Summary
The consensus on the effectiveness and legality of email warm-up tools like Warmy.io is complex and nuanced. While some marketers and documentation suggest potential benefits for new domains or IPs in improving sender reputation and deliverability, a significant portion of experts and marketers strongly advise against them. Concerns include potential legal violations related to unsubscribe options, manipulation of mailbox provider reputation systems, short-term effectiveness, and the lack of a substitute for genuine engagement and quality email practices. Documentation generally emphasizes gradual IP warming with proper authentication and wanted mail. The overall takeaway is that while some tools may offer short-term benefits, building a strong sender reputation through ethical practices is paramount.
Key findings
- Effectiveness Debated: Opinions diverge on the effectiveness of email warm-up tools, with some seeing benefits for new domains and others dismissing them as scams.
- Legality Questionable: Some tools may violate legal requirements regarding unsubscribe options and physical addresses.
- Manipulation Concerns: Mailbox providers actively discourage attempts to manipulate reputation systems through fake engagement.
- Short-Term Gains: Any positive impact from warm-up tools is often short-lived and negated by subsequent sending practices.
- Manual Warming Preferred: Documentation advocates for gradual IP warming with proper authentication and engagement.
- Alternative use case: Tools can sometimes be used in legitimate limited form to kickstart a new domain that incorrectly started in the spam folder
Key considerations
- Prioritize Ethical Practices: Focus on building a strong sender reputation through legitimate and ethical email practices.
- Compliance is Key: Ensure full compliance with relevant email marketing laws and regulations.
- Authentication Essential: Implement robust email authentication protocols to improve deliverability.
- Engage Subscribers: Prioritize sending wanted content to engaged subscribers to build trust with ISPs.
- Avoid Shortcuts: Recognize that there are no shortcuts to building a good sender reputation; it requires consistent effort and ethical behavior.
- Assess Use Case: Carefully assess if the use case of using the tool is simply to jumpstart a new domain out of the spam folder, however be aware of the other risks.
What email marketers say
19 marketer opinions
The effectiveness and legality of email warm-up tools like Warmy.io are debated. While some marketers acknowledge their usefulness in improving sender reputation and deliverability, especially for new domains or IPs, others strongly advise against them. Concerns include the potential violation of federal laws due to missing unsubscribe options and physical addresses, the use of fake engagement tactics that mailbox providers frown upon, and the limited long-term impact on reputation. The general consensus leans towards caution, emphasizing that these tools should not replace genuine engagement, quality email practices, and building a healthy email list. Manual warming and gradually increasing sending volume are often recommended alternatives. Some highlight that the possible limited legitimate use would be to kickstart a domain that incorrectly started in the spam folder.
Key opinions
- Effectiveness Varies: Email warm-up tools may improve sender reputation and deliverability, particularly for new domains or IPs.
- Legality Concerns: Some tools might violate federal laws by omitting unsubscribe options and physical addresses in emails.
- Fake Engagement: Mailbox providers dislike attempts to manipulate reputation platforms through fake engagement.
- Short-Term Impact: The positive effects of warm-up tools often diminish quickly once regular sending volumes resume.
- Not a Substitute: Warm-up tools should not replace genuine engagement, quality content, and opt-in subscribers.
- Limited legitimate use: Can sometimes be used in legitimate limited form to kickstart a new domain that incorrectly started in the spam folder
Key considerations
- List Quality: Prioritize building a high-quality email list with engaged, opted-in subscribers.
- Manual Warming: Consider manual warming strategies by gradually increasing sending volume and monitoring deliverability.
- Legal Compliance: Ensure that all email practices comply with relevant laws and regulations, including providing unsubscribe options and physical addresses.
- Alternative: Carefully assess if the use case of using the tool is simply to jumpstart a new domain out of the spam folder, however be aware of the other risks.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Mailtrap states that warming up a new IP address means building an email sending reputation so your mail reaches inboxes instead of spam folders. You will need to prove to mailbox providers that you’re a responsible sender and your emails are wanted.
28 Mar 2024 - Mailtrap
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains that most warming tools, especially those sending through individual's Gmail accounts, may violate federal law because they send mailing list emails without unsubscribe options or a physical address.
16 Feb 2022 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
The expert opinions on the effectiveness and legality of email warm-up tools like Warmy.io are mixed, with a strong undercurrent of caution. Some experts outright dismiss such tools as scams and highlight the negative impact of attempting to manipulate mailbox provider reputation systems through fake engagement. Others emphasize the importance of legitimate IP warming strategies, which involve gradually building a positive sender reputation over time by sending wanted mail, using proper authentication, and carefully managing sending volumes.
Key opinions
- Negative Perception: Some experts view email warm-up tools as scams.
- Reputation Manipulation: Mailbox providers frown upon attempts to fake engagement and manipulate reputation.
- Gradual Warming: Legitimate IP warming involves building reputation gradually over time.
- Authentication Matters: Proper email authentication is crucial for deliverability.
- Wanted Mail: Sending emails that recipients want is key to building a positive reputation.
Key considerations
- Avoid Manipulation: Refrain from using tactics that attempt to manipulate mailbox provider reputation systems.
- Authenticate Email: Implement proper email authentication protocols to improve deliverability.
- Focus on Engagement: Prioritize sending wanted mail to build a positive sender reputation.
- Manage Volume: Carefully manage sending volumes, starting low and gradually increasing over time.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks simply says "#snakeoil #scam" in response to the question about Warmy.io.
25 Nov 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that IP warming is about building a reputation over time and shares a schedule. They mention that the volume should start low and increase over time and they must have proper authentication and be sending wanted mail.
9 Dec 2024 - Word to the Wise
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
Email service provider documentation consistently emphasizes that warming up an IP address is essential for achieving high deliverability. This process involves gradually increasing sending volume from a dedicated IP to build a positive sender reputation with ISPs and ESPs. Key strategies include sending wanted mail to engaged subscribers, avoiding spam traps, establishing a consistent sending history, and monitoring deliverability rates.
Key findings
- Gradual Volume Increase: IP warming involves gradually increasing sending volume over time.
- Reputation Building: The goal is to build a positive sender reputation with ISPs and ESPs.
- Engaged Subscribers: Emails should be sent to engaged subscribers who want to receive them.
- Avoid Spam Traps: It's crucial to avoid sending emails to spam traps, which can negatively impact reputation.
- Monitor Deliverability: Regularly monitor deliverability rates to identify and address any issues.
Key considerations
- Start Small: Begin with a small sending volume and gradually increase it.
- Consistent History: Establish a consistent sending history to build trust with ISPs.
- Legitimate Sender: Demonstrate that you are a legitimate sender by sending wanted mail.
- Reputation Impact: Understand that IP reputation is a key factor in determining email deliverability.
Technical article
Documentation from SparkPost explains that maintaining a good IP address reputation is critical for high deliverability. ISPs use IP reputation as a key factor in determining whether to accept or reject incoming emails, so warming is crucial.
5 Dec 2021 - SparkPost
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft highlights the importance of warming up new IPs before sending large volumes of email. They recommend starting with small volumes and gradually increasing them over time, while monitoring deliverability rates to identify any issues.
20 May 2025 - Microsoft
Are AI email warmup tools effective for cold outreach, and what are the potential drawbacks?
Are auto warming/deliverability improvement services for email marketing sketchy?
Are domain warmup tools like Lemwarm or WarmupInbox effective and safe to use?
Are IP warming services effective for improving email deliverability?
Are spam trigger words, PDF attachments, and links bad for email warm-up and deliverability?
Can I perform IP warming with single image emails?
Can I skip a day during email warm up without hurting my IP reputation?
How can I automate IP warmup in Iterable?
