Summary
Across expert opinions, marketer insights, and legal documentation, a clear consensus emerges: the CAN-SPAM Act does *not* legally require retaining unsubscribed email addresses for four years. CAN-SPAM primarily mandates honoring opt-out requests promptly (usually within 10 business days) and providing clear unsubscribe mechanisms. The often-cited four-year figure likely stems from internal compliance policies, liability concerns, or other legal considerations beyond CAN-SPAM. A consistent recommendation is to maintain a suppression list to prevent re-mailing unsubscribed contacts, even if long-term data retention isn't practiced.
Key findings
- No 4-Year Mandate: The CAN-SPAM Act does not mandate retaining unsubscribed email addresses for a period of four years.
- Prompt Opt-Out Compliance: CAN-SPAM's core requirement is to promptly honor opt-out requests, typically within 10 business days.
- Suppression Lists are Key: Maintaining a suppression list is widely considered a best practice to avoid re-mailing unsubscribed contacts.
- Internal/External Drivers: The four-year figure likely arises from internal compliance policies, broader legal considerations, or risk management, rather than CAN-SPAM itself.
Key considerations
- Assess Liability: Evaluate potential liability and compliance risks associated with data retention practices.
- Align with Policies: Ensure data retention aligns with internal compliance policies and legal counsel's advice.
- Suppression List Management: Implement and meticulously maintain a suppression list to prevent accidental re-engagement with unsubscribed users.
- Comply with CAN-SPAM: Ensure that opt-out mechanisms are clear, accessible, and promptly honored, meeting CAN-SPAM requirements.
What email marketers say
7 marketer opinions
The consensus among email marketers and legal interpretations of the CAN-SPAM Act is that there's no explicit legal requirement to retain unsubscribed email addresses for four years. The act emphasizes honoring opt-out requests promptly, typically within 10 business days. The four-year retention period might stem from internal compliance policies, liability concerns, or other legal considerations outside of CAN-SPAM. Maintaining a suppression list to avoid re-mailing unsubscribed users is considered best practice, even if the data isn't retained long-term.
Key opinions
- No Legal Mandate: CAN-SPAM Act does not mandate a four-year retention period for unsubscribed email addresses.
- Prompt Opt-Out: CAN-SPAM Act requires businesses to honor opt-out requests quickly (usually within 10 business days).
- Suppression Lists: Maintaining suppression lists to avoid re-mailing unsubscribed users is a widely recommended best practice.
- Internal Policies: A four-year retention policy is likely driven by internal compliance, risk mitigation, or other legal factors beyond CAN-SPAM.
Key considerations
- Liability: Assess your own liability concerns related to data retention and potential CAN-SPAM violations.
- Internal Compliance: Align data retention policies with internal compliance requirements and legal advice specific to your organization.
- Suppression List Management: Implement and maintain a robust suppression list to prevent accidental re-mailing of unsubscribed contacts.
- Data Privacy: Ensure data retention practices comply with broader data privacy regulations and respect subscriber choices.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks confirms 4 years is not a legal requirement and must be an internal requirement. Recommends deletion rather than retention. 4 years seems a long time to store data for someone who doesn't want your emails. If they want to keep it, and there is no privacy policy that this company has published that indicates against this, then leave it be.
26 Aug 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from StackExchange explains that there is no regulation about retaining email address from users who have unsubscribed. They highlight it is critical to never re-mail those users. Best practice is to remove the email from active campaigns, but retain on a suppression list.
14 May 2023 - StackExchange
What the experts say
2 expert opinions
Both experts agree that CAN-SPAM does not legally require keeping unsubscribed email addresses for four years. The regulation focuses on promptly honoring opt-out requests. The four-year period likely originates from internal compliance policies or broader legal considerations. Maintaining a suppression list is recommended as a best practice to prevent accidental re-mailing.
Key opinions
- No CAN-SPAM Requirement: There is no legal requirement under CAN-SPAM to retain unsubscribed email addresses for four years.
- Honor Opt-Outs Promptly: CAN-SPAM focuses on honoring opt-out requests in a timely manner.
- Internal Compliance or Other Laws: The four-year retention period may be driven by internal policies or other legal considerations outside of CAN-SPAM.
- Suppression List Recommended: Maintaining a suppression list is recommended to prevent re-mailing unsubscribed users.
Key considerations
- Compliance Policies: Review and align data retention policies with internal compliance and legal advice.
- Legal Considerations: Consider potential liability and other legal implications for your organization.
- Suppression List: Implement and maintain an effective suppression list management process.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise responds that CAN-SPAM dictates honoring opt-out requests promptly, but doesn't specify a required retention period for unsubscribed addresses. They suggest that the four-year figure might stem from internal compliance policies or other legal considerations beyond CAN-SPAM itself.
12 Jun 2025 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that keeping unsubscribes for four years is not a CAN-SPAM requirement and might conflict with data deletion requests. Al suggests the client might be trying to prevent accidental remailing of an opt-out, which can be handled with a delete instead of a suppression list. He advises ignoring it unless it affects a specific workflow.
1 Jul 2023 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
3 technical articles
Legal documentation consistently indicates that the CAN-SPAM Act doesn't mandate a four-year retention period for unsubscribed email addresses. The primary focus of CAN-SPAM is to ensure that businesses honor opt-out requests promptly, typically within 10 business days, and provide clear mechanisms for recipients to unsubscribe from future mailings.
Key findings
- No Retention Mandate: CAN-SPAM Act does not require retaining unsubscribed email addresses for four years.
- Focus on Opt-Out: The Act emphasizes honoring opt-out requests within 10 business days.
- Clear Unsubscribe Method: Businesses must provide a clear and conspicuous method for recipients to unsubscribe.
Key considerations
- Compliance with CAN-SPAM: Ensure your email marketing practices comply with CAN-SPAM's requirements for honoring opt-out requests and providing unsubscribe mechanisms.
- Data Retention Policies: Develop data retention policies that align with your business needs while respecting user privacy and adhering to all applicable laws.
- Prompt Opt-Out Processing: Establish processes to promptly process and honor unsubscribe requests to avoid legal penalties.
Technical article
Documentation from FTC explains that the CAN-SPAM Act requires businesses to honor opt-out requests within 10 business days and provides mechanisms for recipients to unsubscribe from future mailings. It does not specify a data retention period of four years for unsubscribed email addresses.
31 May 2025 - FTC.gov
Technical article
Documentation from Termly explains that CAN-SPAM mandates a clear and conspicuous method for recipients to opt out of receiving future emails. They note that while CAN-SPAM doesn't specify a retention period for unsubscribed emails, it requires honoring opt-out requests promptly to avoid legal penalties.
23 Dec 2024 - Termly
Are re-engagement email subject lines and practices deceptive and how should you deal with engaging with old leads and unsubscribes?
Are unsubscribe links in cold emails beneficial or harmful?
Can an ESP allow its users to use the ESP's physical address in marketing emails under CAN-SPAM?
Do commercial emails in the USA and Canada require a physical address?
Do email marketing opt-outs ever expire?
Does CAN-SPAM require a physical address in transactional emails?
