Summary
Inviting people to sign up for a newsletter without directly adding them requires a careful approach that prioritizes consent and respects privacy. Directly adding contacts to an email list without their explicit permission can lead to serious deliverability issues, including being flagged as spam, landing on a blocklist or blacklist, and damaging your sender reputation. It also carries legal risks under regulations like GDPR and CAN-SPAM. The most effective strategies involve encouraging self-subscription through clear calls to action, valuable content, and shareable links, ensuring all new subscribers willingly opt in.
Key findings
- Consent is paramount: Never add individuals to your newsletter list without their explicit, verifiable consent. Consent cannot be transferred or inferred, even if a colleague believes someone would be interested.
- Direct invitation risks: While personal invitations from a known contact (e.g., a friend or colleague) might seem harmless, encouraging this practice at scale can expose your organization to significant risks, including spam complaints and reputation damage.
- Promote self-subscription: The safest and most effective method is to provide easy-to-find sign-up forms and clear calls to action that encourage individuals to subscribe themselves.
- Leverage existing content: Provide a “view on web” link for your newsletter, allowing current subscribers to easily share content via social media or direct links without compromising deliverability. This also helps with preventing bot signups.
- Offer value: To entice sign-ups, highlight the benefits of subscribing, such as exclusive content, early access, or valuable insights.
Key considerations
- Avoid incentivizing unauthorized sharing: Do not encourage third parties to collect email addresses on your behalf or incentivize them to send mass invitations from personal accounts. This can complicate compliance and accountability.
- Implement double opt-in: For new subscribers, especially those coming from personal referrals, implementing a double opt-in process adds an extra layer of consent verification. This involves sending a confirmation email that the subscriber must click to verify their interest before being added to the list.
- Transparency: Ensure your sign-up process is clear about what subscribers will receive and how often, managing expectations from the outset.
- Monitor deliverability: Regardless of your growth strategy, regularly monitor your email deliverability rates and complaint rates to quickly identify and address any issues arising from your acquisition efforts.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often face the challenge of growing their lists while adhering to consent-based best practices. Discussions typically revolve around balancing the desire for growth with the imperative of maintaining a healthy sender reputation and avoiding spam complaints. Marketers emphasize the importance of making the sign-up process easy and appealing, often through incentives or by showcasing content, rather than resorting to direct, uninvited additions.
Key opinions
- Direct additions are risky: Marketers generally agree that directly adding people to an email list without their explicit opt-in consent is a bad practice and should be avoided.
- Leverage existing relationships ethically: Some suggest that personal contacts can be invited by a trusted individual, provided the invitation is sent from a personal email and directs recipients to an official sign-up form.
- Use shareable content: Making newsletters easily shareable, for instance, through a “view on web” link, is a safe way to encourage organic growth.
- Incentivize sign-ups: Offering valuable lead magnets, such as an ebook or exclusive content, is a proven method to encourage voluntary subscriptions.
- Strategic placement of CTAs: Placing prominent sign-up forms on websites, using pop-ups, or floating buttons can significantly increase subscription rates.
Key considerations
- Risk assessment for personal outreach: While small-scale personal invitations might seem benign, assess the potential for misunderstanding or abuse that could lead to negative consequences for your sender reputation.
- Clear and compliant opt-in process: Ensure your sign-up forms are clear, compliant with regulations, and ideally employ double opt-in to verify subscriber intent. This is crucial for avoiding invalid email addresses.
- Transparency in sharing: If encouraging subscribers to share, make sure the method of sharing clearly leads to a subscription form, preventing any perception of unauthorized forwarding.
- Content relevance: The most compelling reason for someone to sign up is relevant and valuable content. Focus on what benefits the subscriber.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks asks about inviting people to a newsletter. They want to know if it's acceptable for a colleague to personally email known contacts (e.g., former coworkers, classmates) to introduce the newsletter and ask if they'd like to sign up, then forward the confirmation for manual addition to the list.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks responds that while the idea of a personal invite is better than direct adding, the best approach is to simply provide a sign-up form link that can be easily shared.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts consistently underscore the critical role of explicit consent in email marketing. They warn against any practices that circumvent direct opt-in, highlighting the severe repercussions for sender reputation, deliverability, and potential legal penalties. Their advice centers on protecting the integrity of the mailing list and the sender's domain by ensuring every subscriber genuinely wants to receive communications.
Key opinions
- Avoid work-arounds for consent: Experts strongly advise against any method that bypasses direct, verifiable consent, even if it involves personal outreach, due to the inherent risks.
- Personal mailboxes have limits: Correspondence mailboxes are not designed for bulk sending, and even small volumes of uninvited emails can lead to personal accounts being flagged or blacklisted.
- Risk of escalated complaints: Any uninvited email, regardless of volume, carries the risk of triggering spam complaints, which can negatively impact sender reputation and deliverability.
- Protect your organization's reputation: As a list owner, it's crucial to distance your organization from practices that could lead to spam complaints, particularly if team members are involved in potentially risky invitation methods.
- Encourage organic sharing: The safest approach is to encourage existing recipients to share the newsletter's content or sign-up link with genuinely interested friends, rather than facilitating direct bulk outreach.
Key considerations
- Legal and career implications: Sending unsolicited commercial email, even from a personal work address, can have legal ramifications and be "career limiting" if it leads to official complaints or policy violations.
- Verify all consent: Any process where a third party collects consent and forwards it to you must be extremely robust and verifiable. Consent must be explicitly given to you, the sender, not just to the intermediary.
- Mitigate risk for the list owner: As the list owner, you must be able to demonstrate that you did not encourage or incentivize unconsented additions, especially if issues arise. This directly impacts domain reputation.
- Focus on high-quality sign-ups: Prioritize strategies that yield genuinely interested subscribers over volume. A smaller, engaged list will always outperform a large, unconsenting one for deliverability.
Expert view
Email expert from Email Geeks states that encouraging someone to send unsolicited emails from their work address is not advisable, as it can have serious professional repercussions.
Expert view
Deliverability expert from Email Geeks points out that correspondence mailboxes have volume limitations. Even small, uninvited batches of emails (e.g., 100 or less) carry a slight but present risk of causing a blocklisting or an escalated spam complaint.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and email marketing guidelines from regulatory bodies and major email service providers consistently emphasize the importance of permission-based marketing. They provide clear frameworks for obtaining and managing consent, mandating transparency, and outlining the consequences of non-compliance. These documents serve as the foundation for ethical and effective email list building, prioritizing subscriber choice and data privacy.
Key findings
- Explicit consent is required: Regulations like GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) and CAN-SPAM (Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography And Marketing Act) strictly require explicit, affirmative consent before sending commercial emails. This means pre-checked boxes or implied consent are generally insufficient.
- Consent must be verifiable: Marketers must be able to prove that consent was obtained, including when and how. This often necessitates maintaining detailed records of subscriptions.
- Double opt-in as best practice: While not always legally mandated, double opt-in is widely recommended by email service providers (ESPs) and deliverability experts as a best practice to confirm subscriber intent and reduce complaints.
- Clear unsubscribe mechanism: All commercial emails must include a clear and conspicuous way for recipients to opt out of future communications easily.
- Transparency and identity: Documentation emphasizes that senders must clearly identify themselves and state the purpose of their emails.
Key considerations
- Risk of legal penalties: Non-compliance with anti-spam laws can result in significant fines and legal action, underscoring the importance of adhering to consent requirements.
- Impact on deliverability: ISPs use subscriber engagement and complaint rates as key factors in determining email deliverability. Poor consent practices lead to higher complaints and reduced inbox placement.
- Data privacy expectations: Beyond legal requirements, recipients have an expectation of privacy and control over their inboxes. Respecting this builds trust and a positive sender reputation.
- Opt-in process integrity: Ensure your signup forms are protected from malicious bot signups that can compromise list quality and compliance.
Technical article
Official guidance from Mailchimp on opt-in email states that permission is the cornerstone of good email marketing. They advise using a clear opt-in process, such as pop-ups or dedicated homepage sections, to ensure visitors willingly subscribe to marketing emails, making the sign-up process as easy as possible.
Technical article
The CAN-SPAM Act documentation stipulates that commercial emails must not include false or misleading header information and must contain a clear and conspicuous unsubscribe mechanism. It also requires a valid physical postal address of the sender.
Related resources
11 resources
![How to build an email list and get more subscribers [21 tips]](https://getanewsletter.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/how-to-build-an-email-list-1.png)
Related pages
Does website registration automatically grant email subscription permission and is it best practice?
What are the risks of using services that convert website visitors into email leads without consent?
What are the best practices for referral emails regarding consent and incentives?
How to protect email list signup forms from bots and subscription bombing?
How to prevent bot sign-ups and suspicious contacts on email lists?
What are the best ways to mitigate risks when disabling double opt-in for email sign-up forms?
What is the best practice for handling invalid email addresses in opt-in forms?
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
What happens when your domain is on an email blacklist?
How to run an email deliverability test: a proven checklist
