Summary
The question of whether hosting images directly on an Email Service Provider’s (ESP) Content Management System (CMS) provides a meaningful deliverability advantage over external hosting, such as Amazon Web Services (AWS), is a common one among email marketers. The consensus is that a direct deliverability lift from ESP-local hosting is generally not significant, provided external image hosting is configured optimally. Key factors like domain reputation, use of HTTPS, and avoiding problematic shared infrastructure are far more critical than the physical location of the image server.
Key findings
- No inherent lift: There's no clear evidence that hosting images on an ESP's CMS inherently provides a direct, significant deliverability boost compared to external cloud hosting when both are properly configured.
- Domain reputation matters: The reputation of the domain serving the images is a critical factor. Using a dedicated custom domain for image hosting, regardless of whether it points to an ESP's server or an external one, is crucial for maintaining good sender reputation. Learn more about how hostname affects deliverability.
- HTTPS is standard: All modern image hosting for emails should use HTTPS. This is less about deliverability directly and more about security and recipient trust, preventing browser warnings and ensuring images load reliably. Our guide on HTTPS for email links explains this further.
- Avoid generic cloud URLs: Using generic cloud storage URLs (e.g., direct AWS S3 bucket URLs) can be detrimental to deliverability as they might be shared among many users, some of whom could engage in abusive practices. This is a common issue discussed by email platforms like Vero.
Key considerations
- Consistency: Maintain consistency across your sending domains and image hosting domains for a cohesive brand presence and to build trust with mailbox providers.
- Redirection risks: Avoid redirecting image URLs, as some spam filters interpret this as an attempt to obscure the true destination, potentially leading to deliverability penalties.
- Image optimization: Ensure images are optimized for email (file size, dimensions) regardless of where they are hosted to ensure quick loading times and a good user experience.
- Monitoring: Regularly monitor the reputation of your image hosting domain and ensure it is not listed on any blocklists. This proactive approach can prevent issues before they impact your deliverability.
What email marketers say
Email marketers often express varying opinions on image hosting, frequently driven by assumptions or past experiences rather than specific technical knowledge. Many initially believe that a consolidated approach (hosting images with the ESP) might be inherently safer or offer a deliverability edge, possibly due to a perception of integrated trustworthiness by ISPs. However, as discussions evolve, the focus shifts towards practical concerns like the risks associated with shared infrastructure or the complexities of managing external hosting.
Key opinions
- Perceived trustworthiness: Some marketers believe that if the sender and image host share the same IP address, it might be perceived as more trustworthy by ISPs, though this is generally not a significant factor today.
- Reputation risk of external URLs: A common concern is the potential reputation risk posed by generic cloud service URLs, such as those from S3 or AWS, if they are not masked by a custom domain. For more on this, see S3 buckets and custom domains.
- Preference for direct linking: Many marketers prefer direct linking to images rather than using redirects, fearing that redirects could be misinterpreted as an attempt to obfuscate the final image source by spam filters. This is also covered in discussions about link shorteners and deliverability.
- Host independence: Some feel that owning their own IP or domain for hosting gives them more control and reduces worry about other users on a shared hosting provider potentially damaging their reputation, as highlighted in Quora discussions on image hosting strategies.
Key considerations
- Custom domain usage: Marketers should always use a custom domain name pointed to their external image host (like S3) to build and protect their own domain's reputation, rather than relying on the generic cloud provider's URL.
- Content hygiene: Regardless of hosting method, ensure image hosting environments are secure and free from malware, as compromised image hosts can severely impact deliverability.
- Filter sophistication: Recognize that modern spam filters are highly sophisticated and evaluate the entire context of an email, including all linked content, beyond just simple IP matching for image hosts.
- Performance versus deliverability: While deliverability is paramount, consider performance aspects like image load times. CDNs (Content Delivery Networks) often provide superior speed and reliability, which can enhance the user experience and indirectly support positive engagement metrics.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks questions whether an ESP-local image hosting solution would provide a significant deliverability lift. They expressed curiosity about the underlying reasons marketers might believe this to be true.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks expressed concern about the potential reputation risks associated with using generic S3 or AWS URLs for image hosting. They noted that using a proxy (or custom domain) pointing to S3 would likely mitigate this specific risk.
What the experts say
Email deliverability experts concur that the impact of image hosting location on inbox placement is less about whether it's ESP-local or external, and more about the underlying technical configuration and reputation of the image-serving domain. Experts emphasize that the domain used to host images is paramount, especially regarding its own reputation and security. They highlight that modern spam filters are highly sophisticated, evaluating an email's entire context rather than relying on simplistic rules about co-located IPs.
Key opinions
- Domain reputation is primary: Experts consistently stress that the reputation of the image-hosting domain carries significantly more weight than the physical server location. A clean, dedicated custom domain is key.
- Filter sophistication: Mailbox providers' filters are advanced, capable of discerning context and analyzing complex reputation signals beyond simple IP-based matching for content. They assess the entire email ecosystem.
- Shared infrastructure risk: Using generic, shared domains (like default S3 bucket URLs) can be risky because the actions of other users on that shared domain can negatively impact your own email deliverability if the domain gets blocklisted or develops a poor reputation.
- Custom domain benefits: Establishing a custom subdomain (e.g., images.yourdomain.com) for external image hosting allows you to build and control that specific domain's reputation, isolating it from the main sending domain while still benefiting from cloud scalability.
Key considerations
- HTTPS is mandatory: Ensure all image links, whether hosted by an ESP or externally, use HTTPS. This is a baseline for trust and security in modern email clients.
- Avoid redirects for images: Direct linking to image files is preferred. Redirects can add latency and may be viewed suspiciously by some spam filters.
- Content security: Regardless of the hosting location, ensure that the image storage is secure and free from any malicious content. Malware hosted on your image domain can severely damage your sender reputation and lead to blocklisting.
- Monitoring infrastructure: Regularly check the reputation of your image hosting domain and IP. If using a cloud provider, be aware of their general reputation and any shared IP pool issues. Monitoring tools can assist with this. This is related to how domain blacklisting works.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource suggests that using a reputable Content Delivery Network (CDN) for image hosting can often provide better performance and reliability. They note that this approach typically does not negatively impact deliverability, provided the CDN is configured with a custom domain and adheres to security best practices.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise emphasizes that the domain reputation of the image host is paramount. They highlight that if a shared image host's generic domain becomes associated with spam or malicious activity, even legitimate emails using those images could be affected by filtering or blocklisting.
What the documentation says
Official documentation and industry standards primarily focus on secure and efficient web content delivery, which directly applies to email images. While specific deliverability impacts of hosting location aren't often explicitly detailed, the principles of domain reputation, secure connections (HTTPS), and content integrity are universally emphasized. Documentation from major cloud providers and web best practices guides underscore the importance of proper configuration for reliability and security, which indirectly supports email deliverability.
Key findings
- Security through HTTPS: Web security standards strongly recommend HTTPS for all content, including images, to ensure data integrity and user trust. This is a critical factor for email clients and recipients.
- Domain ownership and control: Documentation for external hosting (e.g., AWS S3, CloudFront) highlights the ability to use custom domains, giving users full control over the domain's reputation, distinct from generic shared cloud URLs.
- Content delivery reliability: CDNs are designed for high-performance content delivery, which ensures images load quickly and reliably for recipients, enhancing the user experience. This reliability can indirectly support positive sender metrics.
- Best practices for web images: General web development guidelines, applicable to email images, stress image optimization (compression, correct sizing) to improve load times and overall performance, regardless of hosting location.
Key considerations
- Infrastructure reputation: While ESPs manage their own infrastructure's reputation, external cloud providers also maintain their network's standing. Users of external hosting need to ensure the service provider has a strong reputation for abuse prevention and network hygiene.
- Compliance and governance: Self-hosting or using external cloud storage for images requires adherence to data privacy and security regulations relevant to your business and audience, which ESPs typically handle as part of their service.
- Scalability and reliability: External cloud hosting solutions are often designed for massive scale and high availability, which can be advantageous for campaigns with large audiences, ensuring images are always accessible.
- Content management integration: Integrating external image hosting with an ESP's CMS might require custom setups, whereas ESP-native hosting is typically seamless. The choice depends on technical capabilities and workflow preferences.
Technical article
Documentation from GetVero highlights that issues related to email images can significantly reduce deliverability and negatively impact user experience. They suggest that careful attention to image hosting and configuration is crucial for successful email campaigns.
Technical article
Documentation from Quora, in discussions about image hosting for websites, suggests that for high-traffic environments, external hosting (like CDNs) can provide performance benefits. This indicates that reliability and speed are key, which translates to a better user experience for email recipients.
Related resources
3 resources
Related pages
How do S3 buckets and custom domains for image hosting affect email deliverability and reputation?
How does self-hosting email images affect deliverability?
Does using HTTPS/SSL for email links and images improve deliverability or performance?
How does the hostname used for image hosting affect email deliverability?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of hosting email images on Amazon S3 versus CloudFront, and how does it impact deliverability?
How to protect email deliverability for image-only emails?
Does a high image to text ratio affect email deliverability and spam filtering?
Why Your Emails Are Going to Spam in 2024 and How to Fix It
A practical guide to understanding your email domain reputation
What does it mean when your email is blacklisted?
