Summary
Seeing signups or abandoned carts from the storebotmail.joonix.net domain can be concerning, especially when associated with generic names like "John Smith." This activity typically indicates automated visits to your website, most commonly by Google's specialized bots, which are performing legitimate functions like price checks for Google Shopping or indexing product information. While it might seem like bot spam, these are generally not malicious in the traditional sense, but they can still inflate your signup metrics or analytics if not properly managed. Understanding the nature of these visits is key to deciding whether to block them or simply filter them from your reporting.
Key findings
- Google's purpose: The storebotmail.joonix.net domain is associated with Google LLC. Its primary function is for Google to perform price checks and verify product information on e-commerce sites listed in Google Shopping or Merchant Center.
- Not malicious: Unlike spam bots that aim to abuse systems or send unwanted mail, these Google bots are generally benign, performing necessary data verification for Google's services.
- Common occurrence: Many businesses integrated with Google Shopping experience these automated signups or abandoned carts. It is a known behavior of Google's systems.
- Inflated metrics: While not harmful, these entries can skew your analytics for new signups or abandoned carts, making it difficult to assess true customer engagement or identify potential leads. Learn more about inflated ESP reporting due to bot activity.
- Domain ownership: Although MarkMonitor might appear in WHOIS records, they are primarily a domain registrar, not the ultimate owner. The domain joonix.net is indeed owned by Google LLC, confirming its legitimate origin.
Key considerations
- Blocking vs. suppression: While you can block these signups, a more nuanced approach might be to suppress them from your email lists and reporting. Directly blocking Google's activity could potentially impact your visibility in Google Shopping or search results. Consider how to prevent bot signups effectively.
- Data accuracy: If you rely heavily on Google Shopping, allowing these bots to operate may be necessary for maintaining accurate product listings and pricing. Suppressing them from your customer-facing data or marketing lists is crucial for data integrity.
- Email deliverability: Sending emails to these bot-generated addresses will likely result in bounces or low engagement, which can negatively affect your sender reputation. It's best to filter them out of your sending lists. Read more about email deliverability issues.
- Monitoring: Regularly monitor your signup sources and analyze patterns. If you see high volumes of joonix.net addresses, consider implementing rules in your CRM or ESP to exclude them from marketing communications. For Shopify users, consider reviewing solutions like those discussed on the Primy Blog for Shopify spam prevention.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter various types of bot activity, including these 'John Smith' signups from domains like storebotmail.joonix.net. Their experiences highlight the need to differentiate between malicious spam bots and benign automated processes, particularly when these processes originate from platforms like Google. The consensus often leans towards managing these entries rather than outright blocking them, to ensure proper data hygiene without disrupting legitimate integrations.
Key opinions
- Familiar problem: Many marketers recognize the 'John Smith' pattern and have encountered various bot-driven signups, making the joonix.net activity a familiar albeit new variant.
- Monitoring list growth: For smaller accounts, these bot signups, even if benign, can disproportionately impact list growth metrics. Marketers value the real-time visibility into such activity for understanding unexpected list changes.
- Blocking vs. managing: The immediate reaction might be to block, but the preference often shifts to suppressing these addresses from email communication to maintain data cleanliness without affecting legitimate platform integrations.
- Email deliverability impact: Marketers are acutely aware that sending emails to bot-generated addresses can harm sender reputation due to high bounce rates or low engagement. Therefore, filtering them out of active mailing lists is critical for improving deliverability.
Key considerations
- Filtering strategy: It's important to implement robust filtering mechanisms within your marketing automation platform or CRM to identify and segment these bot signups, preventing them from entering your active subscriber lists. This helps prevent issues like strange newsletter signups.
- Impact on metrics: Marketers should be mindful of how bot traffic, even from benign sources, can distort key performance indicators related to signups, conversion rates, and email engagement.
- User experience: While these bots are not customers, ensuring they do not trigger unwanted follow-up emails (like abandoned cart reminders) helps maintain a clean system and reduces unnecessary email volume.
- Prevention measures: For other types of bot activity, marketers can explore methods such as CAPTCHAs, honeypots, or IP blacklisting to mitigate unwanted signups. The WordPress.org forums, for instance, discuss ways to exclude Google Storebot from recovery emails.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks notes that encountering 'John Smith' signups, even from new domains like joonix.net, is a recurring phenomenon. They find it particularly insightful for monitoring list growth in smaller accounts because anomalies are more easily detectable. This helps in understanding the true rate of organic list expansion versus automated additions.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Primy Blog recommends implementing a CAPTCHA at checkout to prevent fake customer accounts and spam orders. They emphasize that while some bots might seem harmless, they can still disrupt analytics and potentially lead to unwanted emails being sent, thus affecting overall data quality and deliverability.
What the experts say
Experts in email deliverability and anti-abuse generally concur that the storebotmail.joonix.net domain originates from Google, specifically for price checking and data verification purposes related to their shopping services. They advise against outright blocking, as this could impact legitimate data flows from Google. Instead, managing these entries by suppressing them from marketing communications and filtering them from reporting is the recommended approach to maintain data accuracy and email deliverability.
Key opinions
- Google's ownership: Experts confirm that the joonix.net domain is indeed owned by Google LLC, indicating its legitimate, albeit automated, origin. This provides a clear understanding of the source of the traffic.
- Price verification: The primary function of these bots is to conduct price checks for Google Shopping, ensuring that listed prices on e-commerce sites align with those in Google's index. This is a critical process for merchants using Google's services.
- Suppression over blocking: A common expert recommendation is to suppress these entries from email lists and reporting rather than blocking them entirely. Blocking could disrupt Google's ability to verify data, potentially affecting a merchant's visibility.
- Data impact: Even benign bot traffic can distort analytics and provide misleading metrics. Experts stress the importance of distinguishing between legitimate customer interactions and automated system checks to maintain accurate data. This aligns with why it is important to understand the purposes of bots signing up.
Key considerations
- Maintain Google integration: If your business relies on Google Shopping, allowing these bots to access your site is crucial for accurate product indexing and price validation, which directly affects your presence on the platform.
- Analytics hygiene: Implement robust segmentation and filtering rules within your analytics and email marketing platforms to exclude these bot entries. This ensures your performance metrics reflect genuine human engagement, especially for how bot signups impact deliverability.
- Resource allocation: While harmless, a high volume of bot traffic can consume server resources. Ensure your infrastructure can handle the load, or adjust crawling frequency if possible without affecting Google's data collection.
- Stay informed: Keep abreast of updates from Google regarding their bot activities and best practices for webmasters. Consulting resources like the Wall Street Journal on mystery shoppers can also provide context on similar automated behaviors.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks clarifies that MarkMonitor, while appearing in WHOIS, is likely just an expensive domain registrar. This means they facilitate domain registration and management, but are not necessarily the ultimate owner of the joonix.net domain itself. It’s important to differentiate between registrar and registrant.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that managing bot signups requires distinguishing between malicious bots and those with legitimate purposes, such as search engine crawlers. They emphasize that for benign bots, a suppression strategy is often more appropriate than a hard block to avoid unintended consequences for site visibility or data collection. This nuanced approach helps maintain system integrity while supporting essential functions.
What the documentation says
Technical documentation from major online platforms and web standards organizations frequently addresses automated web crawling and data collection. These documents generally support the presence of legitimate bots, like Google's, that perform indexing and validation tasks. They provide guidelines for how website owners can manage such traffic, often recommending methods to control access or filter data without outright blocking essential services. The focus is on maintaining system integrity while supporting the open web.
Key findings
- Legitimate crawling: Documentation confirms that major search engines and e-commerce platforms deploy specialized bots to crawl websites for data accuracy, indexing, and compliance checks.
- Googlebot variants: Google uses various specialized versions of Googlebot (e.g., for images, videos, news, and shopping) to perform specific tasks, including price verification and product information gathering.
- Purpose of visits: These automated visits ensure the data presented in Google Search and Shopping results is current and accurate, which is crucial for both users and merchants.
- Robots exclusion protocol: The robots.txt file is the standard for instructing compliant web crawlers on which parts of a site they should or should not access.
Key considerations
- Allowing legitimate bots: Documentation typically advises against blocking known, legitimate bots as it can hinder your site's visibility and performance in search engines and other platforms.
- Controlling crawl behavior: While you shouldn't block Google's shopping bots, you can use robots.txt to manage which sections of your site they crawl, potentially preventing them from initiating signups if those forms aren't intended for automated access.
- Distinguishing bot types: Documentation often provides guidelines for identifying legitimate Googlebot traffic through IP verification or user-agent strings, helping differentiate it from malicious bots.
- Data accuracy in platforms: For platforms like Google Merchant Center, accurate and current product data is paramount. Obstructing Google's ability to verify this data can lead to product disapprovals or reduced visibility.
Technical article
Google's Support Documentation specifies that Googlebot and its various specialized crawlers, including those for shopping, are designed to access and index publicly available information on websites. This process is essential for maintaining comprehensive and up-to-date data in Google's search and shopping services. Website owners are encouraged to allow these legitimate bots to ensure their content is properly represented.
Technical article
Webmaster Guidelines advise webmasters on how to manage automated access to their sites using the robots.txt protocol. They typically recommend permitting access for known, beneficial agents like Googlebot, but allow for specific directories or paths to be excluded from crawling if necessary. This provides control without outright blocking essential services.
Related resources
3 resources
Related pages
What are the possible reasons for an increase in bot signups and how to detect/prevent them?
What are the purposes of bots signing up for emails and accounts on websites?
Why am I getting a lot of strange signups to my newsletter?
How can I prevent bots from signing up for my newsletter and marking it as spam?
How can I prevent bot signups on my email newsletter form?
How do bot signups impact email deliverability and what methods can prevent them?
An in-depth guide to email blocklists
Email Deliverability Issues: Getting Your Messages to the Inbox in 2025
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
Why am I seeing inflated clicks in my ESP reporting due to bot activity?
