Summary
Using a custom sending domain is highly recommended and, in most cases, worth the investment of money and effort. While some email service providers (ESPs) offer out-of-the-box solutions with their own auto-generated subdomains, having your own domain for sending emails provides significant long-term benefits for your email deliverability, brand reputation, and overall control. This approach ensures that your sending reputation is tied directly to your brand, rather than being shared with other users on an ESP's shared domain, which can carry inherent risks.
Key findings
- Reputation control: A custom domain gives you full control over your sending reputation. When using an ESP's shared domain, your deliverability can be negatively impacted by the poor sending practices of other users on that same domain, a common issue for email marketers.
- DMARC requirement: Implementing DMARC, a crucial email authentication protocol, requires the use of a custom sending domain. DMARC ensures alignment between your sending domain and your authenticated domains, helping to prevent phishing and spoofing. You can find more information about DMARC, SPF, and DKIM in our guides.
- Professionalism and trust: Emails sent from a custom domain (e.g., yourcompany.com) appear more credible and trustworthy to recipients than those from a shared domain (e.g., espservice.com). This can positively influence open rates and engagement.
- Gmail via tag: Using a custom domain with proper DMARC alignment helps avoid the via tag that sometimes appears next to the sender's name in Gmail, enhancing perceived legitimacy.
Key considerations
- Initial setup: Setting up a custom sending domain involves configuring DNS records like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. This process requires some technical knowledge, but most ESPs provide detailed instructions. Ensuring these are correctly set up is fundamental for email authentication.
- Cost: Purchasing a custom domain is generally inexpensive, with annual costs typically ranging from $10-20. The return on investment in terms of deliverability and brand reputation usually outweighs this minimal expense.
- Portability: Owning your sending domain provides flexibility. Should you decide to switch email service providers, you can seamlessly migrate your domain and its established sending reputation, avoiding disruption to your email program.
- Subdomain strategy: Consider using subdomains for different email streams (e.g., marketing.yourcompany.com, transactional.yourcompany.com). This isolates the reputation of each stream. Learn more about why use subdomains for email marketing deliverability.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often weigh the immediate convenience of using an ESP's default sending domain against the long-term strategic advantages of a custom domain. Many recognize that while ESP-provided domains can get you started quickly, the benefits of brand control, enhanced deliverability, and the ability to implement advanced authentication far outweigh the initial setup effort and minimal cost of a custom domain. The consensus among marketers is that a custom sending domain is a strategic asset for any serious email program.
Key opinions
- Control over destiny: Marketers frequently emphasize that using your own domain means you are the master of your own fate, particularly concerning your email deliverability and sender reputation. This independence is highly valued.
- Shared reputation risks: A common concern is the risk associated with shared IP addresses and domains. If other senders on a shared IP (or domain) exhibit poor sending practices, it can degrade the reputation of everyone on that shared resource, impacting your inbox placement.
- Branding and professionalism: Marketers consistently point to increased professionalism and brand recognition as key benefits. A custom domain reinforces your brand identity and builds trust with subscribers.
- Portability for growth: The ability to transfer your established sending domain reputation when switching ESPs is a significant advantage, ensuring continuity and avoiding the need to rebuild trust from scratch.
Key considerations
- Deliverability impact: While shared domains might offer a temporary boost from others' good reputation, consistently good sending practices on a custom domain will typically yield better long-term deliverability. Understanding how email sending practices impact domain reputation is crucial.
- From address importance: Using the ESP's domain in the 5322.from address (the visible sender) is generally discouraged due to potential deliverability and branding issues.
- ESP policies: Some ESPs restrict the use of generic sender domains like yahoo.com or gmail.com in the 'From' field, automatically replacing them to ensure better deliverability for their clients.
- The via issue in Gmail: The appearance of via alongside your sender name in Gmail can undermine trust and professionalism. This is typically resolved when your domain in the From header aligns with the authenticated domain, which is a key benefit of a custom sending domain. More details on setting up a custom domain can be found on Mutant Mail's blog.
Marketer view
An email marketer from Email Geeks explains that the more shared header lines you have with other senders, the more you share reputation. If your campaigns are not performing well, a shared solution can be beneficial as you leverage others' established reputation. However, if your own sending practices are excellent, a shared domain might actually drag your reputation down to a collective average. This dynamic means the perceived benefit of a shared domain is highly variable, depending on your individual sending quality versus the collective quality of other users.
Marketer view
A marketer from Intercom advises that using your own domain is crucial because sharing a domain with other customers means you're constantly at risk of poor deliverability if any other sender on that shared domain makes a mistake. This shared environment means you lack complete control over your email's journey. By sending from your own domain, you become the master of your deliverability fate, gaining independence. Furthermore, a custom domain allows you to easily transition between email providers without significant disruption, a flexibility not afforded by an ESP's proprietary domain.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts consistently advocate for the use of custom sending domains due to their critical role in authentication, reputation management, and overall inbox placement. They highlight that beyond immediate deliverability benefits, custom domains are fundamental for implementing advanced security protocols like DMARC. This technical control not only improves the chances of emails reaching the inbox but also protects against brand abuse and enhances recipient trust, aligning with evolving email ecosystem requirements.
Key opinions
- DMARC necessity: Experts firmly state that custom sending domains are essential for deploying DMARC. Without a custom domain, a sender cannot fully implement DMARC, missing out on crucial email authentication and reporting capabilities. Learn more about whether DMARC is required for mail sending domains.
- Avoiding ESP domain issues: Using an ESP's domain in the 5322.from header (the visible sender address) is strongly discouraged due to various deliverability and branding complications. Authenticating email with your own domain provides superior control.
- DMARC-style alignment: Many webmail providers are increasingly examining DMARC-style alignment between the From header domain and the authenticated domains (SPF/DKIM) even if a DMARC record isn't explicitly published. This makes custom domains crucial for consistent deliverability.
- General best practice: Experts universally recommend custom domains for all senders, regardless of whether there's an immediate, clear deliverability bonus. The benefits extend beyond direct inbox placement to long-term brand integrity and security.
Key considerations
- Domain reputation isolation: A dedicated sending domain ensures that your email reputation is distinct and not influenced by the sending practices of other clients using the same ESP. This isolation is critical for maintaining consistent deliverability, especially for high-volume senders.
- Brand credibility: Using a custom domain builds trust and professionalism, aligning your email communications directly with your brand. This reinforces authenticity, which is a key factor in avoiding spam folders and increasing recipient engagement.
- Long-term strategy: While shared domains can offer quick setup, a custom domain represents a more robust and sustainable long-term email strategy. It provides a stable foundation for your email program, independent of changes or issues with your ESP's shared infrastructure.
- Adaptability: Owning your sending domain provides flexibility in adapting to new email authentication standards or migrating between ESPs without impacting your established sender reputation. Kickbox's blog offers further insights into sending domain selection.
Expert view
An expert from Email Geeks, Steve, states that custom sending domains are an absolute requirement if you intend to deploy DMARC. DMARC relies on the alignment of the From header domain with either the SPF or DKIM authenticated domain. This alignment is only possible when you control the domain that appears in the From address, making a custom domain non-negotiable for DMARC implementation.
Expert view
Email deliverability expert Steve shares that he strongly dislikes the practice of using an ESP's domain in the 5322.from header. While technically feasible, he emphasizes that this approach introduces a myriad of consequences and potential problems for email deliverability. These issues often relate to brand identity, recipient trust, and the inability to fully control the email's authentication and reputation.
What the documentation says
Technical documentation and industry standards consistently underscore the importance of custom sending domains for robust email deliverability and security. They emphasize that proper domain alignment, typically achieved through SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records associated with a custom domain, is paramount for mailbox providers to trust incoming mail. This alignment helps in distinguishing legitimate mail from spoofed or fraudulent messages, directly impacting inbox placement and protecting sender reputation. Documentation often outlines the configurations necessary to achieve these standards, highlighting custom domains as a foundational element.
Key findings
- Authentication standards: Official email authentication standards like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are designed to work optimally with custom domains, ensuring the sender's identity can be verified by receiving mail servers.
- Domain alignment: DMARC explicitly requires alignment between the From header domain and the domains authenticated by SPF and DKIM. This is almost impossible to achieve without a custom domain.
- Trust and reputation building: Mailbox providers rely heavily on domain reputation. A custom domain allows a sender to build and maintain a consistent, positive reputation over time, leading to better inbox placement rates.
- Anti-spoofing and anti-phishing: Custom domains, combined with proper authentication, are crucial tools in preventing email spoofing and phishing attacks, protecting both the sender's brand and recipients.
Key considerations
- DNS configuration: Implementing a custom sending domain involves adding specific DNS records (TXT, CNAME) to your domain's DNS zone. This technical step is critical for proper authentication and ensuring emails are recognized as legitimate.
- Subdomain recommendation: Documentation often advises using a dedicated subdomain for email sending to isolate email reputation from your main website's domain reputation, minimizing risk if email issues arise.
- Ongoing monitoring: Even with a custom domain, continuous monitoring of DMARC reports and sender reputation is necessary to identify and resolve any deliverability issues promptly. This proactive approach helps maintain a healthy sending domain.
- Evolution of standards: Email authentication standards and mailbox provider requirements are constantly evolving. Owning and managing your custom domain provides the agility to adapt to these changes more easily than relying on a shared ESP domain. GoDaddy's resources often highlight the importance of professional email with a custom domain.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailjet highlights that a custom domain is fundamental for building a professional and trustworthy email presence. It explains that the domain used in your email address is the first thing recipients often see, significantly impacting their perception of your legitimacy. This visual indicator helps establish brand recognition and encourages recipients to open and engage with your messages, rather than dismissing them as generic or potentially suspicious.
Technical article
Kickbox documentation discusses how the choice of your sending domain or subdomain directly affects email deliverability. It emphasizes that a dedicated domain allows for granular control over your sender reputation, which is a critical factor for inbox placement. This contrasts with shared domains, where the actions of other senders can impact your own deliverability, regardless of your sending practices.
Related resources
12 resources
Related pages
Should I authenticate email with my own domain or an ESP's domain?
Why use subdomains for email marketing deliverability?
What are the best practices for choosing an email sending domain?
Is DMARC required for mail sending domains?
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
Why your emails are going to spam in 2024 and how to fix it
Boost email deliverability rates: technical solutions from top performing senders
Google Postmaster Tools domain reputation: the ultimate guide for email marketers
How to fix personal emails going to spam from a custom domain?
