Summary
Email database cleaning services employ a multifaceted approach to removing waste and invalid addresses. Some services use questionable tactics like spamming lists or buying bounce data. However, legitimate services prioritize preventative measures during data capture and use techniques like syntax checking, hard bounce removal, and identifying/removing risky addresses (spam traps, complainers, litigators), role-based addresses, disposable emails, parked domains, and inactive users. AI and proprietary methods also play a role. Preventing errors during data capture is emphasized as more effective than cleaning later.
Key findings
- Data Capture Focus: Legitimate data hygiene focuses on prevention at data capture to avoid typos and malicious additions.
- Address Validation: Email verification and hygiene services validate email addresses to identify invalid, inactive, or risky addresses.
- AI-Powered Validation: AI-powered email validation uses machine learning to detect hard bounces, spam traps, and disposable email addresses.
- Removal of Risky Addresses: Cleaning services remove risky addresses, including spam traps, complainers, and litigators.
- Syntax Checking: Syntax checking is performed to remove invalid email formats.
- Duplicate Removal: Cleaning services remove duplicate email addresses.
- Role-Based Address Removal: Role-based email addresses (e.g., sales@, info@) are identified and removed.
- Disposable Email Removal: Disposable and temporary email addresses are removed.
- Hard Bounce Removal: Addresses resulting in hard bounces are removed.
- Parked Domain Removal: Email addresses from parked domains are removed.
- Inactive User Removal: Inactive or unengaged email addresses are removed.
- Questionable Practices: Some services spam your addresses to see which don't bounce, buy bounce data, or use unreliable SMTP methods.
- Honeypots: Honeypots can be used to identify and remove spammers.
Key considerations
- Reliability of Methods: Be wary of services employing unreliable or potentially harmful methods.
- Data Privacy: Consider privacy implications when sharing email lists and using ESP-based data.
- Importance of Prevention: Proactive data hygiene at capture is more effective than reactive cleaning.
- Incomplete Spam Trap Removal: Cleaning services may not remove all spam traps.
- Accuracy Limitations: Some methods have limitations and may produce false positives.
- Service Cost: Balance the cost of cleaning with the benefits of improved deliverability.
What email marketers say
9 marketer opinions
Email database cleaning services employ a variety of methods to remove waste and invalid addresses, enhancing deliverability and engagement. These methods include verifying email syntax, removing duplicates, and identifying/removing risky addresses like spam traps, disposable emails, role-based accounts, parked domains, and inactive users. AI and machine learning are increasingly used to improve the accuracy of these processes.
Key opinions
- Validation: Email cleaning services validate email addresses to identify and remove invalid, inactive, or risky addresses.
- AI/ML: AI-powered email validation uses machine learning to detect hard bounces, spam traps, and disposable email addresses.
- Duplicate Removal: Email cleaning services remove duplicate email addresses from lists to improve deliverability and engagement.
- Role-Based Removal: Email cleaning services identify and remove role-based email addresses to minimize negative impacts.
- Spam Trap Removal: Email cleaning services use proprietary methods to detect and remove spam traps.
- Disposable Email Removal: Email cleaning services identify and remove disposable or temporary email addresses.
- Bounce Rate Reduction: Email cleaning services aim to reduce bounce rates through email verification.
- Parked Domain Removal: Email cleaning services remove addresses from parked domains.
- Inactive User Removal: Email cleaning services remove inactive or unengaged users.
Key considerations
- Proprietary Methods: Spam trap detection and other advanced cleaning techniques often rely on proprietary methods, making it challenging to fully understand the process.
- AI Reliance: The increasing use of AI and machine learning means that the effectiveness of these services may depend on the quality of the AI models used.
- Impact on Engagement: Removing inactive users can improve engagement metrics, but it's important to ensure legitimate, but infrequent, users are not inadvertently removed.
- Service Variety: Different services focus on different aspects of list cleaning, so it's essential to select a service that addresses specific data quality issues.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Clearout shares they remove inactive or unengaged email addresses that are unlikely to convert.
6 May 2023 - Clearout
Marketer view
Email marketer from NeverBounce shares that they remove duplicate email addresses from lists to improve deliverability and engagement.
30 May 2022 - NeverBounce
What the experts say
6 expert opinions
Email database cleaning services employ various methods to remove waste and invalid addresses. Some services use questionable practices like spamming addresses or buying bounce data. More legitimate services emphasize preventative measures at the point of data capture to avoid errors. Honeypots are also identified as a technique to clean email lists. The efficacy of these methods varies, with some being unreliable or imperfect, making it crucial to choose services and strategies carefully.
Key opinions
- Questionable Practices: Some cleaning services engage in practices like spamming addresses to identify those that don't bounce, buying bounce data from ESPs, and SMTP partial transactions.
- Unreliable Methods: Some services abort email transactions after RCPT TO, which is an unreliable method.
- Data Source Imperfection: Buying bounce data from marketers or ESPs is better but imperfect.
- ESP-Run Services: Some services are run by ESPs and use bounce data across customers.
- Prevention is Key: Legitimate data hygiene services focus on preventing errors at data capture.
- Honeypots: Honeypots can also be a method for email list cleaning.
Key considerations
- Method Reliability: Be aware that some methods employed by cleaning services may be unreliable or even harmful.
- Data Privacy: Consider the privacy implications of services that buy bounce data or use data across multiple ESP customers.
- Timing: Focus on preventative measures at the point of data capture for more effective list hygiene.
- Spam Traps: Cleaning services may claim to remove spam traps but may not remove all of them.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that legitimate data hygiene services focus on prevention at the point of capture, helping avoid typos and malicious additions, which is more effective than trying to clean a badly maintained list later.
12 Nov 2023 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource identifies a way to clean an email list which is through Honeypots
24 May 2024 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
Email database cleaning services employ several methods to remove waste and invalid addresses, focusing on both technical validation and risk mitigation. These methods include identifying and removing risky email addresses such as spam traps, complainers, and litigators; performing syntax checking to eliminate invalid formats and typos; verifying the existence and deliverability of email addresses; and removing addresses that have resulted in hard bounces. These steps help improve sender reputation and deliverability.
Key findings
- Risky Address Removal: Email cleaning services identify and remove risky email addresses that could damage sender reputation, including spam traps, complainers, and litigators.
- Syntax Checking: Syntax checking is performed to identify and remove email addresses with invalid formats or typos.
- Email Verification: Email verification services check if an email address exists and is able to receive emails without sending an actual email.
- Hard Bounce Removal: Email addresses that have resulted in a hard bounce are removed.
Key considerations
- False Positives: Email verification services might sometimes incorrectly flag valid addresses as invalid.
- Data Privacy: Consider the implications of sharing email lists with third-party cleaning services.
- Service Cost: Email database cleaning services can incur costs, so it's important to balance the expense with the potential benefits of improved deliverability.
- Accuracy Limitations: While syntax checking is precise, more advanced checks rely on external data and may not always be 100% accurate.
Technical article
Documentation from MailerCheck shares their system removes email addresses that have resulted in a hard bounce, indicating the address is invalid or non-existent.
25 Jan 2024 - MailerCheck
Technical article
Documentation from Hunter.io explains that their email verification service checks if an email address exists and is able to receive emails without sending an actual email.
1 Jan 2024 - Hunter.io
Are email list cleaning services useful for improving email deliverability, and how do they work?
Do email list cleaning services effectively remove spam traps?
How can I accurately verify my email list and identify potentially harmful domains?
How do email list cleaning companies clean millions of emails daily and avoid being blocked?
How do I validate email addresses and maintain a clean email list?
Is constant email verification worthwhile for B2B and B2C, and what platforms are recommended?
What are the best email list cleaning services and practices?
