Summary
When your SendGrid IP address is blocked by Proofpoint, it typically signals a reputation issue. This challenge is common for email service providers (ESPs) that manage shared or recycled IPs, where prior sending behavior can impact current users. While a dedicated IP offers more control, its reputation still needs careful nurturing and monitoring. Addressing such blocks requires direct engagement with Proofpoint and a robust understanding of email authentication standards like DMARC, even if DMARC doesn't directly influence IP blocklisting.
Key findings
- IP reputation issues: Proofpoint blocks often stem from negative IP reputation, which can be a challenge even with a dedicated IP from a major ESP like SendGrid, as these IPs might have been previously used.
- ESP reputation fluctuations: The overall reputation of an ESP (like SendGrid) can decline over time due to various factors, including acquisitions or changes in their user base's sending practices.
- Direct communication for delisting: The most effective way to resolve a Proofpoint blocklist is often through direct communication with their support or postmaster team, although response times can vary.
- DMARC's role: While essential for email authentication and domain reputation, DMARC does not directly influence IP blocklisting by services like Proofpoint, especially for rejections occurring before the mail content is processed.
Key considerations
- Proactive ESP evaluation: Always research an ESP's current deliverability performance and IP reputation before committing to their services. Consult with industry peers or deliverability consultants for accurate assessments. This can help prevent your IP from being blacklisted prematurely.
- Understanding block reasons: Identify the specific reason for the block, such as an IP blocklist, content filtering, or authentication failure. This will guide your remediation efforts. For more on this, see how to contact Proofpoint about IP blocks.
- Persistence in delisting: If initial delisting requests receive no response, consider following up or seeking assistance from a deliverability expert who may have direct contacts with the blocklist operator. SendGrid also offers guidance on what to do if your email messages are blocked.
- IP warming: Even with a new dedicated IP, a proper IP warming strategy is crucial to build a positive reputation with ISPs, including Proofpoint, especially for B2B sends. Learn how to warm up your IP address.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often face challenges with IP blocks, even when using reputable ESPs like SendGrid. They highlight that a dedicated IP, while seemingly new, might come with a pre-existing negative reputation from previous users. Many also express concerns about the accuracy of ESPs' internal reputation scoring and emphasize the importance of external verification and proactive reputation management. The consensus is that deliverability issues, especially with corporate filters like Proofpoint, often require a multi-faceted approach beyond just technical setup.
Key opinions
- Pre-used IP baggage: Even a 'unique' dedicated IP from an ESP can carry a history of prior negative use, leading to immediate blocklist issues.
- Inaccurate ESP reporting: Marketers frequently find that SendGrid's internal reputation calculations and reporting tools do not always align with real-world deliverability challenges, especially concerning external blocklists.
- ESP reputation critical: The overall reputation of an ESP is crucial, and it's vital to assess this before migrating, as reputation can significantly degrade, especially after acquisitions.
- Delisting process frustration: Many marketers experience a lack of responsiveness from blocklist operators like Proofpoint when attempting to delist IPs via their public channels.
Key considerations
- External reputation checks: Don't rely solely on your ESP's internal reports; use external tools and expert consultations to verify your sending reputation, including specific IP blocklists. This can help you better understand what happens when your IP gets blocklisted.
- DMARC implementation benefits: While not a direct fix for IP blocklists, implementing DMARC is generally seen as a positive step for overall email authentication and domain health, which indirectly supports deliverability. Refer to a simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
- Escalation paths: If standard delisting procedures fail, explore alternative avenues, such as reaching out to network engineers or deliverability consultants who might have direct contacts within organizations like Proofpoint to expedite resolution. Some senders even look to email HSBC as a test, as discussed on Mail-in-a-Box forum.
- Ongoing monitoring: Continuous monitoring of IP and domain reputation is essential to quickly identify and address new blocklist issues. Be prepared to address issues beyond initial setup. This includes understanding how Proofpoint affects webmail deliverability.
Marketer view
A marketer from Email Geeks suggests that a seemingly unique IP from a sending service might still carry a prior negative reputation, indicating it has been used before and comes with existing 'baggage'.
Marketer view
A marketer from HackMD states that to resolve an IP block with Proofpoint, direct engagement through support tickets or whitelist requests for the specific IP is often necessary.
What the experts say
Deliverability experts provide critical insights into IP and domain reputation, distinguishing between various types of identities and how reputation is attributed. They emphasize that while technical authentication standards like DMARC are crucial for overall domain health, they are often irrelevant to direct IP blocklists that occur at an earlier stage of the SMTP conversation. Experts also highlight the evolving nature of ESP reputations and the importance of direct intervention or established relationships with blocklist operators for swift delisting.
Key opinions
- Reputation is identity-based: Both DMARC (domain) and IP addresses are identities to which reputation (a judgment) is applied. Consistent sending of good mail from an IP is key to improving its standing.
- DMARC's limited role in IP blocks: DMARC is generally considered irrelevant to IP blocklisting, especially for rejections that occur before the DATA command in the SMTP transaction.
- ESP reputation changes: The quality and reputation of ESPs are not static and can change significantly over time, affecting client deliverability.
- Expedited delisting: Direct or internal contacts with a blocklist operator can significantly speed up the delisting process for a blocked IP.
Key considerations
- Focus on IP behavior: If an IP is blocklisted, the primary focus should be on the sending behavior and reputation associated with that specific IP, rather than solely on domain-level authentication. This helps clarify why dedicated IPs get blocked.
- DMARC's general utility: Despite not directly resolving IP blocks, having DMARC in place with proper alignment is always beneficial for overall email security and deliverability. It's a critical component in boosting email deliverability rates.
- Forwarding and DMARC: Be aware that DMARC can negatively impact deliverability if receiving systems break authentication during email forwarding, leading to delivery failures for legitimate emails. This is a nuanced aspect of safely transitioning DMARC policies.
- Understanding rejection points: Differentiate between rejections that occur early in the SMTP conversation (likely IP-related) versus later ones (potentially content or authentication-related), as this dictates the troubleshooting path. For more on Proofpoint's behavior, see Proofpoint's policies on SPF hard fail.
Expert view
An expert from Email Geeks explains that ESP quality and reputation can change over time, and noted that Proofpoint blocklists are distinct from those of other providers like Cloudmark, indicating internal channels might be needed for faster delisting.
Expert view
An expert from SpamResource suggests that if an IP is blocklisted, the issue is typically with the IP itself or the sending activity from it, rather than issues with authentication protocols like SPF or DKIM which are related to domain alignment.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from various email service providers and security companies often clarifies the reasons for email blocks, which typically include IP blocklisting, content filtering, or authentication failures. While some documentation focuses on broader deliverability strategies like DMARC, SPF, and DKIM, specific IP block resolutions usually involve direct interaction with the blocking entity. It's often highlighted that even smaller blocklists can impact deliverability, and persistent issues may require comprehensive reputation building.
Key findings
- Block reasons: Email messages are primarily blocked if the sending IP is on a deny list, or if the ISP or messaging organization has directly blocked the mail server IP.
- Delisting requests: Submitting a delisting request is the top priority when an IP address is blocked by legitimate services like Proofpoint.
- Authentication standards: Implementing SPF, DKIM, and DMARC is crucial for authenticating senders and preventing spoofing, which indirectly contributes to better sender reputation.
- Impact of smaller blocklists: Even inclusion on smaller blocklists can affect overall deliverability, although major blocklists have a more significant impact.
Key considerations
- Content compliance: Ensure your email content complies with best practices to avoid triggering spam filters, which can lead to IP reputation issues and blocklisting. This is often a reason why your emails are going to spam.
- Proactive monitoring: Regularly monitor your sending IP(s) and domain(s) on various blocklists to quickly identify and address any listings. Suped offers blocklist monitoring.
- Authentication configuration: Verify that your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correctly configured and aligned to establish strong sender identity, even if it's not a direct fix for IP blocklisting. SendGrid's support notes the importance of mastering email deliverability.
- Engage with ISPs: Directly engage with ISPs and messaging organizations if you find your IP blocked. They often have specific procedures for delisting and may offer insights into the block reason.
Technical article
Documentation from SendGrid states that blocked emails occur when your IP address has been added to a blacklist or has been blocked by an ISP or messaging organization, underscoring the direct impact of IP reputation.
Technical article
Documentation from SendGrid's Deliverability Guide indicates that if your sending IP(s) are blocklisted, the first step is to check if the blocklist caused message rejection, noting that smaller blocklists might not severely impact overall deliverability.
Related resources
15 resources
Related pages
How to contact proofpoint about IP blocks and understand dynamic block behavior?
Is proofpoint commonly used for corporate email, and how does it affect webmail deliverability issues like blacklisting?
How to get Proofpoint to unblock my IP address?
Why are my emails being blocked by Apple Mail and Proofpoint?
How should I warm up my IP address for B2B email sends to avoid Proofpoint blocks?
An in-depth guide to email blocklists
A simple guide to DMARC, SPF, and DKIM
Why is my IP address blacklisted when sending email, and how can I fix it?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Boost Email Deliverability Rates: Technical Solutions from Top Performing Senders
