Summary
Domain warmup tools like Lemwarm and WarmupInbox aim to improve email deliverability by simulating engagement and building sender reputation. While some users report ease of use and deliverability improvements, others warn that mailbox providers may detect such practices as inauthentic, leading to negative consequences. Experts emphasize that the warm-up process is an introductory step, not a permanent solution, and must be supported by a robust email program with good data acquisition, content targeting, and consistent sending practices. Essential technical aspects include email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), using seedlists, monitoring deliverability metrics, and gradual increases in sending volume. Key recommendations include focusing on quality content, clean email lists, proper email authentication, and avoiding automation that simulates engagement.
Key findings
- Mixed Opinions: Experiences with domain warmup tools vary; some find them effective, while others see limited or negative impact.
- Authenticity Concerns: Mailbox providers may penalize simulated engagement, affecting domain reputation.
- Gradual Warmup is Key: Slowly increasing email volume and frequency is crucial to establishing a positive sending reputation.
- Authentication is Essential: Proper setup of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC is necessary for legitimate email programs and preventing abuse.
- Data and Content Quality: High-quality content and clean data are vital and tools will not solve those problems.
Key considerations
- Address Root Causes: Identify and fix underlying deliverability issues (data, content, targeting).
- Comprehensive Strategy: Domain warming should be part of a holistic deliverability strategy, not a standalone fix.
- Prioritize Genuine Engagement: Focus on creating engaging content and building genuine relationships with subscribers.
- Monitor and Adjust: Continuously monitor deliverability metrics and adapt strategies based on performance.
- Long Term is Important: Ensure the senders reputation will work well beyond the tool.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
Domain warmup tools like Lemwarm and WarmupInbox aim to improve email deliverability by simulating engagement and building sender reputation. While some users report ease of use and deliverability improvements, others warn that mailbox providers may detect such practices as inauthentic, leading to negative consequences. Experts emphasize the importance of addressing underlying deliverability issues such as poor data acquisition and content targeting, rather than relying solely on warmup tools. Effective IP/domain warming also involves gradual increases in sending volume and proper email authentication setup.
Key opinions
- Mixed effectiveness: Some users find domain warmup tools effective for improving deliverability and maintaining sender reputation, while others see them as providing only a temporary boost.
- Potential risks: Mailbox providers may detect and penalize simulated engagement, resulting in a negative impact on domain reputation.
- Importance of good practices: Focusing on quality content, clean email lists, and proper email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) is crucial for long-term deliverability.
- Gradual warming: Warming up involves gradually increasing sending volume over time to establish a positive sending reputation.
Key considerations
- Root cause analysis: Identify and address the underlying causes of deliverability issues, such as poor data quality or unengaging content.
- Long-term strategy: Domain warming should be part of a broader deliverability strategy that includes best practices for email marketing.
- Authenticity: Prioritize genuine engagement over artificial methods to avoid penalties from mailbox providers.
- Monitoring: Continuously monitor deliverability metrics and adjust strategies as needed.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks shares that if you use a service like this we will a) most likely spot the gaming going on and shut it down and b) your domain reputation will take a major hit. So chances are you will achieve quite the opposite of what you were trying to achieve …
9 Jan 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks shares that domain warming tools are sketchy, and mailbox providers will eventually catch up to anything you are trying to fake - be it spoofed email headers or be it fake engagement. They believe the only way it could work is a very temporary boost in reputation.
29 Sep 2024 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
Experts highlight that domain and IP warming is about establishing initial recognition with email systems, not creating a permanent reputation. Warming up practices must be coupled with good overall email practices. Essential aspects include email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) and monitoring deliverability through seedlists.
Key opinions
- Introductory Process: Domain warm-up introduces you to email systems, but doesn't create a lasting reputation.
- Email Authentication: Proper setup of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC is crucial alongside IP warming.
- Monitoring Deliverability: Using seedlists and tracking deliverability metrics is important during IP/Domain warming.
Key considerations
- Sustainable Reputation: Ensure your own email stream is strong enough to maintain reputation after the warm-up period.
- Abuse Prevention: Email authentication helps prevent abuse and demonstrates legitimate email practices.
- ESP Considerations: Pay close attention to warming strategies when using a new or unknown Email Service Provider.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that domain warm up is about introducing yourself to a system. It’s not “do this to develop a reputation and that reputation is now permanent”. If your own mail stream isn’t good enough to create a reputation then when you stop using the warmup system your own reputation needs to develop.
30 Aug 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource shares that using seedlists and tracking your deliverability metrics with them is an important step in IP/Domain warming up, especially if you are using a new or unknown Email Service Provider.
13 Jan 2023 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
Email providers like Google, Microsoft, SparkPost, and Sendgrid emphasize the importance of gradually warming up new IP addresses to establish a positive sending reputation. This involves slowly increasing email volume and prioritizing the sending of legitimate, valuable emails that recipients want. They advise against using automated tools to simulate engagement, as this can damage sender reputation.
Key findings
- Gradual Warm-up: Slowly increasing email volume is crucial for establishing a positive sending reputation.
- Valuable Content: Sending legitimate, valuable emails that recipients want is essential for building a good sender reputation.
- Avoid Automation: Automated tools that simulate engagement can damage sender reputation.
Key considerations
- Deliverability Monitoring: Continuously monitor deliverability rates during the warm-up process.
- Engagement Metrics: Base volume increases on engagement and deliverability metrics.
- Legitimate Sending Practices: Prioritize sending genuine emails that recipients find valuable.
Technical article
Documentation from Google explains that warming up a new IP address gradually is important to establish a positive sending reputation with Gmail. This involves slowly increasing the volume of emails sent over time and monitoring deliverability rates.
7 Oct 2023 - Google Workspace Admin Help
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft states that building a good sender reputation requires consistently sending legitimate, valuable emails that recipients want to receive. They advise against using automated tools to simulate engagement, as this can damage sender reputation.
12 Jan 2022 - Microsoft
Are AI email warmup tools effective for cold outreach, and what are the potential drawbacks?
Are auto warming/deliverability improvement services for email marketing sketchy?
Are email warm-up tools like Warmy.io effective and legal?
Are IP warming services effective for improving email deliverability?
How can I automate IP warmup in Iterable?
How can I intentionally deliver emails to the spam folder?
How can I intentionally send a newsletter to the spam folder?
How do I warm up a new IP address for transactional emails?
