Summary
When Free.fr SMTP responses falsely flag an IP as being on the Spamhaus PBL, it almost always indicates an issue on Free.fr's side. This could be due to misconfigured mail servers, outdated DNS records, a flawed PBL implementation, or even a network connectivity issue masking itself as a blocklist error. The Spamhaus PBL is a list of consumer IPs that shouldn't be sending email, so a sending server shouldn't be on it. SMTP error messages can be misleading, and one shouldn't rely solely on the message itself. Checking the IP against multiple blocklist and reputation services is crucial. Because Free.fr uses a non-standard error code, checking that specific code is key. The problem frequently requires contacting Free.fr support with detailed information to resolve the issue.
Key findings
- Free.fr Problem: The issue primarily resides with Free.fr's infrastructure (misconfiguration, outdated records, or flawed PBL implementation).
- False Positive: The IP is likely *not* actually listed on Spamhaus PBL.
- Misleading Errors: SMTP error messages can be misleading, and the PBL error could mask other problems (network, reputation).
- Context Matters: Interpret error messages in context; don't rely on face value alone.
- PBL Purpose: The PBL (Policy Block List) is meant for consumer IPs not sending authenticated email.
- Non-Standard code: Code 499 is a Free.fr specific message.
Key considerations
- Contact Free.fr Support: Contact Free.fr support immediately with detailed logs, timestamps, and the SMTP conversation.
- Verify Blocklist Status: Confirm the IP's status on Spamhaus PBL and other blocklists using multiple lookup tools.
- Check Reputation: Assess the sending IP and domain reputation using services like Talos Intelligence or MXToolbox.
- Inspect Headers: Analyze raw email headers for deeper diagnostic information.
- Investigate Free.fr's 499 Code: Research the specific meaning of error code 499 used by Free.fr.
What email marketers say
9 marketer opinions
When Free.fr SMTP responses incorrectly identify an IP as blacklisted on Spamhaus PBL, it typically indicates a problem on Free.fr's end, rather than an actual listing on Spamhaus. This issue can stem from misconfigured mail servers, outdated DNS records, or flawed PBL implementation by Free.fr. While the error message mentions Spamhaus PBL, it could also mask underlying network connectivity problems or IP/domain reputation issues. Resolving this often involves contacting Free.fr support with detailed information and utilizing diagnostic tools to assess the origin of the problem.
Key opinions
- Free.fr Issue: The problem is likely on Free.fr's side, such as misconfigured servers or flawed PBL implementation.
- False Positive: The IP address is likely not actually listed on the Spamhaus PBL.
- Misleading Message: The Spamhaus PBL error might be a symptom of other underlying problems like network connectivity or IP reputation issues.
- Non-Standard: Free.fr could be using a non-standard code, indicating a custom error.
Key considerations
- Contact Free.fr Support: Report the issue to Free.fr support with detailed logs and error information.
- Check IP Reputation: Verify the IP's reputation on other blocklists and reputation services.
- Use Diagnostic Tools: Employ tools like MXToolbox to run blacklist checks, SMTP tests, and DNS lookups.
- Check Domain Reputation: Verify the sending domain's reputation to see if this is impacting sending abilities.
Marketer view
Email marketer from StackOverflow answers by stating that the root cause could be that Free.fr's mail server is misconfigured to check the wrong IP against the PBL, or that their PBL implementation is flawed.
5 May 2024 - StackOverflow
Marketer view
Email marketer from Gmass explains that domain reputation could cause deliverability issues. If one IP has damaged reputation on the PBL or other blocklists, this might impact all IPs on the same range. It might be useful to contact the IP provider to solve these problems together.
20 Sep 2022 - Gmass.co
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
When Free.fr incorrectly reports an IP as blacklisted on Spamhaus PBL, it signifies that Free.fr has likely experienced an internal error or misconfiguration, rather than an actual listing on Spamhaus. The PBL is designed to block consumer IP addresses that should not be sending email. Experts advise against solely relying on the error message's literal interpretation, noting that SMTP error messages can be misleading. It is crucial to consider the context and cross-reference with other reputation services.
Key opinions
- Free.fr Error: The 'Invalid response code' indicates a problem specific to Free.fr, not a Spamhaus listing.
- PBL Definition: PBL is intended to block consumer IP addresses from sending email.
- False Positives Possible: Reputation systems can generate false positives.
- Misleading Messages: SMTP error messages can be inaccurate or misleading.
Key considerations
- Context is Key: Do not rely solely on the error message; consider the context of the error.
- Check Multiple Services: Verify IP reputation across multiple reputation services.
- Free.fr Responsibility: The issue likely requires investigation and resolution by Free.fr.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks says that the “Invalid response code” means that Free broke something and that it's not a spamhaus issue.
13 Apr 2024 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise (Laura Atkins) explains that SMTP error messages can be misleading or inaccurate. It's important to understand the context and not rely solely on the text of the error to diagnose the problem.
3 Dec 2022 - Word to the Wise
What the documentation says
7 technical articles
When Free.fr SMTP responses falsely indicate an IP is blacklisted on Spamhaus PBL, it suggests an issue on Free.fr's side. The Spamhaus PBL is intended to block end-user IP ranges sending unauthenticated email. The '4' series SMTP response indicates a temporary failure, but an invalid or non-standard response code implies non-compliance with standards. Verifying the IP's presence on Spamhaus PBL and using multiple lookup tools is essential. Contacting Free.fr support is recommended after confirming the IP is not actually listed. Checking raw message headers can also provide contextual information. Implementations of SMTP Enhanced Status Codes are supposed to provide more information, and may require looking at Free.fr's error code specifically.
Key findings
- PBL Purpose: Spamhaus PBL blocks end-user IP ranges sending unauthenticated email.
- Transient Failure: SMTP '4xx' responses indicate temporary failures; clients should retry.
- Non-Standard Code: Free.fr's '499' code indicates a custom error.
- Verify Listing: It is essential to independently verify if the IP is actually listed on Spamhaus PBL.
Key considerations
- Contact Free.fr: Contact Free.fr support to report the false positive with detailed logs.
- Check Message Headers: Examine raw message headers for more context.
- Use Multiple Tools: Employ multiple DNSBL lookup tools to verify the IP's status.
- Investigate enhanced error code: Check Free.fr's meaning of code 499.
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft shares the potential for blocklist errors is always present and that it's key to check the raw message headers for specific error messages to understand the context of the issue better.
1 Jul 2024 - Microsoft.com
Technical article
Documentation from Dnsrecords.io explains the steps involved in performing a DNS lookup to verify whether an IP is listed on the Spamhaus PBL, and that checking against multiple DNSBL lookup tools is key to determine if this is a genuine block or a Free.fr issue.
13 Oct 2022 - Dnsrecords.io
Besides Spamhaus, what blocklists are important for email marketers to monitor?
How can I get delisted from Spamhaus?
How can I get help with a Spamhaus listing delisting?
How do I check Spamhaus for my IP address and understand the listings?
How to remove IP address from Spamhaus PBL list?
Is being listed on SpamStopHere harmful to senders' reputation?
