability.
- Dark mode considerations: Design emails to adapt gracefully to dark mode. If images are used, ensure they do not create contrast issues that make content unreadable when backgrounds invert.
Technical article
Documentation from Klaviyo Help Center states that emails consisting solely of images, or those that are very image-heavy, may trigger spam filters. It advises that emails should ideally contain a combination of images and text for optimal deliverability.
Technical article
Documentation from Be Accessible highlights that accessible emails help meet legal compliance standards, specifically referencing the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). Adherence to these guidelines is crucial for avoiding legal issues.
Related resources
11 resources
Related pages
How to protect email deliverability for image-only emails?
How do email image sizes affect deliverability and Gmail promotions tab placement?
Is image-to-text ratio still important for email deliverability?
Does a high image to text ratio affect email deliverability and spam filtering?
Are image-based emails a good practice, and what are the deliverability and accessibility implications?
Do images in emails affect deliverability?
Are image-only emails bad for deliverability?
What are the negative impacts of using large images in email marketing and how to fix them?
How does the image to text ratio in email affect deliverability?
Does using images instead of text affect email deliverability?
