Summary
Addressing spam trap issues, particularly those related to disposable email domains and resulting in zero open rates, is critical for maintaining healthy email deliverability. A high delivery rate combined with no opens often indicates that messages are hitting spam traps or being heavily filtered before reaching the inbox. Disposable email addresses, frequently used for temporary sign-ups, are often converted into spam traps by internet service providers (ISPs) to identify and penalize senders with poor list hygiene. Identifying and rectifying these issues involves a multi-faceted approach focusing on list acquisition, validation, and continuous monitoring.
Key findings
- Zero open rates: A 0% open rate with a high delivery rate strongly suggests a problem beyond content, such as emails landing directly in the spam folder or hitting spam traps. It may also indicate an issue with open tracking configuration.
- Disposable domains: Domains like mailsac.com are known disposable email providers, which are common sources of spam traps. Sending to these addresses signals poor list quality to ISPs.
- Volume of bad addresses: Having a large number of disposable email addresses, especially from a single domain, drastically increases the risk of hitting spam traps and getting blocklisted.
- List acquisition: The source of your email list is paramount. Lists acquired without proper consent or through questionable means often contain a high percentage of invalid or disposable addresses.
Key considerations
- Tracking configuration: First, investigate if your email tracking (especially open tracking) is configured correctly, as a misconfiguration can falsely report 0% open rates. While it is less likely when all other domains are fine, it is still a possibility.
- Email validation: Implement robust email validation at the point of signup to prevent disposable (and other invalid) addresses from entering your list. This proactive approach helps avoid spam traps.
- List hygiene: Regularly clean your email lists to remove inactive subscribers, hard bounces, and known disposable domains. This practice is crucial for avoiding spam traps and improving inbox placement. For more information, read our guide on improving low open rates.
- Source audit: Review your list acquisition methods to identify and stop sources that contribute high volumes of disposable or low-quality email addresses.
What email marketers say
Email marketers frequently encounter challenges with low open rates and spam traps, often stemming from list quality issues. They understand that a healthy email list is the foundation of successful campaigns and that disposable email addresses pose a significant threat to deliverability and sender reputation.
Key opinions
- Tracking issues: Some marketers suggest that 0% open rates could indicate a configuration problem with open tracking rather than solely a deliverability issue.
- Disposable domain impact: It is widely agreed that disposable email domains are a likely cause for 0% open rates and deliverability issues. They are often spam traps.
- Excessive volume: Marketers view a large number of disposable email addresses, especially from a single domain like mailsac.com, as a serious problem that significantly impacts sender reputation.
- Preventative measures: There's a strong consensus that preventing disposable email addresses from entering your system in the first place is far better than trying to fix issues later.
Key considerations
- Open tracking audit: Before assuming spam trap issues, check your open tracking setup to ensure it's functioning correctly across all campaigns and domains.
- Email validation at signup: Use real-time email validation services during signup to reject known disposable and suspicious domains. Learn how to validate email signups.
- Source investigation: If you have a high volume of disposable email addresses, investigate how your list was acquired. This can help you identify suspicious domains and prevent future contamination.
- List cleaning: Regularly remove unengaged subscribers and invalid addresses from your list to improve overall deliverability. This also helps you avoid emails going to spam.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks suggests that a high delivery rate with zero opens for specific domains like mailsac.com and firstsource.com indicates a spam trap issue. They are seeking guidance on how to resolve it.
Marketer view
Email Marketer from Email Geeks indicates that 0% open rates can often point to a configuration issue with open tracking that needs investigation. They also recommend seed testing and checking for spam filtration reports.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts consistently emphasize that low open rates and spam trap hits are clear indicators of underlying issues with email list quality and sender reputation. They advocate for stringent preventative measures rather than reactive fixes, stressing the long-term impact on deliverability.
Key opinions
- Root cause of low opens: Experts believe that zero or extremely low open rates often point directly to messages being delivered to spam folders or hitting active spam traps.
- Disposable email risk: It is a consensus among experts that disposable email addresses are highly likely to become spam traps, damaging sender reputation and causing delivery failures.
- List quality focus: Prioritizing the quality of your email list at the point of collection is crucial to prevent deliverability issues down the line.
- Proactive prevention: Experts stress that it's far more effective to prevent disposable addresses from entering your list than to try and remove them later.
Key considerations
- Strict validation: Implement robust email validation, including blocking known disposable domains, at the signup stage. This will help identify email spam traps.
- Regular list cleaning: Periodically remove inactive and unengaged subscribers from your lists, as old or abandoned email addresses can be repurposed as spam traps. Consider the impact of spam trap hits on deliverability.
- Double opt-in: Employ double opt-in for all new subscribers to confirm their intent and ensure the validity of the email address, significantly reducing spam trap exposure. For more details, consult Kickbox's guide to spam traps.
- Monitoring reputation: Continuously monitor your domain and IP reputation using tools like Google Postmaster Tools to detect early signs of deliverability issues.
Expert view
Expert from Spamresource.com advises that a sudden drop in open rates, particularly to zero, often signals a catastrophic deliverability issue, such as hitting a widespread spam trap. This requires immediate investigation.
Expert view
The team at Wordtothewise.com explains that disposable email addresses are prime candidates for becoming spam traps and should be prevented from entering your mailing list from the outset.
What the documentation says
Official documentation from email service providers and industry standards consistently highlight the detrimental effects of poor list quality, including disposable email addresses, on sender reputation and deliverability. They outline best practices for list management and compliance to ensure emails reach their intended recipients.
Key findings
- ISP filtering: ISPs utilize various signals, including hits on spam traps, to filter incoming mail, often leading to legitimate emails being junked or blocked.
- Reputation damage: Sending to invalid or disposable email addresses significantly damages a sender's IP and domain reputation, affecting deliverability across all recipients.
- Compliance requirements: Adherence to anti-spam laws like CAN-SPAM often necessitates explicit consent for email sending, which is typically absent with disposable email users.
- Importance of authentication: While DMARC, SPF, and DKIM are crucial for authentication, even perfectly authenticated emails can fail delivery if sender reputation is poor due to spam trap hits.
Key considerations
- Implement double opt-in: Mandatory double opt-in processes are recommended by many best practices guides to ensure genuine subscriber interest and valid email addresses.
- Real-time validation: Utilize real-time email verification during sign-up to immediately reject disposable email addresses. This aligns with expert guides on email deliverability.
- Segment and prune: Regularly segment your audience and prune inactive subscribers to prevent sending to addresses that may have become spam traps. For more on this, see the Mailgun deliverability tips.
- Monitor feedback loops: Subscribe to ISP feedback loops to promptly identify and remove users who mark your emails as spam, which helps mitigate spam trap related issues.
Technical article
Google Postmaster Tools documentation indicates that consistent hits on spam traps significantly lower your domain and IP reputation, leading to increased spam classifications for your legitimate emails.
Technical article
The CAN-SPAM Act guidelines specify that senders must have verifiable consent to send commercial emails. Sending to disposable addresses without consent can lead to compliance issues.
Related resources
15 resources
![Email deliverability: avoiding the spam folder [2025]](https://moosend.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Email-Deliverability.png)
Related pages
How to identify email spam traps?
What are effective strategies to avoid spam traps and improve email deliverability?
How can I validate email signups from unusual or new domains?
Why are my email open rates low and how can I improve deliverability?
What are the best tips and tools to keep spam traps to a minimum?
Spam traps: what they are and how they work
What are the different types of spam traps and how do they work?
How your email address ends up on a blacklist
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
Email deliverability issues: getting your messages to the inbox
