Summary
Under the CAN-SPAM Act, welcome series emails almost always require an unsubscribe link if their primary purpose is commercial. This includes messages designed to introduce products, services, special offers, or even to simply build brand awareness with a marketing objective. The critical distinction lies in the 'primary purpose test': if an email promotes or advertises, it is commercial and must offer a clear, conspicuous way for recipients to opt out of future communications. Purely transactional welcome emails, such as a confirmation that an account has been created without any additional marketing content, are generally exempt. Email Service Providers largely adhere to this interpretation, often requiring an opt-out mechanism for any content not strictly defined as transactional, further underscoring the importance of including unsubscribe links in most welcome series.
Key findings
- Primary Purpose Rule: The core determinant for requiring an unsubscribe link under CAN-SPAM is whether a welcome email's 'primary purpose' is commercial or transactional. Most welcome series emails fall into the commercial category.
- Commercial Equals Unsubscribe: If a welcome email contains any promotional content, introduces products or services, offers discounts, or aims to foster brand engagement with a marketing objective, it is considered commercial and legally requires an unsubscribe link.
- Transactional Exemption: Welcome emails that are strictly transactional, such as pure account activation notices, password resets, or order confirmations without any marketing material, are exempt from the unsubscribe link requirement.
- ESP Requirements: Many Email Service Providers align with CAN-SPAM's interpretation, often mandating an opt-out link for any welcome series email that isn't purely transactional, reinforcing the need for compliance.
- Beyond the Link: Some experts highlight that requests for unsubscribes can signal broader issues with email content or subscriber expectations, encouraging marketers to evaluate their welcome series strategy if opt-out rates are concerning.
Key considerations
- Content Audit: Thoroughly review each email in your welcome series to determine its primary purpose. If it contains any promotional elements, special offers, or aims to build a relationship with a sales-oriented goal, it should be treated as commercial.
- Default to Compliance: When uncertain about the classification of a welcome email, it is always safer and recommended to include a clear and conspicuous unsubscribe link to ensure full CAN-SPAM compliance.
- Holistic Compliance: Remember that CAN-SPAM also requires a physical postal address in commercial emails. While the focus here is on unsubscribe links, maintaining overall compliance is crucial for deliverability.
- User Experience: Ensure the unsubscribe process is straightforward, easily found, and functions promptly, as mandated by law. A positive off-boarding experience can prevent spam complaints.
- Performance Insights: Track unsubscribe rates within your welcome series. High rates might indicate issues with content relevance, audience targeting, or expectation setting, rather than just the presence of the unsubscribe button itself.
What email marketers say
9 marketer opinions
When assessing welcome series emails for CAN-SPAM compliance, the inclusion of an unsubscribe link hinges on the email's predominant objective. If a welcome message, even one simply introducing a brand, includes any promotional content, offers, or aims to drive engagement with a marketing goal, it is classified as a commercial email. This designation immediately triggers the legal requirement for a clear, functional unsubscribe mechanism. Conversely, only purely transactional welcome emails-such as a simple account activation or subscription confirmation devoid of marketing elements-may be exempt from this rule. The general consensus among industry experts and the common practices of Email Service Providers underscore that most welcome series, by their very nature of onboarding and relationship-building, typically fall under the commercial umbrella and therefore mandate an opt-out option.
Key opinions
- Primary Purpose is Key: The fundamental distinction for unsubscribe link necessity under CAN-SPAM lies in a welcome email's primary purpose, differentiating between commercial and purely transactional messages.
- Promotional Content Mandates Opt-Out: Any welcome email containing elements like product introductions, special offers, or brand-building efforts with a marketing intent is deemed commercial and legally requires an unsubscribe link.
- Strict Transactional Emails Are Exempt: Only welcome emails that are exclusively transactional, such as basic account setup confirmations or service alerts without any marketing, might be exempt from the unsubscribe requirement.
- ESPs Reinforce Compliance: Many Email Service Providers adopt a conservative approach, often requiring an unsubscribe link for any welcome series email that is not strictly defined as transactional, reinforcing the broad application of the rule.
- Subtle Marketing Triggers Requirement: Even seemingly innocuous content that aims to introduce or promote, rather than merely confirm, can classify a welcome email as commercial, necessitating the unsubscribe option.
Key considerations
- Content Scrutiny: Carefully evaluate every email within your welcome series for any hint of promotional material, special offers, or attempts to guide future purchases, as these elements designate it as commercial.
- Prioritize Opt-Out Inclusion: When in doubt about whether a welcome email is purely transactional or has a commercial aspect, it is safest and recommended practice to include a visible and working unsubscribe link.
- CAN-SPAM's Full Scope: Remember that beyond the unsubscribe mechanism, the CAN-SPAM Act also mandates the inclusion of a valid physical postal address in all commercial emails, ensuring comprehensive compliance.
- Clear Unsubscribe Process: Design a simple, intuitive, and immediate unsubscribe process for recipients. This not only meets legal requirements but also improves user experience and minimizes spam complaints.
- Monitor Unsubscribe Rates: Analyze unsubscribe trends within your welcome series. Higher than expected rates might signal a need to adjust content relevance, audience targeting, or the initial subscriber expectations set.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains that the interpretation of "transactional" versus "marketing" emails can also depend on the Email Service Provider (ESP), as many systems require an opt-out link for anything not strictly defined as transactional.
4 Jul 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Marketer from HubSpot Blog explains that generally, if a welcome email contains any promotional content, it's considered a commercial email under CAN-SPAM and must have an unsubscribe link. The primary purpose test determines if an email is commercial or transactional.
7 Nov 2021 - HubSpot Blog
What the experts say
5 expert opinions
The necessity of including an unsubscribe link in welcome series emails is a common question, and the answer hinges on the email's predominant objective as defined by the CAN-SPAM Act. If a welcome message serves any commercial or promotional purpose, such as introducing products, services, or brand value, it is legally obligated to provide a clear and conspicuous opt-out mechanism. This applies even if the marketing content is subtle. Only welcome emails that are strictly transactional, like an account activation confirmation without any additional marketing content, may be exempt. Industry experts and Email Service Providers consistently advise that most welcome series, by their very nature of onboarding and engaging new subscribers, fall under the commercial classification, thus requiring an accessible unsubscribe option.
Key opinions
- Commercial Purpose Dictates: The primary purpose of a welcome email determines its CAN-SPAM classification; if it's commercial or promotional, an unsubscribe link is legally required.
- Any Marketing Triggers: Even subtle marketing or brand-building content in a welcome email classifies it as commercial, mandating the inclusion of an unsubscribe link.
- Purely Transactional Exception: Only welcome emails that are strictly informational, like account setup confirmations devoid of any marketing, may be exempt from the unsubscribe requirement.
- Broader Compliance View: Commercial emails, including those in a welcome series, must also include a physical postal address to comply with CAN-SPAM, despite deliverability focus often being on the unsubscribe link.
- Unsubscribe Signals Issues: High unsubscribe rates may indicate that the email content itself is not meeting subscriber expectations or is irrelevant, rather than the mere presence of the unsubscribe button being the issue.
Key considerations
- Content Primary Purpose Check: Thoroughly review each welcome email's content to identify its primary purpose. If there's any promotional intent, treat it as commercial and include an unsubscribe link.
- Always Include When Unsure: When there's any ambiguity regarding an email's classification, always default to including a clear and visible unsubscribe link to ensure full legal compliance.
- CAN-SPAM Holistic View: Remember that CAN-SPAM compliance extends beyond unsubscribe links; a valid physical postal address is also mandatory for all commercial welcome emails.
- Streamlined Opt-Out: Ensure the unsubscribe process is easy, immediate, and straightforward for the user. A positive opt-out experience helps maintain sender reputation and reduce spam complaints.
- Analyze Unsubscribe Data: Regularly monitor unsubscribe rates in your welcome series as they can provide valuable feedback on the relevance and effectiveness of your onboarding content.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that every commercial email needs an unsubscribe link unless it's strictly transactional, as defined by CAN-SPAM. She elaborates on what constitutes transactional content versus commercial content based on primary purpose. She also states that all commercial emails are required to have a physical postal address, though she notes it can be a gray area and FTC prosecution is unlikely, but it's a bad idea to omit it.
28 Jan 2023 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks shares insight into the motivation behind requests to remove unsubscribe links, suggesting that if people are unsubscribing, it indicates a problem with the email content, not the unsubscribe button itself.
4 Apr 2022 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
6 technical articles
For welcome series emails, the inclusion of an unsubscribe link is largely dictated by the CAN-SPAM Act, which mandates this for any message deemed 'commercial.' If a welcome email includes promotional content, introduces products or services, offers discounts, or aims to build brand engagement with a marketing purpose, it falls under the commercial category and therefore must provide a clear and easy-to-find opt-out mechanism. The exemption for transactional emails is quite narrow, applying only to messages like direct account confirmations or shipping updates that contain no marketing material whatsoever. Industry experts and Email Service Providers consistently advise that the vast majority of welcome series emails, by their nature of engaging and onboarding new subscribers, carry a commercial intent and must consequently include an unsubscribe option.
Key findings
- Commercial Content Triggers Requirement: Under CAN-SPAM, welcome series emails must include an unsubscribe link if they contain any commercial content, such as promoting products, services, or special offers, regardless of how subtle the promotion is.
- Broad Definition of Commercial: Many welcome emails, even those focused on brand building or relationship nurturing, are considered commercial if they aim to engage subscribers with a marketing objective, necessitating an opt-out.
- Transactional Exemption is Strict: Only purely transactional welcome emails-like an order confirmation or account activation without any marketing messages-are exempt from the unsubscribe link requirement.
- ESPs Mandate Compliance: Leading Email Service Providers generally align with this interpretation, often requiring an unsubscribe mechanism for any welcome series email that is not strictly defined as transactional, reinforcing the regulatory expectation.
- Beyond Pure Confirmation: Any welcome email that moves beyond mere confirmation or information-delivery to engage with a recipient commercially requires a clear and conspicuous way to opt out.
Key considerations
- Content Review: Carefully examine each email in your welcome series for any commercial or promotional elements, even subtle ones. If such content is present, treat the email as commercial and include an unsubscribe link.
- Default to Including Link: If there is any uncertainty about whether a welcome email qualifies as purely transactional or has a commercial intent, it is always the safest and most recommended practice to include a clear and functional unsubscribe link.
- CAN-SPAM's Full Scope: Beyond the unsubscribe mechanism, remember that the CAN-SPAM Act also requires all commercial emails to include a valid physical postal address for comprehensive compliance.
- Streamlined Opt-Out: Ensure that the unsubscribe process is straightforward, easy to find, and allows recipients to opt out promptly, as mandated by law. An efficient process enhances user experience and helps prevent spam complaints.
- Monitor Unsubscribe Metrics: Regularly track unsubscribe rates for your welcome series. Elevated rates can provide valuable insights into potential issues with content relevance, audience targeting, or initial subscriber expectations.
Technical article
Documentation from FTC.gov explains that under CAN-SPAM, all commercial email messages must include a clear and conspicuous way for recipients to opt out of getting future email from you. Welcome series emails, if they contain commercial content (e.g., promoting products/services), are considered commercial and thus require an unsubscribe link. Transactional emails, however, are exempt.
30 Oct 2023 - FTC.gov
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp Knowledge Base clarifies that all marketing emails, including welcome emails that promote products or services, are subject to CAN-SPAM and must include an unsubscribe link. Transactional emails, like order confirmations, are exempt.
1 Dec 2022 - Mailchimp Knowledge Base
Do subscription based emails require a list unsubscribe option according to Gmail and Yahoo's new sending requirements?
Is it bad for email deliverability to not have an unsubscribe link?
Is requiring a login to unsubscribe compliant with email regulations?
Is the one-click unsubscribe / list-unsubscribe header a requirement for marketing emails?
What are the requirements for one-click unsubscribe in email marketing?
When are automated sales emails considered marketing under CAN-SPAM and require an unsubscribe link?
