Summary
The Distributed Checksum Clearinghouse (DCC) enhances email scoring in SpamAssassin and Rspamd by identifying mass-mailed emails. It functions as a decentralized network where participating mail servers share checksums of emails. When an incoming message's checksum is queried against the DCC database, DCC reports how many times that specific checksum has been observed, indicating if it's a bulk mailing. Both SpamAssassin and Rspamd then use this information to assign a higher spam score to messages identified as bulk, often through specific rules or symbols like 'DCC_BULK,' significantly contributing to the overall spam score. While DCC primarily identifies bulk rather than inherently malicious content, it serves as a crucial data point for these filters, allowing them to more precisely detect and score unsolicited mass-distributed emails.
Key findings
- Checksum-Based Identification: The Distributed Cheksum Clearinghouse (DCC) operates by maintaining a decentralized database of checksums for common bulk emails. When an email passes through a spam filter, its checksum is queried against the DCC database. DCC then reports the number of times that specific checksum has been observed across the network, indicating if the message is a mass mailing.
- SpamAssassin Integration: SpamAssassin leverages DCC to identify widely distributed messages. It queries the DCC daemon with message checksums and, based on the reported frequency, applies scores via rules like dcc_dccifd, dcc_rcvd, and DCC_CHECK. This increases the likelihood of marking mass-mailed messages as spam by adding significant weight to the overall spam score.
- Rspamd Integration: Rspamd, an open-source solution similar to SpamAssassin, easily integrates with the DCC reputation network. Its DCC module checks message checksums against the DCC database. When a match indicating a mass mailing is found, Rspamd adds specific symbols, such as DCC_BULK, which are then assigned configurable scores to contribute directly to the email's overall spam score.
Key considerations
- Bulk vs. Spam: DCC primarily identifies "bulk" email, meaning messages sent to a large number of recipients. While much spam is bulk, not all legitimate bulk email is spam, and a high DCC score indicates mass mailing rather than inherent malicious content. Spam filters then interpret this bulk signal to assign a spam score if other factors align with spam characteristics.
- Varied Configurations: The effectiveness and scoring impact of DCC vary significantly across different SpamAssassin (SA) and Rspamd installations. Each system is uniquely configured, meaning a specific score from one setup does not necessarily reflect how other SA or Rspamd instances will score the same message. Only SA installations with DCC actively installed and configured will utilize its data for scoring decisions.
What email marketers say
8 marketer opinions
DCC serves as a crucial external data source, significantly enhancing how SpamAssassin and Rspamd score incoming emails. By identifying messages that have been widely distributed across its network, DCC enables these filters to apply higher spam scores to bulk mail. This process involves comparing an email's unique checksum against the DCC database; if the checksum has been frequently observed, it acts as a strong indicator of a mass mailing. Both SpamAssassin and Rspamd incorporate this information, either by directly adding weight to the overall spam score or by assigning specific symbols, like DCC_BULK in Rspamd, which then trigger score adjustments. This mechanism allows for more precise identification and filtering of unsolicited mass-distributed content, bolstering the effectiveness of email deliverability defenses.
Key opinions
- Shared Bulk Intelligence: DCC provides SpamAssassin and Rspamd with critical shared intelligence by counting how many unique mail servers have encountered an identical or near-identical message. This count is a primary metric that helps determine if an email is bulk mail, enabling more accurate spam filtering decisions by both systems.
- SpamAssassin's Scoring Leverage: SpamAssassin utilizes DCC's bulk detection to significantly influence its spam scoring. By identifying widely observed message checksums, SpamAssassin adds substantial weight to the overall spam score, aiding in the effective filtering of mass-distributed unsolicited emails.
- Rspamd's Symbol-Based Scoring: Rspamd integrates DCC to leverage its database of known bulk emails, assigning specific symbols, such as DCC_BULK, to messages whose checksums match. These symbols are then configured to add corresponding scores, directly increasing the spam score for emails identified as mass mailings.
Key considerations
- Bulk vs. Spam Distinction: While DCC effectively identifies bulk email, it is crucial to remember that not all bulk email is unsolicited spam. DCC flags messages that are widely distributed, and spam filters like SpamAssassin and Rspamd then use this information in conjunction with other criteria to determine if a message is indeed spam.
- Configuration Variability and Support Challenges: The precise impact of DCC on email scoring can vary widely across different SpamAssassin and Rspamd installations, as each system is uniquely configured. This leads to inconsistencies in how the same message is scored by different email providers, creating challenges for email marketers and support teams when troubleshooting deliverability issues for clients.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks shares that one of the biggest hosting providers in Brazil uses Rspamd, an open-source solution like SpamAssassin, and that Rspamd is easily plugged into the DCC reputation network, indicating its importance. He also notes that many ISPs in Brazil use SA or similar solutions, which can be a "nightmare" when clients ask for help due to their varied configurations.
5 May 2025 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Marketer from LinuxBabe.com explains that SpamAssassin leverages DCC to identify bulk emails by checking if a message's checksum has been observed numerous times across the DCC network. This detection of widely distributed messages allows SpamAssassin to apply a higher spam score, effectively filtering out mass-distributed unsolicited emails.
5 Sep 2021 - LinuxBabe.com
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
DCC (Distributed Checksum Clearinghouse) plays a pivotal role in email scoring for both SpamAssassin and Rspamd by facilitating the identification of mass-mailed messages. It operates as a collaborative network, enabling mail servers to share checksums of bulk emails. When an incoming message's checksum aligns with one reported by DCC, both SpamAssassin and Rspamd leverage this information to increase the email's spam score, thereby assisting in the filtering of unsolicited bulk content. It's crucial to understand that DCC primarily flags "bulk" rather than explicitly "spam," and the actual impact on scoring can differ significantly across various SpamAssassin or Rspamd installations, as DCC functionality requires specific setup and configuration.
Key opinions
- DCC's Core Function: DCC functions by allowing participating mail servers to share checksums of mass-mailed emails, providing a collaborative system for identifying widely distributed messages.
- SpamAssassin's Score Adjustment: When SpamAssassin encounters a message whose checksum matches one reported by DCC, it utilizes this data to assign a higher spam score, effectively flagging bulk messages as potentially unwanted.
- Rspamd's Multi-Source Scoring: Rspamd integrates DCC as one of several data sources, alongside tools like RBLs, to leverage bulk mail checksums in its comprehensive assessment of an email's spam likelihood.
Key considerations
- Bulk Identification, Not Spam: DCC is designed to identify "bulk" email, not necessarily spam; while much spam is bulk, a message flagged by DCC only indicates widespread distribution, which then contributes to a spam score in conjunction with other factors.
- Installation-Specific Impact: The effectiveness and scoring influence of DCC are entirely dependent on its installation and configuration within each specific SpamAssassin or Rspamd setup, meaning deliverability scores can vary widely between different systems.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that DCC is a way to identify "bulk" email, not spam. She clarifies that only SpamAssassin (SA) installations that have DCC installed and configured will score on it and emphasizes that every SA or Rspamd installation is different, meaning a score from one particular installation does not necessarily reflect how others will score.
10 Nov 2023 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that DCC (Distributed Checksum Clearinghouse) functions with SpamAssassin by allowing mail servers to share checksums of bulk emails. When a message's checksum matches one reported by DCC, SpamAssassin uses this information to assign a higher spam score, aiding in the identification and filtering of bulk or spam messages.
14 Dec 2022 - Word to the Wise
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
DCC (Distributed Checksum Clearinghouse) provides a crucial layer to how SpamAssassin and Rspamd assess email legitimacy, particularly in identifying mass-mailed content. It operates by maintaining a decentralized network that collects checksums of widely distributed messages. When an email is processed, its checksum is queried against the DCC database. If a high count of identical checksums is reported, indicating a bulk mailing, both SpamAssassin and Rspamd leverage this data. They apply higher spam scores, either through specific rules or by assigning unique symbols, significantly aiding in the filtration of unsolicited bulk messages.
Key findings
- DCC's Foundational Role: DCC operates as a decentralized network, maintaining a database of checksums for widely distributed emails. When SpamAssassin or Rspamd query DCC with a message's checksum, DCC reports how many times that specific checksum has been observed, indicating if the message is a mass mailing.
- SpamAssassin's Scoring Rules: SpamAssassin uses DCC to detect bulk messages by querying the DCC daemon. When a message is identified as widely sent, specific rules such as `dcc_dccifd`, `dcc_rcvd`, and `DCC_CHECK` are triggered. These rules are assigned predetermined scores, which significantly increase the email's overall spam score, making it more likely to be marked as spam.
- Rspamd's Symbol-Based Scoring: Rspamd integrates DCC through its dedicated module, checking message checksums against the DCC database. Upon identifying a mass mailing, Rspamd adds specific symbols, like DCC_BULK, to the message. These symbols are then associated with configurable scores within Rspamd's setup, directly contributing to the email's overall spam score.
Key considerations
- Bulk Detection vs. Spam Classification: DCC's core purpose is to identify messages sent in bulk, a common characteristic of spam. However, a bulk message is not automatically spam; legitimate newsletters or transactional emails are also sent in bulk. SpamAssassin and Rspamd use DCC's bulk identification as a significant data point, combining it with other filtering criteria to determine if a message is truly unsolicited.
- System-Specific Implementation: The actual effectiveness and scoring impact of DCC are highly contingent on its proper installation and configuration within each unique SpamAssassin or Rspamd environment. Deliverability professionals must recognize that scores can vary significantly between different systems depending on how DCC rules and symbols are weighted, requiring tailored tuning for optimal performance.
Technical article
Documentation from Apache SpamAssassin Wiki explains that SpamAssassin uses DCC to check if a message has been sent to many recipients by querying the DCC daemon with message checksums. This allows SpamAssassin to assign scores based on the `dcc_dccifd` and `dcc_rcvd` rules, increasing the likelihood of marking mass-mailed messages as spam.
17 Sep 2021 - Apache SpamAssassin Wiki
Technical article
Documentation from Rspamd Project details how the DCC module integrates by checking message checksums against the DCC database. When a match indicating a mass mailing is found, Rspamd adds specific symbols (e.g., DCC_BULK) to the message. These symbols are then assigned scores within Rspamd's configuration, directly contributing to the email's overall spam score.
31 Mar 2025 - Rspamd Documentation
How do DMARC, spam complaints, and IP reputation affect email deliverability and rejections?
How do spamassassin rules affect email deliverability?
How does senderscore impact email deliverability and how is it calculated?
How relevant is SpamAssassin scoring for modern email deliverability?
What is the Spamhaus content hash blocklist and how does it compare to DCC, Vipul's Razor, and Cloudmark?
Why does SpamAssassin give positive score for DMARC reject and MIME_NO_TEXT or LONG_INVISIBLE_TEXT?
