Summary
The necessity of double opt-in (DOI) in email marketing is a nuanced issue. Experts, marketers, and documentation from various sources agree that DOI offers significant advantages, especially for small senders, those prioritizing list quality, and businesses needing to comply with GDPR. It improves deliverability, protects sender reputation, reduces spam complaints, and fosters trust. However, some argue that single opt-in can be viable for established brands with clean data and robust anti-spam measures. DOI is viewed as a useful tool, but not always the *only* or *best* option, with alternatives and hybrid approaches considered depending on the specific context and business goals.
Key findings
- Deliverability Boost: DOI improves deliverability rates by ensuring engaged and valid email addresses.
- Reputation Protection: DOI protects sender reputation by minimizing spam complaints and maximizing engagement.
- Legal Compliance (GDPR): DOI ensures explicit consent, crucial for GDPR and other privacy regulations.
- Trust & Brand Image: DOI demonstrates a commitment to data privacy, building trust with subscribers.
- Smaller Senders Benefit Most: DOI is especially valuable for small senders to avoid blocklists and maintain deliverability.
- Alternatives Exist: Single opt-in, with robust anti-spam, can be viable for established brands focusing on rapid growth.
- List Hygiene: DOI ensures a cleaner, more engaged email list, reducing bounce rates.
Key considerations
- Business Objectives: Prioritize list growth vs. engagement and deliverability when choosing opt-in methods.
- Data Quality Practices: Assess the strength of your anti-spam measures and data hygiene protocols.
- Legal Requirements: Understand and comply with data privacy regulations, especially GDPR.
- Audience Understanding: Well a well known audience and pre-existing brand might make single-opt in viable.
- List Management: Regularly clean and segment your list, regardless of opt-in method, to maintain engagement.
- Cost Analysis: Weigh the cost of losing subscribers to DOI against the risks of poor deliverability from single opt-in.
- Sender Size: Smaller Senders are likely to be affected more than larger senders if they have delivery problems.
What email marketers say
13 marketer opinions
The necessity of double opt-in (DOI) in email marketing depends on various factors. While some marketers argue it's not always crucial, especially for senders with clean data and strong reputations, others emphasize its importance for list quality, deliverability, legal compliance (GDPR), and sender reputation. Alternatives to DOI, such as single opt-in with robust anti-spam measures, or hybrid approaches like applying COI to non-paid signups, are also considered. Ultimately, the decision hinges on balancing the desire for rapid list growth with the need for a highly engaged and compliant subscriber base.
Key opinions
- List Quality: DOI ensures a cleaner, more engaged list, reducing bounce rates and spam complaints.
- Deliverability: DOI improves deliverability by confirming subscriber interest and avoiding sending to invalid or uninterested addresses.
- Legal Compliance: DOI is crucial for GDPR compliance, demonstrating explicit consent from subscribers.
- Sender Reputation: DOI protects sender reputation by minimizing spam complaints and maximizing engagement.
- Alternatives Exist: Single opt-in with strong anti-spam measures or hybrid approaches can be viable alternatives in certain scenarios.
- Data Security: DOI helps protect against emailing personally identifiable information (PII) to spam traps, enhancing data security.
Key considerations
- Business Goals: Determine whether your priority is rapid list growth or a highly engaged subscriber base.
- Data Quality: Assess the cleanliness of your data and the effectiveness of your anti-spam measures.
- Legal Requirements: Consider the legal requirements in your operating region, particularly GDPR and other privacy regulations.
- List Size: For smaller lists, each email address is more critical, making DOI more valuable to filter out bad addresses.
- Alternative Costs: Compare the opportunity cost of losing potential subscribers who don't confirm via DOI with the risk of poor deliverability and damage to your sender reputation.
- Brand Reputation: For senders with an established brand, it may be possible to leverage Single-Opt in to ensure rapid list growth.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Entrepreneur.com answers that double opt-in is necessary when you need to demonstrate to your audience that your company takes their personal data privacy seriously, helping to build trust in your business.
29 Aug 2022 - Entrepreneur.com
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks sees no drawbacks to DOI, suggesting even a 'faux' version provides valuable engagement data for analysis and segmentation.
8 Feb 2025 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
5 expert opinions
Experts generally agree that double opt-in (DOI) offers significant advantages, particularly for smaller senders or when list hygiene, deliverability, and legal compliance are paramount. DOI can protect against blocklists, limit complaints, safeguard sender reputation, and ensure explicit consent, aligning with GDPR requirements. While considered a useful tool, some experts acknowledge that DOI might not always be the most suitable approach, and other methods may prove more effective depending on the specific context.
Key opinions
- Protection for Small Senders: DOI is particularly beneficial for small senders, providing a safeguard against blocklists.
- Client Preference: If a client wants to implement DOI, it's generally advisable to support their decision, given its widespread acceptance and user familiarity.
- General-Purpose Tool: DOI serves as a versatile tool, although its effectiveness may vary depending on the situation, with alternative methods potentially being more appropriate.
- List Hygiene and Deliverability: DOI significantly improves list hygiene and deliverability by ensuring that only genuinely interested subscribers are included.
- Legal Compliance: DOI is crucial for legal compliance, especially with GDPR, as it demonstrates explicit consent from subscribers to receive emails.
- Business Protection: DOI safeguards your business by limiting complaints, protecting your reputation, and ensuring you have permission to send.
Key considerations
- Sender Size: Smaller senders benefit more from DOI due to heightened risk of blocklisting.
- Client Objectives: Consider the client's objectives and comfort level when deciding whether to implement DOI.
- Specific Context: Evaluate the specific circumstances and determine if DOI is the most appropriate solution or if alternative methods might be more effective.
- Legal Landscape: Be aware of and comply with relevant legal requirements, particularly GDPR, when managing email lists.
- Hygiene is Vital: If the cost of lost deliverability outweighs the cost of those not confirming, then DOI is required.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks recommends DOI for small senders to protect against blocklists, especially hyperlocal news and newsletter senders.
30 Nov 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks advises against dissuading clients who want DOI, suggesting confirmations are common enough that most users understand the process and those who don't may not be valuable customers.
11 Jan 2025 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
3 technical articles
Email marketing platform documentation consistently emphasizes that double opt-in (DOI) is necessary to ensure high-quality subscribers, improve deliverability rates, protect sender reputation, and comply with GDPR and other privacy regulations. DOI helps to filter out invalid or uninterested email addresses, minimize spam complaints, and maximize engagement metrics.
Key findings
- High-Quality Subscribers: DOI guarantees that subscribers are genuinely interested in your content.
- Improved Deliverability: DOI significantly improves deliverability rates by ensuring only valid and engaged email addresses are added to your list.
- Sender Reputation: DOI protects your sender reputation by sending only to subscribers who have confirmed their interest.
- GDPR Compliance: DOI assists in complying with GDPR and other privacy regulations.
- Spam Reduction: DOI reduces spam complaints by filtering out uninterested users.
- Engagement: DOI improves engagement metrics by only sending to interested and validated users.
Key considerations
- Deliverability Goals: If maintaining high deliverability is a top priority, DOI is essential.
- List Quality Goals: If building a high-quality, engaged subscriber list is important, DOI is the best approach.
- Regulatory Compliance: If operating in regions with strict privacy regulations like GDPR, DOI is a must.
- Resource Investment: The implementation of DOI needs to be taken into consideration.
Technical article
Documentation from Mailchimp answers that double opt-in is necessary to protect your sender reputation by only sending to subscribers who have confirmed their interest, helping you avoid spam complaints and improve engagement metrics.
1 Sep 2022 - Mailchimp
Technical article
Documentation from Sendinblue explains that double opt-in is necessary when you want to ensure high-quality subscribers who are genuinely interested in your content, improve deliverability, and comply with GDPR and other privacy regulations.
27 Aug 2022 - Sendinblue
Are B2B lead vendors' claims of opt-in leads reliable?
Do email marketing opt-outs ever expire?
How can I ensure deliverability when many signups are from qq.com addresses and what steps can I take to prevent spam signups?
How can I prevent nefarious email signups using rate limiting, reCAPTCHA, and double opt-in?
Is COI/DOI email opt-in still a relevant best practice?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of double signing DKIM by ESPs?
