Summary
Warming up a new dedicated IP address while simultaneously managing ongoing email campaigns presents a common challenge for email marketers. The core issue is how to introduce a new IP to Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and build a positive sender reputation without disrupting the delivery of existing, business-critical communications. This often involves navigating the complexities of current Email Service Provider (ESP) capabilities and carefully segmenting your audience. The most effective strategies typically involve a phased approach that ensures continuity of service while meticulously nurturing the new IP's reputation.
Key findings
- IP overlap strategy: The most recommended solution involves maintaining existing email campaigns on your old shared or dedicated IP while simultaneously warming up the new dedicated IP with your most engaged subscribers.
- Engagement-first approach: Starting the warm-up process by sending to your highly engaged users helps establish a strong positive reputation quickly with ISPs, which is crucial for overall email deliverability.
- Gradual volume increase: IP warming is fundamentally about gradually increasing sending volume over time, signaling to ISPs that you are a legitimate sender. For a comprehensive guide on this, refer to this IP Warm Up guide from Twilio SendGrid.
- ESP support: The feasibility of implementing an IP overlap strategy depends heavily on your current ESP's capabilities to manage multiple IP pools or sending domains simultaneously. Many modern ESPs offer features to support this transition.
Key considerations
- Subdomain management: Using a new subdomain for the dedicated IP during the warm-up phase can help isolate its reputation from your primary sending domain. However, be mindful that warming a new subdomain and IP simultaneously can add complexity.
- Domain reputation: While you are warming a new IP, your domain's reputation is equally important. Ensure your core domain (the one in your 'From' address) maintains a strong standing to positively influence the new IP's perception.
- Monitoring: Closely monitor deliverability metrics, including open rates, click-through rates, bounce rates, and spam complaints, for both the old and new sending streams. This data will guide your volume adjustments.
- Transition planning: Develop a clear plan for gradually shifting all traffic from the old IP to the new one once the dedicated IP has established sufficient reputation.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often face the practical dilemma of needing to warm a new dedicated IP without pausing their ongoing, essential email campaigns. Their discussions frequently revolve around pragmatic solutions that balance deliverability goals with business continuity. The consensus points towards strategies that involve carefully segmenting audiences and leveraging ESP features to manage the transition gracefully.
Key opinions
- Phased migration: Many marketers successfully implement a phased migration, where less engaged users continue to receive communications from the established IP, while highly engaged users are gradually moved to the new dedicated IP.
- Dedicated subdomain for warming: Some marketers find it effective to use a distinct subdomain specifically for the new dedicated IP during its warm-up period. This allows for isolated reputation building before full integration.
- Exclusion lists for dual sending: When overlapping old and new IPs, maintaining careful exclusion lists is crucial to prevent recipients from receiving duplicate emails from both sending sources.
- Leveraging engaged segments: Prioritizing the most active subscribers for the new IP warm-up is a widely accepted tactic to demonstrate positive engagement signals to mailbox providers quickly.
Key considerations
- ESP functionality: The ability to execute sophisticated IP warm-up strategies, such as overlapping IPs or using multiple subdomains, is often constrained by the features offered by their current Email Service Provider (ESP).
- Data accuracy: Accurate segmentation of engaged vs. less engaged users is paramount for the success of any warm-up strategy, especially when attempting to mitigate deliverability issues during large sends.
- Strategic planning for campaigns: Careful planning is required to decide which campaigns (e.g., transactional, promotional, newsletter) should be routed through the new IP at each stage of the warm-up.
- Post-warmup management: After the warm-up, marketers need a clear strategy for managing email frequency and volume to maintain the established IP and domain reputation.
- Consulting ESP: It is always advisable to contact your ESP directly to understand their specific recommendations and technical capabilities for IP warming within their infrastructure, as their setup can significantly impact the process.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks notes that maintaining business-as-usual communications for less engaged users, who typically have 10-20% open rates, is critical while warming up a new dedicated IP with highly engaged users (20%+ open rates).
Marketer view
A marketer from Mailchimp explains that dedicated IP addresses must undergo a warm-up process by gradually increasing the volume and frequency of emails sent, emphasizing the importance of this process for email deliverability.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts generally agree on the foundational principles of IP warming, especially when existing campaigns cannot be paused. Their insights often focus on strategic infrastructure utilization, the interplay between IP and domain reputation, and the importance of continuous monitoring. They provide a more technical and strategic perspective on the nuances of managing multiple sending streams.
Key opinions
- Overlap is superior: The consensus among experts is that overlapping the old and new IPs is the optimal approach. This allows less engaged email traffic to continue from the established IP while the new dedicated IP builds its reputation with highly engaged audiences.
- Domain reputation is key: Experts emphasize that maintaining a strong domain reputation is as crucial as IP warming. Even with a new IP, a tarnished domain reputation can hinder deliverability. You can learn more about how to assess this using Google Postmaster Tools via SpamResource.
- Subdomain considerations: While some ESPs might set up new subdomains for new IPs, experts caution that warming a new subdomain alongside a new IP can potentially complicate the process unless meticulously managed.
- Slow transition: Regardless of the specific setup, a slow, methodical transition of sending volume to the new IP is universally recommended to build trust with ISPs.
Key considerations
- Migration complexity: When migrating between ESPs, the complexity of IP warming increases due to differing configurations and the need to ensure consistent email authentication (DMARC, SPF, DKIM) across platforms.
- ISP-specific behavior: Different ISPs (e.g., Gmail, Outlook) have unique filtering algorithms and warm-up expectations. Tailoring your strategy to specific major ISPs can improve results.
- Consistent monitoring: Continuous monitoring of deliverability performance, including inbox placement rates and any blocklist (or blacklist) issues, is critical to identify and address problems early during the warm-up.
- Authentication domain alignment: Experts advise that as long as the authentication domain (the 'd=' tag in DKIM) remains consistent, adding subdomains for dedicated IPs may not significantly impact the core warming process.
Expert view
An expert from Email Geeks explains that the best approach for IP warming is to overlap old and new IPs, specifically sending business-as-usual communications on the old IPs while directing highly engaged traffic to the new ones, transitioning slowly.
Expert view
A deliverability expert from SpamResource states that establishing a good IP reputation requires consistent and positive sending behavior, which is particularly crucial during the initial warm-up phase of a new IP address.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from various email service providers and industry bodies consistently provides guidelines for IP warming, emphasizing systematic and reputation-focused approaches. These documents typically outline specific schedules, volume recommendations, and best practices designed to build and maintain a healthy sender reputation. While specific details may vary, the core principles remain universal.
Key findings
- Phased volume increase: Documentation frequently stresses the importance of starting with very low sending volumes and gradually increasing them over a period, often specified in daily or weekly increments, to allow ISPs to observe and trust the new IP.
- Engaged audience focus: Most guides recommend sending to your most active and engaged subscribers first, as this generates positive signals (opens, clicks) that contribute significantly to a good sender reputation.
- Consistency and frequency: Consistent daily sending (without large, sudden spikes) is advised during the warm-up period to build a reliable sending history and avoid triggering spam filters.
- Monitoring tools: Utilizing ISP-specific postmaster tools and feedback loops is often highlighted as essential for monitoring the new IP's performance, identifying issues, and adjusting the warm-up schedule as needed.
Key considerations
- Adherence to schedules: Following pre-defined IP warm-up schedules provided by your ESP or other authoritative sources is critical to avoid overburdening the new IP and triggering spam filters. You can find out more about warm-up strategies for individual ISPs.
- Content relevance: Documentation often advises sending highly relevant and engaging content during the warm-up phase to ensure high open and click rates and minimize spam complaints or unsubscribes.
- List hygiene: Clean, permission-based email lists are fundamental. Sending to invalid addresses or spam traps can quickly damage the reputation of a new IP. Learn more about spam traps.
- DNS records: Proper configuration of DNS authentication records (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) for the new IP and sending domain is a non-negotiable prerequisite for successful deliverability.
Technical article
Mailchimp's documentation outlines that a dedicated IP requires a careful warm-up process, starting with a low volume of emails and incrementally building up the sending amount and frequency, highlighting this as a crucial step.
Technical article
MassMailer Help Center documentation advises that to manually warm up an IP, senders should gradually increase the volume of emails over their IP address, following a suggested IP warm-up schedule to establish reputation effectively.
Related resources
6 resources
Related pages
What are the best practices for dedicated IP warm-up?
Best practices for email frequency and volume management after IP warming
What are the best strategies for warming email sending IPs by individual ISP?
What causes emails to go to spam when migrating to a new ESP and warming an IP?
How does email reputation transfer during IP warming with a new ESP, and how to resolve deliverability issues?
How to consolidate email sending platforms and warm up a new IP for improved deliverability?
What is the best IP and domain warm-up strategy for Gmail and Microsoft?
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
What happens when your ip gets blocklisted?
