Summary
Spambots leverage signup forms for a range of malicious activities, far beyond simple spam. Their primary motivations include validating active email addresses to build valuable lists for future attacks, orchestrating 'subscription bombing' campaigns that overwhelm inboxes, and undermining a sender's email reputation. Additionally, these automated threats exploit forms for SEO spam, to test security vulnerabilities, and to disrupt a business's operations and data integrity.
Key findings
- Email Validation and List Building: Bots confirm the validity of email addresses through successful form submissions, creating high-value lists for future spam campaigns, phishing attempts, or sale on dark web markets, fueling further cybercrime.
- Subscription Bombing: A common tactic involves flooding a target's inbox with numerous legitimate-looking subscription confirmations, aiming to cause harassment, hide more serious cybercrimes, or overwhelm the recipient's email system and anti-spam filters.
- Damage to Sender Reputation: Submitting real email addresses, especially known spam traps or inactive accounts, leads to increased bounce rates, higher spam complaints, and ultimately, significant damage to an organization's email deliverability and sender reputation.
- Security Reconnaissance: Bots use signup forms to probe for vulnerabilities, test existing security measures like CAPTCHAs, and gather intelligence on form structures to refine their automated attack strategies against web applications.
- Business Operations Disruption: Beyond email issues, these submissions can inflate lead metrics with junk data, exhaust marketing budgets associated with email sends, and create operational headaches by contaminating databases with irrelevant entries.
- Content Injection and Referral Spam: Spambots can treat forms as content fields to inject malicious links, engage in referral spam to manipulate analytics, or attempt to embed unwanted content into automated confirmation emails sent by the application.
Key considerations
- Robust Bot Protection: Implementing advanced bot detection and prevention tools, such as intelligent CAPTCHAs or behavior analysis, is critical to stop automated submissions at the source and protect your signup forms.
- Email List Hygiene: Regularly cleaning email lists and validating addresses helps prevent hitting spam traps and reduces the impact of bots submitting inactive or compromised emails, safeguarding your sender reputation.
- Monitoring for Abnormal Activity: Companies should actively monitor signup form submissions for unusual patterns, high volumes from single IP addresses, or suspicious data entries to detect bot activity early and mitigate its impact.
- Form Security Audits: Periodic security audits of web forms are essential to identify and patch vulnerabilities that bots could exploit for data injection, reconnaissance, or email manipulation, ensuring form integrity.
- Impact on Analytics and Data: Businesses must recognize that bot submissions can skew lead generation metrics and contaminate CRM or marketing automation databases, requiring proactive strategies for data cleansing and accurate reporting.
What email marketers say
12 marketer opinions
Spambots intentionally submit real email addresses to signup forms as a strategic part of their diverse malicious campaigns. This tactic serves multiple purposes, from validating email existence for more potent phishing and spam operations to overwhelming targets with 'email bombing' attacks. It also aims to compromise a sender's deliverability by triggering spam traps or inflating bounce rates, directly disrupting a business's lead generation efforts, or injecting unwanted content and referral links. These actions can be driven by competitors, the desire to cause harassment, or simply to profit from validated email lists sold on dark web markets.
Key opinions
- Email Address Validation and Monetization: Spambots confirm the legitimacy and activity of email addresses through form submissions, curating valuable lists for subsequent spam, phishing, or sale on dark web marketplaces.
- Subscription Bombing and Harassment: These bots often flood inboxes with a barrage of legitimate-looking subscription confirmations, a tactic used for harassment, to conceal other criminal activities, or to overwhelm a target's email system.
- Damage to Sender Reputation: By submitting real email addresses, especially those that are inactive or known spam traps, bots actively aim to increase bounce rates and spam complaints, severely degrading a sender's email deliverability and reputation.
- Business Operations Disruption: Bots can inflate lead counts with junk data, exhaust marketing budgets tied to email sends, and contaminate databases with irrelevant entries, causing significant operational challenges for businesses.
- SEO Spam and Content Injection: Signup forms are exploited to embed spam links, manipulate analytics through referral spam, or inject malicious and unwanted content into web pages or automated confirmation emails, using real emails to lend an air of legitimacy.
- Competitor Sabotage and Malicious Intent: In some cases, these actions are motivated by competitors seeking to disrupt lead generation, or simply by individuals aiming to cause operational issues for businesses, often for personal gain.
Key considerations
- Enhanced Form Security: It is crucial to implement robust bot detection and prevention mechanisms on all signup forms to stop malicious submissions at the entry point, protecting against the influx of real but unwanted email addresses.
- Proactive Email List Management: Regularly cleaning and validating email lists helps mitigate the impact of bots submitting invalid or spam trap addresses, preserving sender reputation and ensuring legitimate engagement.
- Vigilant Activity Monitoring: Businesses should continuously monitor signup form submissions for unusual patterns, high volumes, or suspicious data to detect and respond to bot activity promptly, especially when real email addresses are being used.
- Safeguarding Data Integrity: Recognizing that bot submissions can skew marketing analytics and pollute customer databases, organizations must establish processes for data cleansing and accurate reporting to maintain reliable insights.
- Understanding Varied Attack Vectors: Marketers and businesses need to be aware that spambot motivations extend beyond simple spam, encompassing data validation, harassment, reputation damage, and content manipulation using real email addresses.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains spambots submitting fake signups might be from competitors, paid by competitors, or for personal gain by causing innocent people and businesses issues.
2 Sep 2022 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains two main reasons for spambots submitting real emails to signup forms: 1) SEO spam bots treating signup forms as comment sections to create spam links for their clients, and 2) Subscription bombing, where criminals use mailing list traffic to overwhelm mailboxes, either to hide other criminal activities or for harassment.
4 Apr 2025 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
2 expert opinions
Spambots intentionally submit genuine email addresses to signup forms as a part of targeted attacks, primarily to execute what is known as 'subscription' or 'list bombing.' The core objective is to inundate a recipient's inbox with a flood of unwanted subscription confirmations and other emails. This tactic effectively renders the inbox unusable, acts as a denial-of-service attack, and often serves as a diversion to obscure more severe security threats, such as attempts to compromise accounts or to hide phishing campaigns. The resulting email overload can prevent victims from identifying crucial legitimate messages or security alerts, causing significant frustration and operational disruption.
Key opinions
- Subscription Bombing Tactic: Spambots employ real email addresses to execute 'subscription bombing' or 'list bombing' campaigns, deliberately flooding a target's inbox with a torrent of unwanted subscription confirmations and other legitimate-looking emails.
- Inbox Overload and DoS: A key objective is to overwhelm the target's inbox, making it unmanageable and effectively unusable. This functions as a denial-of-service attack, preventing the recipient from finding or accessing legitimate messages.
- Obscuring Cyberattacks: The deluge of unwanted emails acts as a strategic diversion, designed to obscure or camouflage more serious security incidents, including attempts to compromise financial accounts or deploy advanced phishing schemes.
- User Frustration and Missed Alerts: This deliberate flooding tactic causes significant user frustration, consumes valuable time, and critically, can lead the recipient to overlook or miss crucial security alerts or important legitimate communications.
- Overwhelming Anti-Spam: The high volume of seemingly legitimate subscription emails can overload the recipient's email service provider's anti-spam filters, potentially reducing their effectiveness and allowing other, more malicious, messages to bypass detection.
Key considerations
- Detecting Bombing Patterns: It is crucial for organizations to implement monitoring systems capable of identifying unusual submission patterns, such as sudden, massive influxes of real email addresses to signup forms, which indicate a subscription bombing attempt.
- Preventing Inbox Overload: Employing measures like intelligent rate limiting on signup forms, advanced CAPTCHAs, and real-time email verification services can help prevent spambots from successfully submitting real email addresses for bombing campaigns.
- Safeguarding User Experience: Preventing subscription bombing directly contributes to a better user experience, safeguarding legitimate subscribers from harassment and ensuring they can receive important communications without their inboxes being overwhelmed.
- Integrated Security Strategy: Understanding that subscription bombing can act as a smokescreen for more severe security incidents necessitates integrating form security measures into a comprehensive cybersecurity strategy to defend against multi-layered attacks.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that spambots submit real emails to signup forms primarily for 'list bombing' or 'subscription bombing.' The purpose is to flood the target's inbox with numerous subscription confirmations and other emails, making it difficult for them to locate legitimate messages. This can also overwhelm the recipient's email service provider's anti-spam filters, potentially hiding more malicious attacks or simply causing significant frustration for the user.
2 Oct 2021 - Spam Resource
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that spambots submit real emails to signup forms as part of a 'subscription bombing' attack. The primary motivation is to overwhelm the target's inbox with an unmanageable volume of emails, rendering it unusable. This tactic can serve as a denial-of-service attack or a diversion to obscure more significant security incidents, like attempts to compromise financial accounts. The flood of unwanted subscriptions can cause the victim to miss crucial security alerts or legitimate communications.
19 May 2024 - Word to the Wise
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
Spambots strategically utilize genuine email addresses when submitting to signup forms for a range of sophisticated malicious purposes beyond mere spamming. This includes orchestrating 'flooding' attacks to overwhelm inboxes and disrupt communications, or exploiting insecure forms as a relay for email injection. Furthermore, these actions are critical for automated reconnaissance, where bots test security defenses, identify vulnerabilities, and gather intelligence on web form structures. The use of real emails also aids in training bot algorithms, allowing them to adapt and become more effective at bypassing security measures like CAPTCHAs, paving the way for future, more advanced attacks.
Key findings
- Flooding Attacks and Disruption: Spambots submit real emails to overwhelm target inboxes with unwanted subscription confirmations or newsletters, effectively disrupting communication and service as part of a 'flooding' attack.
- Email Injection and Spam Relays: Insecure signup forms can be exploited by bots using real email addresses to inject malicious content or additional recipients, leveraging the form as an unwitting spam relay for unwanted messages.
- Automated Reconnaissance: Bots use real email submissions as part of reconnaissance, testing form security measures, identifying vulnerabilities, and assessing their ability to bypass anti-bot defenses like CAPTCHAs for future attacks.
- Profiling Web Forms: Automated bots submit real emails alongside other data to collect and profile the structure of web forms and their data handling mechanisms, gathering intelligence for more sophisticated future attacks.
- Algorithm Training for Evasion: Spambots use real emails in form submissions to train their algorithms, allowing them to refine techniques for bypassing security measures like CAPTCHAs, improving their overall attack effectiveness.
Key considerations
- Implementing Advanced Bot Protection: Businesses must deploy sophisticated bot detection and mitigation solutions to prevent automated submissions of real email addresses, stopping both flooding attacks and reconnaissance attempts at the source.
- Auditing for Injection Vulnerabilities: Regularly audit signup forms for email injection vulnerabilities, as bots can exploit these to use your application as a spam relay, even with legitimate email addresses.
- Monitoring for Reconnaissance: Actively monitor form submission patterns for signs of automated reconnaissance, such as varied data inputs with real emails, indicating bots are testing defenses and gathering intelligence.
- Understanding Bot Evolution: Stay informed about the evolving tactics of spambots, including their use of real data to train algorithms and bypass security measures, which necessitates adaptable defense strategies.
- Securing Data Handling Processes: Ensure that web forms and their backend data handling processes are secure against profiling attempts, preventing bots from gathering structural intelligence for future, more sophisticated attacks.
Technical article
Documentation from Akamai Bot Manager Documentation explains that bots can submit real emails to signup forms as part of a flooding attack, aiming to overwhelm the target's inbox with unwanted subscription confirmations or newsletters, effectively disrupting their communication or service.
15 Aug 2021 - Akamai Bot Manager Documentation
Technical article
Documentation from OWASP Top 10 indicates that insecure signup forms can be exploited by bots through email injection vulnerabilities. While the form itself might not be the source of the email, bots can use real email addresses to inject malicious content or additional recipients into emails sent by the application, effectively leveraging the form as a spam relay.
24 Nov 2024 - OWASP Top 10
How are spammers getting content for their spam emails?
How to protect email list signup forms from bots and subscription bombing?
What are potential reasons for spam or fake email addresses in a marketing email list?
What are the purposes of bots signing up for emails and accounts on websites?
Why am I getting bot signups with domain names in the email address?
Why do people mark wanted emails as spam after signing up?
