Summary
Interpreting a 'yellow' status in Microsoft SNDS during IP warming is a critical aspect of email deliverability, though experts offer varied perspectives on its definitive meaning. This 'yellow' warning typically signals a potential risk to your IP's reputation, stemming from increased spam complaints, low engagement, or hits on spam traps. It's often observed that new IPs will shift to 'yellow' as good email volume is introduced during warming, and returning to 'green' may require sustained, significant positive sending. While some marketers question the direct correlation between SNDS colors and actual delivery, many advise cautious action. The general consensus suggests that senders should not panic over a single day's 'yellow' result but instead monitor trends. If the 'yellow' status persists alongside a dip in actual open rates for Microsoft domains, immediate adjustments are warranted. These include scaling back sending volume to Microsoft addresses, rigorously cleaning mailing lists, ensuring content is highly relevant, and prioritizing sends to your most engaged subscribers. Ultimately, monitoring actual open and click-through rates for Microsoft recipients often provides a more reliable gauge of inbox placement than the SNDS color alone.
Key findings
- SNDS Yellow Meaning: A 'yellow' status in Microsoft SNDS indicates a warning sign for an IP's reputation, often signifying increased spam complaints, low user engagement, or spam trap hits.
- Common During Warming: It is a common occurrence for IP addresses to initially appear 'green' in SNDS and then turn 'yellow' when legitimate email volume is introduced during IP warming, often requiring significant, sustained positive volume to revert to 'green'.
- Reliability Debated: Some email marketing experts find SNDS color indicators, particularly 'yellow', to be unreliable or unclear, suggesting they may not always directly correlate with actual email delivery success.
- Content and Pattern Impact: A 'yellow' status, especially when combined with 'filtered as spam' data in the SNDS dashboard, suggests that specific content or sending patterns are triggering Microsoft's spam filters.
- Engagement as Primary Metric: Healthy actual open and click-through rates, particularly for Microsoft domains, are often considered a stronger indicator of successful inbox placement than the SNDS color status alone.
Key considerations
- Monitor Trends: Make decisions based on observing trends in SNDS data and your own engagement metrics over several days, rather than reacting to a single day's yellow status.
- Adjust Volume: If a yellow status persists and is accompanied by a dip in actual open rates, immediately reduce or pause sending volume, particularly to Microsoft domains, to mitigate further reputation damage.
- Prioritize Engagement: Focus sending efforts on your most engaged subscribers to improve positive signals and demonstrate desired email traffic to Microsoft.
- Review Content: Thoroughly analyze your email content for any elements that might be triggering spam filters or contributing to elevated complaint rates.
- Clean Lists: Proactively clean your mailing lists to remove inactive, unengaged, or risky contacts that could be contributing to negative feedback loops.
- Slow Down Warm-up: If you halt or reduce sending, gradually re-initiate your IP warming schedule at a slower pace once the yellow status improves or your engagement metrics stabilize.
- Assess Actual Delivery: Complement SNDS data with your own actual open and click-through rates, specifically for Microsoft domains, as these are often more reliable indicators of true inbox placement.
What email marketers say
10 marketer opinions
The 'yellow' indicator in Microsoft SNDS during IP warming is a critical warning sign for an IP's sending reputation. This status generally suggests that Microsoft has detected negative signals, such as elevated spam complaints, low user engagement, or encounters with spam traps. While some industry experts note that the SNDS color indications can sometimes be unclear or not perfectly align with actual delivery, a persistent 'yellow' during IP warming should prompt immediate corrective action. It strongly suggests that the sending volume might be increasing too quickly or that emails are reaching unengaged or problematic recipients. To address this, senders must significantly scale back daily sending volume to Microsoft domains, thoroughly clean their mailing lists of inactive or risky contacts, and meticulously review email content for potential spam triggers. The focus should shift entirely to sending highly engaging, relevant content to the most active segments of their audience. This cautious approach, combined with daily monitoring of SNDS for a return to 'green' and observation of actual open rates, is crucial before gradually resuming the IP warming process.
Key opinions
- SNDS Yellow Signifies Issues: A 'yellow' rating in Microsoft SNDS indicates the detection of issues like elevated spam complaints, low engagement, or spam trap hits, signaling a potential decline in IP reputation.
- Warning for Warming Pace: During IP warming, 'yellow' explicitly warns that sending volume is increasing too rapidly or targeting unengaged users, requiring immediate adjustment.
- Actionable Signal for Adjustment: Unlike general unreliability, when 'yellow' appears during IP warming, it is considered a clear signal to pause or significantly reduce sending and re-evaluate strategy.
- Common Initial Response to Volume: It is a common pattern for new IPs to turn 'yellow' once good email volume is introduced during warming, and returning to 'green' often requires sustained positive engagement.
Key considerations
- Immediate Volume Reduction: Significantly decrease or halt sending volume to Microsoft domains immediately upon observing a persistent 'yellow' status.
- Thorough List Cleaning: Actively clean mailing lists to remove inactive, unengaged, or problematic contacts that contribute to negative signals.
- Content Review: Analyze email content for any elements that might trigger spam filters or higher complaint rates.
- Prioritize Engaged Users: During the adjustment period, focus exclusively on sending to your most engaged and active subscribers to build positive reputation.
- Monitor and Adjust Gradually: Continuously monitor SNDS daily for a return to 'green' and only gradually resume or re-initiate the IP warming schedule at a slower pace once the status improves and engagement stabilizes.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that Microsoft SNDS colors, particularly yellow, are often unreliable and may not correlate with actual email delivery, suggesting that 'the colors are a lie' and that the reporting is, at best, unclear.
27 Jan 2025 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks suggests that while Microsoft SNDS colors can be unclear, senders should monitor trends over several days and observe open rates. If open rates significantly dip and yellow persists, it might be advisable to scale back sends for Microsoft, focusing on engaged users, but not to make a decision based on a single day's data.
25 Oct 2024 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
2 expert opinions
When interpreting 'yellow' results in Microsoft SNDS during IP warming, it's crucial to balance Microsoft's signal with your own performance data. While a 'yellow' status indicates suspicious traffic that is not yet blocked, expert advice suggests that if your actual open and click-through rates, particularly for Microsoft domains, remain strong-for example, in the mid-60s for open rates-your mail is likely reaching the inbox effectively. In such scenarios, while continued monitoring is advisable, there may not be a need for excessive concern or drastic action. However, if the 'yellow' rating is consistent, it strongly suggests that elements within your email are triggering filters. In these cases, slowing down your sending volume is recommended, although a complete halt might not be necessary.
Key opinions
- Engagement Over Color: Healthy actual open rates, such as mid-60s, for Microsoft domains suggest that mail is successfully reaching the inbox, even if SNDS indicates 'yellow'.
- Yellow Signals Suspicion: Microsoft SNDS 'yellow' results indicate suspicious traffic that has not yet resulted in a block.
- Consistent Yellow Action: Consistently observing 'yellow' ratings during IP warming suggests that aspects of your email are triggering Microsoft's filters, necessitating a reduction in sending volume.
Key considerations
- Prioritize Engagement Metrics: Regularly assess your actual open and click-through rates, specifically for Microsoft domains, as these metrics provide a more direct indication of successful inbox delivery than the SNDS color alone.
- Adjust for Persistent Yellow: If Microsoft SNDS consistently shows a 'yellow' status during IP warming, it signals that email elements are triggering filters. In such cases, reduce your sending volume, although a complete stop might not be required.
- Avoid Overreaction: While monitoring SNDS is essential, avoid excessive worry over a 'yellow' change if your actual engagement metrics, such as open rates, remain strong for Microsoft recipients.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks advises assessing actual open and click-through rates, specifically for Microsoft domains, to gauge delivery success. She concludes that if open rates are healthy (e.g., mid-60s), the mail is likely reaching the inbox successfully, and therefore, while monitoring is good, the sender should not overly worry about a Microsoft SNDS color change from green to yellow.
29 Jun 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that Microsoft SNDS yellow results indicate suspicious traffic that isn't yet leading to a block. During IP warming, if you consistently observe yellow ratings, it signals that some elements of your email are triggering filters. In such situations, it's recommended to slow down your sending volume, although a complete stop might not be required.
26 Sep 2022 - Word to the Wise
What the documentation says
3 technical articles
When Microsoft SNDS displays a 'yellow' status during IP warming, it serves as a critical warning that your IP address's reputation is at risk. This indicator is often tied to increased spam complaints, negative signals, or a rise in emails being 'filtered as spam,' suggesting that your content or sending patterns are triggering Microsoft's filters. Unlike a passive alert, a 'yellow' signal during IP warming demands immediate and decisive action. Senders must undertake a thorough review of their email content, list quality, and sending frequency, as these elements are likely contributing to the negative feedback. It is strongly advised to immediately halt or significantly reduce sending volume to Microsoft domains. The focus should shift to mitigating issues by ensuring only genuinely desired mail is sent, rigorously cleaning mailing lists, and meticulously reviewing sending practices to improve positive signals and avoid a 'red' listing.
Key findings
- Yellow Indicates Reputation Risk: Microsoft SNDS 'yellow' status signals a warning that an IP address's reputation is at risk due to increased spam complaints or other negative signals, requiring immediate attention.
- Linked to Spam Filtering: A 'yellow' status, especially when coupled with an increase in 'filtered as spam' data in the SNDS dashboard, directly indicates that content or sending patterns are triggering Microsoft's spam filters.
- Necessitates Immediate Action: During IP warming, a 'yellow' status is a critical warning that necessitates immediate review and adjustment of sending practices, content, and list quality to prevent reputation degradation and a 'red' listing.
- Requires Volume Reduction: Expert advice indicates that a 'yellow' status, particularly when accompanied by rising negative feedback, requires an immediate halt or severe reduction in sending volume.
Key considerations
- Monitor Negative Signals: Continuously monitor SNDS data for increased spam complaints, spam trap hits, and emails 'filtered as spam' to understand the specific negative signals contributing to a 'yellow' status.
- Adjust Sending Volume Immediately: Upon observing a 'yellow' status during IP warming, immediately halt or severely reduce sending volume to Microsoft recipients to prevent further reputation degradation and a 'red' listing.
- Review Content and Practices: Conduct a thorough review of your email content, subject lines, sending frequency, and overall sending patterns to identify and correct elements triggering spam filters.
- Prioritize List Quality: Rigorously examine and clean your mailing lists, ensuring you are sending only to highly engaged, consented recipients to improve positive feedback and mitigate issues.
- Send Desired Mail Only: During periods of 'yellow' status, focus exclusively on sending mail that is genuinely desired by recipients, avoiding any potentially unwanted or low-engagement content.
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft Learn indicates that SNDS provides a status for IP addresses (Green, Yellow, Red) and associated data like spam trap hits, complaint rates, and recipient counts. A "Yellow" status signifies a warning, suggesting that the IP address's reputation is at risk due to increased spam complaints or other negative signals. While not explicitly detailing IP warming adjustments, it implies that senders should monitor this data closely to prevent reputation degradation.
1 Nov 2023 - Microsoft Learn
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft Learn highlights that the SNDS dashboard provides insights into email traffic, including filtering outcomes like 'filtered as spam'. A 'Yellow' status, coupled with an increase in 'filtered as spam' data, suggests that content or sending patterns are triggering spam filters. During IP warming, this would necessitate an immediate review of content, list quality, and sending frequency to avoid a 'red' listing.
24 Feb 2024 - Microsoft Learn
How to resolve IP warming issues with Microsoft email accounts?
How to resolve Microsoft 451 4.7.650 error during email IP warm-up?
How to resolve Microsoft deliverability issues during IP warm up after being blocked?
Why are new email IPs taking longer to warm and remain in red on SNDS?
Why do new IPs remain red in Microsoft SNDS during warming?
Why does Microsoft SNDS data contradict email deliverability during IP warming?
