Summary
When commencing an email warmup, a common question arises regarding how to best target mailbox providers (MBPs) across different regions, such as North America (NA), Canada (CA), and Europe, the Middle East, and Africa (EMEA). The consensus among deliverability experts and experienced marketers leans towards a strategy that prioritizes the quality and engagement of your existing email list over attempting to hit specific volume targets for various regional ISPs. Instead of seeking predefined lists of major MBPs by geography, a more effective approach involves analyzing your current recipient data to understand the domain breakdown within your own audience.
Key findings
- Audience-centric approach: Successful warming relies on sending to segments of your existing, opted-in email list. This ensures you are interacting with real, engaged subscribers.
- Gradual volume increase: The core of a warmup is to start with low volumes and gradually increase them over several weeks, allowing mailbox providers to build trust in your sending patterns.
- Engagement is key: Mailbox providers assess your reputation based on how recipients interact with your emails (opens, clicks, replies) and negative signals (complaints, bounces). Targeting highly engaged segments improves these metrics during warmup.
- Data-driven targeting: Instead of generic lists, analyze your own subscriber data to identify the major domains and regions present within your actual audience, then tailor your warmup sends accordingly.
Key considerations
- Avoid generic lists: Sending to made-up accounts or generic domains can harm your sender reputation, leading to poor inbox placement or even being added to an email blacklist or blocklist (also called a blocklist).
- Analyze client's current data: For accurate targeting by domain and region, examine your client's existing email list to determine the actual breakdown of mailbox provider domains. This provides insights into which ISPs are most significant for your specific audience, eliminating the need for generalized regional lists.
- Leverage ESP guidance: Most Email Service Providers (ESPs) offer detailed guides and best practices for IP or domain warm-up. These resources are tailored to their infrastructure and global sending patterns, providing valuable insights specific to your setup.
- Regional variations matter after initial analysis: While major players like Gmail and Yahoo are globally dominant, regional variations (e.g., Comcast in NA versus local providers in EMEA) should be considered only after you have a clear understanding of your own list's composition. For more detailed insights, you can review this article on building a strong email reputation with IP warm-up. Understanding your current list's distribution is crucial for effective IP warmup strategies, and for improving domain reputation.
What email marketers say
Email marketers widely agree that the most effective way to target mailbox providers during a warmup is by leveraging your existing, opted-in email list. The focus should be on sending relevant content to engaged subscribers with gradual volume increases, rather than attempting to artificially target specific ISPs based on assumed regional dominance. Analyzing your actual recipient data provides the most accurate picture of your audience's domain breakdown.
Key opinions
- Use existing opt-in lists: The most common and effective warmup method involves sending to segments of an email list that has already opted in.
- Send slow and low, gradual growth: Start with small volumes and incrementally increase them over several weeks to build a positive sender reputation.
- Focus on engagement: Targeting your most engaged recipients during warmup helps establish good open and click rates, which are crucial positive signals.
- Generic approaches are not effective: Sending generic emails to made-up accounts or trying to manually target specific providers without real list data is generally seen as unproductive and potentially harmful.
Key considerations
- Analyze client's current recipient data for domain breakdown: To identify major mailbox providers, examine your client's existing email list to determine the actual distribution of domains. This will guide your warmup strategy more accurately than generalized regional assumptions.
- Leverage ESP's existing warmup guidance: Your Email Service Provider (ESP) should provide a warm-up guide, as their recommendations are based on their specific infrastructure and network reputation.
- Regional insights are secondary: While regional differences in ISP dominance exist, your primary focus should be your actual list composition. Once you know your list's domain breakdown, you can then consider if any specific regional ISPs require particular attention. This is part of the best practices for warming up an IP address, and critical for understanding your email domain reputation. For further reading, Mailgun provides insights on domain warm-up and reputation.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks notes that warmups generally use segments of an existing opted-in email list. They do not recommend sending generic emails to multiple providers using made-up accounts, as this deviates from standard and effective warm-up parameters.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks confirms that marketers should take a relative sample of their opt-in lists and send slowly, with gradual growth over several weeks. This approach helps build trust with mailbox providers naturally.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts consistently advise that a natural and effective warm-up process focuses on building sender reputation through genuine engagement, rather than attempting to hit arbitrary volume targets for specific mailbox providers in different regions. The key is to leverage your actual subscriber data to inform your sending patterns, prioritizing quality and recipient interaction over broad geographical assumptions. A well-executed warm-up is about trust and consistent positive behavior.
Key opinions
- Warmup is about reputation, not just volume: The primary goal of a warm-up is to establish a positive sender reputation with mailbox providers, not merely to send a certain number of emails.
- Engagement is paramount: Mailbox providers heavily weigh user engagement (opens, clicks) as a signal of a sender's legitimacy and value. High engagement during warmup helps build this trust.
- List quality dictates targeting: The composition of your existing, opted-in email list should determine which domains and, by extension, which regional mailbox providers you naturally target.
- No substitute for real subscriber data: Relying on generic or theoretical breakdowns of regional ISPs is less effective than analyzing your own actual subscriber base.
Key considerations
- Avoid artificial warming techniques: Attempts to rapidly inflate volume or target non-existent addresses will likely lead to spam traps and a damaged reputation, negating the warm-up purpose.
- Monitor performance closely: During warmup, it's crucial to track key deliverability metrics such as inbox placement rates, bounce rates, and complaint rates. This allows for quick adjustments if issues arise.
- Focus on inbox placement metrics: The true measure of a successful warm-up is whether your emails are consistently landing in the inbox, not just that they are being sent. Our guide on warming up an IP address further explains this concept. Additionally, consider why your emails might be going to spam.
- Understanding the client's data is key: To effectively target, analyze the client's existing email list for a breakdown of mailbox provider domains, providing concrete data on which providers are most relevant. For more expert insights, you can often find valuable information on sites like SpamResource.com.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource.com suggests that effective email warm-up is less about hitting specific volume thresholds for each ISP and more about demonstrating consistent, positive sending behavior to a responsive audience. Quality of interaction far outweighs sheer quantity.
Expert view
Expert from WordtotheWise.com advises that focusing on subscriber engagement during the warm-up period, such as opens and clicks, is far more valuable than simply increasing send volume. High engagement signals legitimacy to mailbox providers.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and best practice guides from various sources consistently highlight a data-driven approach to email warm-up. They emphasize that while understanding major global mailbox providers is useful, the actual targeting during warmup should be guided by the composition and engagement of your specific email list. The core principles revolve around gradual volume increases, maintaining high engagement rates, and leveraging your existing recipient data to build trust and reputation, rather than relying on predefined regional ISP lists.
Key findings
- Gradual volume increase is standard: Warm-up processes universally recommend starting with low sending volumes and slowly increasing them over time to establish a positive sending history.
- Maintain good sending practices: This includes ensuring proper email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), minimizing bounce rates, and avoiding spam traps.
- Prioritize engaged recipients: Sending to active subscribers (e.g., those who have opened emails in the last 0-3 months) helps generate positive engagement signals, which are crucial for reputation building.
- Sender reputation is built over time: Mailbox providers learn from your sending behavior. Consistent positive engagement and low complaint rates establish trust.
Key considerations
- Monitor deliverability metrics closely: Regularly check metrics like inbox placement, bounce rates, and spam complaints to adapt your sending strategy. For instance, warming up for Gmail and Microsoft has specific considerations.
- Align warmup with actual list composition: Instead of general regional ISP lists, analyze your own list's domain breakdown to determine your actual sending targets. This is especially true when considering best practices for Yahoo and Microsoft.
- Ensure email authentication is in place: Properly configured SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are fundamental for any warm-up strategy, as they verify your sender identity.
- Understand domain/IP boundaries: Knowing the limitations and best practices for your specific sending infrastructure (e.g., dedicated IP versus shared IP) is crucial for a successful warm-up. Bloomreach provides a comprehensive email warm-up process guide.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailgun states that senders should recommend targeting their most engaged recipients during the warm-up process to ensure strong open and click rates. This approach helps to quickly establish a positive sender reputation with mailbox providers.
Technical article
Documentation from Bloomreach emphasizes that learning how to warm up an email domain or IP is crucial to boost deliverability, avoid spam filters, and build sender reputation effectively. They outline a systematic process for achieving this.
Related resources
9 resources
Related pages
What is the best IP warmup strategy for email sending?
What are the best practices and schedules for warming up an IP address for email sending?
What is the best IP and domain warm-up strategy for Gmail and Microsoft?
What are the best practices for warming up new email domains with Yahoo and Microsoft?
What is the best approach for warming up an IP address for email sending?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Boost Email Deliverability Rates: Technical Solutions from Top Performing Senders
How to Improve Domain Reputation Using Google Postmaster Tools [2025 Guide]
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
What is a good strategy for aggressively warming a new email domain?
