Summary
Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP), introduced with iOS 15, has fundamentally reshaped how email open rates are tracked and interpreted. By automatically preloading images and tracking pixels when an email is received, MPP can make it appear as though an email has been opened, even if the recipient never actually views the message. This automated process leads to inflated open rates, making traditional engagement metrics less reliable. Understanding this shift is crucial for marketers and deliverability professionals aiming to accurately gauge campaign performance and subscriber engagement.
Key findings
- Inflated metrics: MPP automatically triggers tracking pixels by preloading images, leading to artificially higher open rates that do not reflect actual user engagement.
- Lost accuracy: Traditional open rates are no longer a precise indicator of subscriber interest for users on Apple Mail.
- Not universal: While significant, MPP does not result in a 100% open rate for all Apple users.
- Wider impact: Beyond Apple, other email providers and spam filters may also prefetch images, adding to the complexity of open rate measurement.
Key considerations
- Shift focus: Emphasize alternative metrics like clicks, conversions, and replies as truer indicators of engagement. For more on this, see how to accurately measure open rates.
- Segment data: Analyze open rates for Apple Mail users separately from other email clients to gain a clearer picture.
- Trend analysis: Use open rates to monitor long-term trends rather than as a precise measure of individual engagement. Learn how to better deduce inbox placement metrics by using per-ISP open rates.
- Adapt strategies: Adjust your email marketing strategies to account for MPP's impact, as outlined by industry comprehensive guides.
What email marketers say
Email marketers are actively grappling with the implications of Apple Mail Privacy Protection, acknowledging the significant disruption it has caused to traditional open rate metrics. They often discuss the difficulty in distinguishing between genuine subscriber engagement and the automated preloading of emails. This has prompted a collective effort to explore new approaches and metrics for accurately assessing email campaign performance in the current privacy-focused landscape.
Key opinions
- Clarity lost: Marketers frequently express that open rates no longer provide a clear or reliable indication of actual user engagement due to MPP.
- New metrics sought: There's a strong consensus among marketers for the need to find and adopt alternative metrics to accurately measure campaign success.
- Widespread effect: The impact of MPP is recognized as pervasive, affecting a large portion of email opens across various providers.
- Audience segmentation: Many marketers find it crucial to segment their data to understand the distinct behaviors of Apple versus non-Apple audiences.
Key considerations
- Strategic adaptation: Email marketing strategies must evolve beyond a reliance on traditional open rates for performance evaluation.
- Focus on clicks: Marketers are increasingly shifting their focus to click-through rates as a more reliable indicator of active engagement. Learn how to increase email click-through rates.
- Segmentation is vital: Dividing your audience based on their email client provides valuable insights into true engagement, helping to avoid misinterpreting inflated data. Sometimes, your deliverability rate is wrong.
- Embrace new approaches: Experiment with different analytical methods and metrics to adapt to the post-MPP environment, as suggested by leading ESPs.
Marketer view
An Email Marketer from Email Geeks notes that they understand Apple's iOS 15 update marks emails as read if opened on an iPhone, leading to inflated open rates. They are looking for a reliable way to estimate genuine opens, acknowledging that suppressing Apple Mail opens might exclude actual engagement.
Marketer view
A Marketer from Twilio states that Apple's Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) inflates email open data, making it harder for email marketers to gauge how their target audience who have enabled MPP truly engage with their messages. This indicates a challenge in understanding audience behavior and adapting marketing strategies accordingly.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts agree that Apple Mail Privacy Protection has fundamentally changed the landscape of open rate measurement. They stress that while tracking pixels are still triggered, the data no longer represents direct user engagement. Experts advocate for a shift in analytical focus, emphasizing that open rates should now primarily be used for observing broad trends rather than precise individual interactions, and that other engagement metrics are now more crucial.
Key opinions
- No definitive answer: Experts concur that it's impossible to know the exact number of true opens after MPP's introduction.
- Estimates only: Open pixel loads have always provided estimates, not precise figures, a characteristic that remains unchanged by MPP.
- Trend tracking: The primary utility of open rates now lies in observing general trends over time, rather than individual engagement points.
- Inbox placement correlation: Even with MPP, high inbox placement can still correlate with certain (inflated) open rate ranges for Apple domains.
Key considerations
- Holistic view: Experts recommend considering a broader set of engagement metrics beyond just opens for a complete picture of campaign success. This impacts IP warmup strategy and open rate tracking.
- Adjust expectations: New benchmarks are essential for understanding email performance in the post-MPP era, moving away from outdated assumptions. Read how MPP affects tracking email opens.
- Leverage other data: Combine open data with click, conversion, and reply data to form a more accurate and actionable understanding of engagement. Segmentation is key for insights into Apple devices.
- Prioritize deliverability: Ensuring messages reach the inbox remains the most critical factor, regardless of how opens are reported.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks clarifies that marketers will not achieve 100% open rates with Mail Privacy Protection (MPP). This refutes a common misconception and sets realistic expectations for open rate reporting, emphasizing that while inflated, opens are not universal.
Expert view
An Expert from SpamResource highlights that Apple's privacy protection features fundamentally alter how open rates are measured by pre-fetching email content. This means traditional open rate metrics are no longer reliable indicators of user engagement, prompting a need for new measurement strategies.
What the documentation says
Technical documentation and industry guides provide detailed explanations of how Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) functions by preloading email content, including tracking pixels, to safeguard user privacy. This process inherently skews traditional open rate metrics, making it challenging for senders to differentiate between actual user engagement and automated system actions. Understanding these technical nuances is vital for anyone trying to interpret email performance data accurately in the current environment.
Key findings
- Preloading mechanism: MPP downloads email content, including images and pixels, upon receipt, rather than when the user opens the email.
- Tracking pixel activation: This preload action automatically triggers the tracking pixel, falsely recording an open.
- User privacy goal: The core purpose of MPP is to prevent senders from collecting precise data on user activity, enhancing privacy.
- Industry-wide impact: MPP influences how all email platforms and senders must now interpret open rate data, not just those directly on Apple Mail.
Key considerations
- Re-evaluate engagement: Traditional open rates no longer serve as a true measure of user interest due to automatic preloading. This impacts accuracy of client market share data.
- Explore alternatives: Focus on metrics like click-through rates, conversions, and replies that reflect explicit user interaction. Read how MPP and ITP affect click tracking.
- Understand the technicality: A clear grasp of how MPP technically operates is essential for accurate data interpretation and strategy adjustment, as highlighted by industry resources on how to adapt.
- Refined interpretation: Interpret open rate data with a full understanding of its new limitations, recognizing that many reported opens are automated.
Technical article
Documentation from SendGrid explains that Apple's Mail Privacy Protection preloads email images and tracking pixels, which makes it appear as if all emails are opened, even if the recipient never actually views the message. This describes the core mechanism of MPP's impact on open rate metrics.
Technical article
The documentation from Twilio highlights that email open rate, traditionally used to measure recipient engagement, is significantly inflated by Apple's Mail Privacy Protection (MPP). This creates a substantial challenge for senders in accurately gauging audience interaction and campaign effectiveness.
Related resources
10 resources
Related pages
How to accurately measure email open rates without relying on image pixels or clicks?
How to identify artificial email opens and clicks generated by spam filters?
How does Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) affect the tracking of email opens and clicks, and how are machine opens categorized?
How accurate is email client market share data when Apple Mail intentionally opens messages?
How does Apple Mail Privacy impact IP warmup strategy and open rate tracking?
How do AI assistants and MPP impact email open rates, and what are better metrics to measure outbound campaign effectiveness?
Does Apple Mail Privacy Protection pre-fetch images from spam folders or only the inbox?
How do Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) and Intelligent Tracking Prevention (ITP) affect click tracking in email marketing?
Why Your Email Deliverability Rate Is Wrong: Hidden Factors Most Marketers Miss
How to Increase Email Click Through Rate [Step By Step Guide]
