Summary
The question of whether your email's origination IP and outbound IP should be identical is common, particularly for those managing their own email infrastructure or using an Email Service Provider (ESP). In most contemporary email setups, especially when leveraging an ESP, these IP addresses are typically not the same, and there's no inherent requirement for them to match. The originating IP refers to the IP address of the device or server that initially created or submitted the email to the first Mail Transfer Agent (MTA) in the sending chain. Conversely, the outbound IP is the IP address of the server that ultimately sends the email to the recipient's Mail Exchange (MX) server. Understanding this distinction is crucial for effective email deliverability and troubleshooting issues like soft bounces or rate limiting.
Key findings
- IP distinction: The origination IP and the outbound IP are distinct and often do not need to be the same, particularly when using an ESP that processes and sends mail on your behalf.
- Role of ESPs: When you use an ESP, your originating IP (your local network or server) sends the email to the ESP's servers, which then use their own outbound IPs to dispatch the email to recipients. This is a standard and expected configuration.
- Deliverability impact: Issues like soft bounces or rate limiting are more likely to be tied to the reputation of your outbound IP address, rather than a mismatch between originating and outbound IPs.
- Header analysis: Email headers can be used to trace the path of an email, revealing both the origination and outbound IPs, which is helpful for troubleshooting.
Key considerations
- Monitor soft bounces: Rather than focusing on IP matching, analyze the specific error messages associated with soft bounces. These provide direct clues regarding rate limiting, reputation issues, or content-related blocks.
- Understand your setup: Familiarize yourself with how your email infrastructure (whether in-house or an ESP) routes emails and what IP addresses are used at each stage of the sending process.
- Focus on reputation: Prioritize maintaining a strong sending IP and domain reputation. This is far more critical for inbox placement than whether the originating and outbound IPs match.
- DNS records: Ensure your SPF and DKIM records are correctly configured to authorize the IPs used by your outbound mail server or ESP.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often find themselves troubleshooting deliverability challenges, leading to investigations into various technical aspects of email sending. Questions about IP addresses, particularly the distinction between originating and outbound IPs, frequently arise when experiencing unexpected issues like soft bounces or sudden drops in delivery rates. Their experiences highlight the practical impact of IP reputation and the complexities of maintaining consistent inbox placement, even with high engagement metrics.
Key opinions
- IP matching is not critical: Many marketers confirm that origination and outbound IPs don't necessarily need to be the same, especially when using an ESP.
- Soft bounce triggers: Sudden increases in soft bounces often lead marketers to investigate potential underlying causes beyond volume changes, such as reputation shifts or recipient server issues.
- Legacy domains: Some marketers face challenges delivering to older domains (e.g., rr.com), which may employ stricter or less predictable filtering mechanisms.
- API sending: When composing emails outside an ESP and pushing them via API, marketers still rely on the ESP's outbound IPs for final delivery.
Key considerations
- Review bounce messages: Detailed bounce messages are crucial for diagnosing deliverability problems, providing insights into rate limits, blocklists, or other rejection reasons.
- Monitor deliverability metrics: Keep a close eye on delivery rates and bounce trends, as even minor fluctuations can indicate an emerging issue with inbox placement.
- IP reputation awareness: Understand that changes in your IP reputation can lead to rate limiting, even if your sending volume remains consistent.
- Engagement vs. deliverability: High open rates are positive, but they do not guarantee perfect deliverability if underlying IP or domain reputation issues exist.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains they compose all their messages outside of SendGrid and then push them to SendGrid through an API, noting a recent increase in soft bounces.
Marketer view
Marketer from Comcast Business Support Community highlights a problem where outgoing mail is consistently rejected by recipient servers because the outbound IP differs from their static IP.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts consistently emphasize that the technical path an email takes, including the IPs involved, is less about matching and more about proper authentication and reputation. They clarify the definitions of originating and outbound IPs and stress that rate limiting is often a sign of declining IP reputation, rather than a simple configuration issue. Their insights underscore the importance of understanding the complex interplay between sending practices, IP reputation, and recipient server policies for consistent inbox delivery.
Key opinions
- IPs don't require matching: Experts confirm that originating and outbound IPs do not need to be the same and frequently differ in modern email setups.
- Header interpretation: While email headers provide IP information, their exact definitions can vary, and what matters most is the outbound IP's reputation.
- Reputation is key: If a sender experiences rate limiting without a volume increase, it's a strong indicator that their IP reputation has declined.
- Bounce analysis: Analyzing the specific details of soft bounces is crucial for diagnosing the root cause of deliverability issues, rather than speculating on IP configuration.
Key considerations
- Monitor reputation proactively: Regularly assess the reputation of your outbound IPs, as this directly influences acceptance by recipient servers.
- Understand ESP routing: Be aware of how your ESP routes and sends emails, and whether they provide dedicated or shared IP addresses.
- Don't fixate on originating IP: The focus should be on the outbound IP's health and proper authentication, not on whether it matches the initial sending point.
- Engage with expert resources: Consult industry experts and resources like Word to the Wise for insights into complex deliverability issues, including nuances of email headers and IP behavior.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that the originating IP is typically the machine that initiated the email, while the outbound IP is the one that actually sends the mail to the recipient's MX server.
Expert view
Expert from Wordtothewise.com indicates that email deliverability is often influenced by factors like IP reputation, which can lead to rate limiting even for stable senders.
What the documentation says
Technical documentation and industry standards provide the foundational knowledge for understanding IP addresses in email sending. They describe how email systems route messages, the importance of DNS records like SPF, and methods for controlling outbound IP addresses. While they outline the technical possibilities, they often implicitly reinforce that the primary concern is not necessarily that originating and outbound IPs match, but rather that the outbound IP is correctly authorized and has a good reputation.
Key findings
- Header information: Email headers, particularly Received headers, document the path an email takes and the IP addresses involved at each hop.
- Outbound IP configuration: Mail servers can be explicitly configured to use a particular IP address for outbound mail, regardless of the originating IP.
- Authentication standards: Standards like SPF (Sender Policy Framework) directly authorize specific outbound IP addresses to send email on behalf of a domain.
- Network security: Organizations often implement IP allowlisting based on static outbound IPs to secure network traffic, including email.
Key considerations
- Align SPF records: Ensure your SPF records correctly list all authorized outbound IPs to prevent authentication failures.
- Internal IP suppression: Review documentation on how to remove internal network IP addresses from outbound email headers for privacy and security.
- Firewall configuration: Properly configure firewalls and network devices to allow necessary email traffic and manage the outbound IP addresses used.
- Dedicated IP usage: If using dedicated IPs, understand that these are exclusively for your use and contribute directly to your sending reputation.
Technical article
Documentation from DuoCircle explains that tracing emails back to their source IP addresses is a key method for identifying and combating fraudulent senders, spam, and phishing attempts.
Technical article
Check Point CheckMates documentation provides a solution for configuring systems to use the same public IP address for both incoming and outgoing traffic, typically through an HA Cluster setup with a Virtual IP (VIP).
Related resources
13 resources
Related pages
What causes unexpected IP addresses to appear on Senderscore for dedicated IPs?
Does a new dedicated IP for transactional emails fix existing deliverability problems?
What is the best practice for reverse DNS resolution when sending email via an ESP?
What are the best practices for email sending domains and IP reputation in business partnerships?
Do transactional emails negatively impact marketing email deliverability, and is it necessary to use separate IP addresses for them?
Why you shouldn't add MailChimp to your SPF record
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
What happens when your ip gets blocklisted?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Boost Email Deliverability Rates: Technical Solutions from Top Performing Senders
