Is DKIM configuration truly sufficient for email authentication?

No, DKIM configuration alone is generally not sufficient. While it verifies the sender's identity, for comprehensive email authentication and to meet modern sender requirements, you also need to implement SPF and DMARC. DMARC, in particular, requires alignment of either SPF or DKIM with your From header domain.

Should I configure custom DKIM for my domain even if Google Workspace or Office 365 applies a default signature?

Yes, it is highly recommended. Both Google and Microsoft apply default DKIM signatures (e.g., google.com or onmicrosoft.com ), but these do not align with your custom domain. Custom DKIM configuration ensures your emails are signed with your domain, which is crucial for DMARC alignment and preventing your emails from being marked as spam.

What is the complete set of email authentication protocols I should use?

For optimal deliverability and strong anti-spoofing protection, you should implement all three: SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. SPF specifies which servers are authorized to send email on your behalf, DKIM cryptographically signs your emails, and DMARC uses both to define policies for handling unauthenticated emails and provides valuable reporting.

Are SPF and DMARC really necessary alongside DKIM for Google Workspace and Office 365?

Yes, especially for senders of bulk email. Google and Yahoo have recently updated their requirements, mandating DMARC with either SPF or DKIM alignment for bulk senders. Failure to comply can lead to your emails being rejected or sent to spam.

Is DKIM configuration sufficient for Google Workspace and O365 email authentication? - Technical - Email deliverability - Knowledge base

Many organizations rely on Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 for their email infrastructure, and configuring email authentication is a critical step for deliverability and security. Often, the first authentication method people consider is DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail). It's a powerful tool, but the question frequently arises: is DKIM configuration alone sufficient for robust email authentication in these major platforms?

The answer, as with many aspects of email, is more nuanced than a simple yes or no. While a properly configured DKIM record provides a cryptographic signature that verifies the sender's identity and ensures message integrity, it's typically part of a larger ecosystem of authentication protocols.

For individual, low-volume sends, DKIM might seem sufficient on its own, especially if the receiving server is not overly strict. However, when we consider the broader landscape of email deliverability, including the latest requirements from major mailbox providers like Google and Yahoo, DKIM is just one piece of the puzzle. It's truly a foundational element, but it needs companions to achieve comprehensive protection and optimal inbox placement.

Suped DMARC monitoring

Free forever, no credit card required

Learn more

Trusted by teams securing millions of inboxes

The role of DKIM in email authentication

DKIM's primary function is to confirm that an email was indeed sent by the domain it claims to be from and that the message hasn't been tampered with in transit. It does this by adding a digital signature to the email's header. This signature is generated using a private key held by the sending server, and recipients verify it using a public key published in the sender's DNS records.

When an email passes DKIM authentication, it signifies that the sender is authorized to send mail on behalf of the domain associated with the DKIM signature. This helps prevent email spoofing and phishing attempts, where malicious actors try to impersonate legitimate senders. You can learn more about how DKIM and other standards work by reviewing this guide to SPF, DKIM, and DMARC email authentication.

DKIM configuration for

Google Workspace and

Office 365 involves generating DKIM keys within their respective admin consoles and then adding the public key as a TXT record in your domain's DNS. While both platforms provide a default DKIM signature, it's crucial to set up DKIM specifically for your custom domain to ensure proper alignment and maximum benefit.

DKIM configuration in Google Workspace and Office 365

When you send emails through Google Workspace or Microsoft 365, they often apply a default DKIM signature if you haven't explicitly configured one for your domain. For instance, Office 365 might sign your emails with an .onmicrosoft.com signature. While this passes DKIM authentication, it does not align the DKIM signing domain with your From address, which is critical for DMARC. This is a common issue that can lead to deliverability problems, and you can find more details on troubleshooting Office 365 DKIM and SPF failures here.

The proper configuration involves generating specific DKIM records within your Google Workspace Admin console or Microsoft 365 portal. This process ensures that your emails are signed with your actual sending domain, providing the necessary alignment for robust email authentication. For Office 365, you'll typically configure CNAME records. Microsoft's documentation provides a detailed guide for this.

Here's a comparison of how DKIM is generally configured in both environments:

Google Workspace DKIM

Admin Console: Administrators generate the DKIM record directly within the Google Workspace Admin console.
Record Type: A TXT record is provided, containing the public key.
DNS Update: This TXT record needs to be added to your domain's DNS settings.
Activation: After DNS propagation, you activate DKIM within the Google Workspace console.

Office 365 DKIM

Admin Portal: DKIM is configured through the Microsoft 365 Defender portal or Exchange Online PowerShell.
Record Type: CNAME records are typically used, pointing to Office 365 hostnames.
DNS Update: These CNAME records are added to your domain's DNS.
Activation: DKIM signing is enabled in the Microsoft 365 Defender portal after DNS propagation.

Proper DKIM setup ensures that emails sent directly from Google Workspace or Office 365 carry a valid signature aligned with your domain. This is especially important for domains with aliases, as DKIM and DMARC are required for aliases in Google Workspace for the same reasons as your primary domain.

Why DKIM alone is not enough

While DKIM is a strong authentication method, it is not sufficient on its own for complete email authentication and deliverability, especially for senders of bulk mail. The main reason is that DKIM primarily verifies the domain that signed the email, not necessarily the domain shown in the From header (the one your recipients see). This distinction is called alignment.

Without alignment, even if an email passes DKIM, it could still be flagged as suspicious. This is where DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) becomes indispensable. DMARC builds upon both DKIM and SPF (Sender Policy Framework), requiring at least one of them to align with the From header domain.

Major mailbox providers, including Google and Yahoo, have tightened their email sending requirements, particularly for bulk senders. They now mandate DMARC, with either SPF or DKIM alignment, along with other measures like one-click unsubscribe and low spam complaint rates. This means that simply having DKIM configured, even if it passes authentication, may not be enough if it's not aligning correctly under a DMARC policy. Failing to meet these new requirements can severely impact your email deliverability, leading to messages landing in spam or being outright rejected. For more on this, explore DKIM domain alignment requirements for Google and Yahoo.

Therefore, for comprehensive email security and optimal deliverability, a multi-layered approach using SPF, DKIM, and DMARC is essential. SPF helps to prevent unauthorized senders from using your domain, while DKIM cryptographically signs your emails. DMARC acts as the policy layer, instructing recipient servers on how to handle emails that fail authentication and providing valuable feedback reports.

The critical role of DMARC

DMARC is the policy layer that allows you to tell receiving mail servers what to do with emails that fail SPF or DKIM checks, especially if those checks don't align with your From domain. It also provides reporting capabilities, giving you insight into who is sending email on behalf of your domain and whether those emails are passing authentication checks. This reporting is invaluable for identifying and mitigating potential spoofing and phishing attacks.

For both Google Workspace and Office 365, setting up DMARC is crucial. Google explicitly states that you must turn on SPF and/or DKIM for your domain before you can use DMARC.

A basic DMARC record looks like this:

Example DMARC RecordDNS

v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:reports@yourdomain.com;

Setting a p=none policy allows you to monitor your email traffic without affecting delivery, which is a recommended starting point. Gradually moving to a stricter policy like p=quarantine or p=reject provides stronger protection against impersonation. You can learn how to safely transition your DMARC policy to these stricter policies.

Views from the trenches

Best practices

Always configure DKIM for your custom domain, not just rely on default signatures like onmicrosoft.com.

Implement SPF and DMARC alongside DKIM for comprehensive email authentication.

Ensure DKIM and SPF alignment with your 'From:' header domain, especially for DMARC compliance.

Monitor DMARC reports regularly to identify authentication failures and potential spoofing attempts.

Common pitfalls

Assuming default DKIM signatures (e.g., .onmicrosoft.com) are sufficient for deliverability.

Not configuring DKIM for all sending domains, including alias domains in Google Workspace.

Neglecting DMARC implementation, which is now critical for major mailbox providers.

Ignoring DMARC reports, missing crucial insights into email authentication issues.

Expert tips

When helping less technical users, emphasize the need for super admin access for full control.

For non-bulk mail, a DKIM pass might appear sufficient, but alignment is always a good idea.

If sending any bulk mail, ensure all mail aligns with DKIM and SPF under a DMARC policy.

Monitor your domain's authentication health through DMARC reports to preempt deliverability issues.

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks says that for non-bulk mail, any DKIM configuration might be sufficient, but aligning it is definitely recommended.

2024-01-29 - Email Geeks

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks says that if any bulk mail is being sent, then all emails need to be aligned with their respective domains.

2024-01-29 - Email Geeks

The path to comprehensive email authentication

In conclusion, while DKIM is a vital component of email authentication, it is not sufficient on its own for Google Workspace and Office 365 email authentication, especially in today's stricter email ecosystem. Relying solely on a default DKIM signature or DKIM without proper alignment can lead to deliverability issues.

For robust email security and optimal inbox placement, particularly for bulk senders or those concerned about domain reputation, implementing SPF and DMARC in conjunction with DKIM is paramount. This tripartite approach ensures your emails are authenticated, protected from spoofing, and reliably delivered to recipients' inboxes.

The small investment of time in setting up these authentication protocols correctly will yield significant returns in improved deliverability and enhanced trust in your email communications.