Summary
The CAN-SPAM Act broadly applies to any electronic mail message whose primary purpose is commercial advertisement or promotion, regardless of whether it's sent individually, as part of an automated cadence, or in bulk. This means that individual sales emails and automated sales sequences, even personalized ones, are generally subject to CAN-SPAM compliance if they aim to promote a product or service. Key requirements for such emails include providing a clear mechanism for recipients to opt-out, a valid physical postal address, and ensuring truthful header information.
Key findings
- Purpose-Driven Compliance: CAN-SPAM compliance is determined by an email's primary purpose, applying to messages focused on commercial advertisement or promotion, not solely by whether they are sent in bulk.
- Broad Application: The Act covers individual sales emails, one-to-one outreach, and automated sales cadences, extending beyond traditional mass marketing campaigns.
- B2B Inclusion: CAN-SPAM regulations apply to commercial emails sent in a business-to-business (B2B) context, not just consumer-facing communications.
- Mandatory Elements: Commercial emails must include a clear and conspicuous opt-out mechanism, a valid physical postal address of the sender, and accurate sender and subject line information.
Key considerations
- Low Volume, Still Commercial: While individual, human-generated cold emails may pose a lower detection risk due to their low volume, they are technically still subject to CAN-SPAM if their primary purpose is commercial.
- Post-Reply Exemption: Once a recipient provides a positive reply, subsequent emails in that specific conversation are generally considered part of an ongoing dialogue and may no longer require an unsubscribe link, as they are no longer unsolicited commercial messages.
- Sales Team Responsibility: Sales professionals and teams must integrate CAN-SPAM requirements, such as unsubscribe links and physical addresses, into all commercial outreach efforts, whether one-off or automated.
- Hybrid Email Content: Even transactional emails may fall under CAN-SPAM if they also contain promotional material, necessitating careful review of their primary purpose.
What email marketers say
13 marketer opinions
The consensus among experts is clear: the CAN-SPAM Act governs emails based on their primary purpose-specifically, whether they are commercial advertisements or promotions-rather than their sending volume or method. This means individual sales emails and automated sales cadences, including personalized cold outreach, are subject to compliance if they aim to promote a product or service. Essential requirements for such communications include providing a straightforward way for recipients to opt-out, a valid physical postal address for the sender, and ensuring transparent and honest sender and subject line information.
Key opinions
- Primary Purpose Governs: CAN-SPAM compliance is primarily determined by an email's commercial or promotional purpose, not by whether it is sent individually or in bulk.
- Sales Cadences are Commercial: Individual sales emails, cold outreach, and automated sales sequences fall under CAN-SPAM if their main goal is to promote a commercial product or service.
- Non-Negotiable Requirements: All commercial sales communications must include an easily accessible opt-out option, the sender's valid physical postal address, and accurate sender and subject line information.
Key considerations
- Volume Does Not Grant Exemption: Even low-volume, individual sales emails are technically subject to CAN-SPAM if their primary purpose is commercial, despite a potentially lower risk of detection compared to mass sends.
- Engagement Shifts Status: After a recipient provides a positive reply, the subsequent one-to-one email exchanges are typically considered ongoing correspondence, generally removing the need for CAN-SPAM compliance for those specific, engaged communications.
- Comprehensive Sales Strategy: Sales teams need to integrate CAN-SPAM requirements, such as including opt-out links and physical addresses, into all commercial outreach methods, from personalized individual emails to automated sequences.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains that CAN-SPAM compliance is determined by whether an email is 'commercial' rather than 'bulk'. If an email's primary purpose is commercial advertisement or promotion, it requires clear identification as an advertisement, a notice of the opportunity to opt-out, and a valid physical postal address, regardless of how it was sent or triggered.
26 Jan 2024 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains that while one-off, human-generated cold emails may technically violate CAN-SPAM, the risk of detection is significantly lower compared to sending through automated tools due to the low volume.
12 Sep 2023 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
Experts confirm that the CAN-SPAM Act applies comprehensively to any commercial email, encompassing both one-to-one sales messages and multi-step automated cadences, regardless of the recipient type or sending volume. This means even a single unsolicited commercial email is covered if its primary aim is promotional. Essential compliance requirements for such communications include honest header information, a clear statement that the message is an advertisement, a valid physical postal address for the sender, and a functional opt-out mechanism. Once a recipient provides a positive reply, subsequent messages within that specific dialogue are generally considered solicited and may no longer necessitate elements like an unsubscribe link.
Key opinions
- Universal Commercial Reach: CAN-SPAM applies to all commercial emails, including individual sales messages and automated cadences, without exemption for B2B or low volume sends.
- Purpose-Driven Compliance: An email's primary purpose, not its sending method or volume, determines whether it falls under CAN-SPAM's commercial scope.
- Mandatory Disclosures: All covered emails must include accurate header information, a physical postal address, and a clear, functional unsubscribe option.
Key considerations
- Shift in Email Status: A positive recipient reply transforms an unsolicited commercial email into an ongoing conversation, potentially exempting subsequent messages in that thread from certain CAN-SPAM requirements.
- Software Use Implication: Utilizing software for sending commercial emails, even if low volume, can lead to their categorization as "bulk" by regulatory interpretations, reinforcing the need for compliance.
- Unsolicited Commercial Definition: The Act covers even a single unsolicited commercial email, underscoring its broad application beyond traditional mass marketing.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks clarifies that CAN-SPAM applies to commercial emails, not just bulk. She states that if software is used to manage commercial email, it is considered bulk, and even a single unsolicited commercial email is covered by CAN-SPAM.
15 Jul 2022 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks clarifies that once a recipient replies positively to an unsolicited commercial email, subsequent messages in that conversation are no longer considered unsolicited and therefore do not require CAN-SPAM compliance like an unsubscribe link, as they are a response to an inquiry.
9 Apr 2023 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
The CAN-SPAM Act mandates compliance for all emails primarily aimed at commercial advertisement or promotion, a scope that directly includes individual sales emails and automated sales cadences. This regulation applies irrespective of the sending volume or personalization level, extending to B2B communications and even transactional emails that contain promotional content. Key stipulations for such commercial outreach involve providing an unambiguous opt-out option, a verified physical postal address, and ensuring all sender and subject line information is accurate and transparent.
Key findings
- Primary Commercial Intent: The CAN-SPAM Act's applicability hinges on an email's main purpose being commercial advertisement or promotion, not its format, sending volume, or whether it's one-to-one.
- Sales Outreach Included: Both individual sales emails and automated sales cadences are generally subject to CAN-SPAM compliance, given their inherent commercial nature.
- Universal Compliance Elements: Essential requirements across all covered commercial emails are a clear unsubscribe option, a physical postal address, and truthful identifying information in the subject line and sender fields.
Key considerations
- Broad Definition of Commercial: The Act's wide definition captures many forms of sales outreach, even those highly personalized or sent in small quantities, as long as their primary purpose is commercial.
- Hybrid Email Scrutiny: Emails that blend transactional and promotional content must be carefully evaluated for CAN-SPAM compliance based on their dominant purpose.
- Sales Process Integration: Adherence to CAN-SPAM, particularly regarding opt-outs and physical addresses, must be a standard part of all sales email strategies, including individual outreach and automated sequences.
Technical article
Documentation from Federal Trade Commission explains that the CAN-SPAM Act applies to "commercial messages," defined as emails primarily purposed for commercial advertisement or promotion. This broad definition means individual sales emails and automated sales cadences generally require CAN-SPAM compliance, including a clear opt-out and physical postal address, if their primary purpose is commercial.
2 Jun 2023 - Federal Trade Commission
Technical article
Documentation from U.S. Government Publishing Office outlines that the CAN-SPAM Act applies to any electronic mail message primarily purposed for commercial advertisement or promotion. This broad definition encompasses both individual sales emails and automated sales cadences if they serve this primary commercial purpose, requiring adherence to all Act stipulations.
11 Sep 2024 - U.S. Government Publishing Office
Are gift membership invitation emails transactional under CAN-SPAM?
Does CAN-SPAM require a physical address in transactional emails?
Does CASL apply to emails sent from outside Canada to Canadian recipients?
How should collection agencies handle email marketing compliance and deliverability?
Is ZoomInfo's interpretation of CAN-SPAM accurate regarding email marketing best practices?
When are automated sales emails considered marketing under CAN-SPAM and require an unsubscribe link?
