Summary
Website registration, by itself, does not automatically grant permission for email marketing subscriptions, nor is it considered a best practice. While regulations like the U.S. CAN-SPAM Act focus more on opt-out mechanisms rather than upfront consent, global privacy laws, notably Europe's GDPR, strictly mandate explicit, unambiguous, and informed consent for marketing communications. Leading email service providers and industry experts uniformly advise against assuming consent from registration alone. This approach not only risks legal non-compliance, particularly under GDPR, but also severely impairs email deliverability, increases spam complaints, damages sender reputation, and leads to disengaged subscriber lists.
Key findings
- No Automatic Consent: Website registration alone does not automatically grant permission for email marketing subscriptions; explicit, separate consent is required by best practices and many legal frameworks. Leading Email Service Providers (ESPs) and industry experts consistently state that merely creating an account or logging in does not constitute valid permission for marketing emails, even if transactional emails related to account activity are acceptable. This distinction is crucial for maintaining a healthy email program and avoiding issues related to compliance and deliverability, as users expect transactional emails related to their account but not unsolicited marketing messages. The consensus among email marketing professionals and platform documentation is that a user's action of registering for a website should not be conflated with an agreement to receive promotional content. Instead, a clear and distinct act of consent, such as checking a specific box for marketing updates, is necessary to establish permission. This separation ensures that marketing communications are only sent to individuals who have genuinely expressed an interest in receiving them, fostering a more engaged and responsive subscriber base. Failing to obtain such explicit consent can lead to negative user experiences and consequences for the sender, including an increased likelihood of being marked as spam, which directly impacts deliverability. It is a fundamental principle of permission-based email marketing to ensure that every subscriber has actively chosen to be on your list for promotional content, thereby building a foundation of trust and respect with your audience, which is essential for long-term success in email marketing and for safeguarding your sender reputation.
Key considerations
- Explicit Opt-in: Always implement a clear, separate, and unchecked opt-in checkbox for marketing emails during the registration or checkout process to ensure users willingly consent to receive communications from you. This is crucial for building a quality list and avoiding deliverability issues, as well as for legal compliance globally, especially under GDPR, where consent must be unambiguous and freely given. Hiding consent within privacy policies is considered both rude to the user and legally insufficient for true permission. Users should be able to clearly understand what they are consenting to and for what purpose, distinguishing between transactional emails and marketing messages. This practice ensures your subscribers genuinely wish to receive your content, leading to higher engagement rates and a more valuable subscriber list. Providing a clear option for users to opt into marketing communications, rather than assuming consent, respects user privacy and builds trust. It is the foundation for a healthy email program, fostering better engagement and improving your sender reputation over time, as it signals to Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and Email Service Providers (ESPs) that your list is permission-based and valued by its recipients. Additionally, consider incorporating double opt-in or confirmation steps, such as sending a confirmation email or requiring a code, to further verify email ownership and reduce the risk of spamming incorrect addresses or collecting bot sign-ups, which also contribute to list quality and deliverability.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
Reinforcing the consensus among email marketing experts and regulatory bodies, website registration does not inherently grant permission for marketing email subscriptions, nor is it considered an acceptable or effective practice. While transactional emails directly related to user accounts are generally permissible, any promotional content requires a distinct, explicit opt-in. This separation is crucial, not only for adhering to stringent global privacy regulations like GDPR, which demand clear and unambiguous consent, but also for fostering a healthy sender reputation and ensuring high email deliverability, as unauthorized marketing emails frequently result in increased spam complaints and subscriber disengagement.
Key opinions
- No Implied Consent: The overwhelming consensus from email marketing professionals and regulatory guidelines is that website registration or account creation does not automatically imply consent for receiving marketing emails. While necessary transactional communications, such as password resets or order confirmations, are generally permissible, any promotional or marketing content strictly requires a separate, explicit opt-in. This distinction is paramount, as confusing account activity with marketing permission can lead to legal complications and severely negative impacts on email program performance, including higher spam complaint rates and diminished sender reputation. Industry leaders and privacy laws worldwide emphasize that consent for marketing must be a clear, affirmative action from the user, not a byproduct of another activity like signing up for a service.
Key considerations
- Negative Deliverability Impact: Relying on implied consent from website registration for marketing emails is widely recognized as a detrimental practice that significantly jeopardizes email deliverability and sender reputation. This approach often leads to high unsubscribe rates and an increased volume of spam complaints, signaling to Internet Service Providers (ISPs) that your emails are unwelcome. Such negative signals can result in your emails being filtered into spam folders or blocked entirely, undermining the effectiveness of your entire email marketing strategy. To mitigate these risks and build a robust, engaged subscriber list, it is imperative to implement clear, separate opt-in mechanisms, such as an unchecked checkbox specifically for marketing communications, during the registration process. This ensures that every subscriber genuinely wishes to receive your content, fostering higher engagement, better deliverability, and a healthier sender reputation over time.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that creating an account does not constitute newsletter consent.
4 Jul 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that creating a login does not grant permission for marketing emails. Sending genuinely transactional email is reasonable, but anything else requires more informed permission. He adds that even transactional mail assumes the user owns the email address, which needs to be considered.
25 Apr 2023 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
Email marketing experts are in agreement: merely signing up for a website account does not automatically equate to permission for marketing email subscriptions, nor is this approach considered a beneficial or recommended practice. This consensus underscores that explicit consent is crucial, not implied. Attempting to hide consent within a privacy policy is seen as disrespectful to users and legally insufficient for true permission. Such methods not only diminish user trust but also pose substantial risks to email deliverability, leading to higher spam complaints and the potential for sending messages to invalid addresses.
Key opinions
- Explicit Consent is Essential: Website registration on its own does not provide implicit permission for marketing emails. Industry experts uniformly assert that explicit, affirmative consent, distinct from the registration process, is a mandatory best practice to ensure compliance and maintain optimal email deliverability.
- Hidden Consent is Harmful: Concealing email subscription consent within privacy policies or terms of service is considered rude to the user and does not constitute genuine permission. This practice can erode trust, increase spam complaints, and negatively impact sender reputation, rather than building a valuable, engaged subscriber list.
- Risk of Invalid Addresses: A significant risk associated with assuming consent from website registration is the potential for accumulating incorrect or invalid email addresses. Without explicit opt-in and verification, senders are more likely to target non-existent or disengaged recipients, which directly harms deliverability rates and wastes marketing resources.
Key considerations
- Implement Clear Opt-in: For best practice, always use a clear, separate, and typically unchecked opt-in mechanism, such as a dedicated checkbox, specifically for marketing communications during the website registration or account creation process. This ensures users knowingly and willingly consent to receive emails, which is fundamental for both compliance and deliverability.
- Verify Subscriptions: To enhance list quality and prevent sending to incorrect email addresses, consider implementing subscription confirmation processes, such as double opt-in where users click a link in a confirmation email, or requiring a code to verify their email address. This step significantly reduces the risk of spamming and improves deliverability, as it verifies genuine interest and email ownership.
- Promote Preference Management: Integrate account and subscription preferences as a prominent part of the user's initial interaction with the site. Offering clear options for users to manage their communication preferences from the outset, rather than after registration, fosters a transparent and user-friendly experience, leading to higher satisfaction and engagement.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that hiding email consent within a privacy policy is rude to the user and does not constitute actual permission. She states it is a bad, though common, practice. She also highlights the risk of spamming incorrect email addresses. For best practice, she suggests confirming subscriptions, such as by having users check their email for a code to enter, and incorporating account and subscription preferences as part of the site introduction.
5 Jun 2025 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that website registration alone does not automatically grant permission for email subscriptions. Explicit opt-in, such as a clear checkbox, is required and is the best practice to avoid deliverability issues.
20 Aug 2022 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
Website registration does not automatically confer permission for email marketing subscriptions, nor is this considered a best practice by industry experts or regulatory bodies. While the U.S. CAN-SPAM Act focuses on providing clear opt-out options for commercial emails, global privacy frameworks like GDPR require explicit, affirmative consent that is distinct from account creation. Major email service providers, reflecting industry standards, also mandate clear opt-ins. This distinction is critical for maintaining legal compliance, especially internationally, and for fostering a healthy sender reputation and optimal email deliverability.
Key findings
- Varying Consent Standards: While the U.S. CAN-SPAM Act allows for initial commercial emails with an easy opt-out, global regulations such as GDPR strictly demand explicit, specific, and unambiguous consent for marketing, which website registration alone does not fulfill.
- ESPs Uphold Explicit Opt-in: Leading Email Service Providers like Mailchimp enforce policies requiring clear, separate opt-in for marketing communications, indicating that mere website registration is insufficient for adding users to promotional lists.
- Legal Insufficiency: Under GDPR and similar frameworks, consent obtained solely through website registration, without a distinct affirmative action for marketing, is legally invalid, exposing senders to compliance risks and potential penalties.
Key considerations
- Prioritize Explicit Consent: Always implement a clear, separate, and typically unchecked opt-in option specifically for marketing communications during the website registration process to ensure genuine, informed consent from users.
- Adhere to Stricter Laws: When managing email lists, especially for international audiences, always default to the stricter consent requirements of global privacy laws like GDPR, rather than assuming implied consent from registration.
- Impact on Deliverability: Understand that assuming marketing consent from website registration can significantly harm your sender reputation and deliverability rates due to increased spam complaints and lower engagement, making explicit opt-in crucial for long-term success.
Technical article
Documentation from FTC.gov explains that while the CAN-SPAM Act does not require an explicit opt-in for commercial emails, it does mandate clear identification, an easy unsubscribe mechanism, and a truthful header. It doesn't automatically grant permission for unsolicited marketing emails based solely on website registration, emphasizing that the focus is on allowing recipients to opt-out, rather than requiring upfront consent like GDPR.
15 Feb 2025 - FTC.gov
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp Knowledge Base clarifies that merely registering for a website account does not automatically grant permission to send marketing emails. Mailchimp's policy, aligned with industry best practices and global privacy laws like GDPR, requires explicit consent, typically obtained via a clear opt-in checkbox, before adding someone to a marketing list.
15 Nov 2022 - Mailchimp Knowledge Base
Is COI/DOI email opt-in still a relevant best practice?
Is it a common practice to request extra info like captcha when unsubscribing from email lists?
Is requiring a login to unsubscribe compliant with email regulations?
Is requiring a login to unsubscribe from emails legal?
Should email marketing opt-in buttons be checked by default?
Should Shopify checkout opt-in boxes for email marketing be pre-checked for GDPR and deliverability?
