Summary
The effectiveness of IP warming services is a debated topic. Many sources, including email marketers and technical documentation from major platforms like Amazon SES, Google, and Microsoft, advocate for IP warming as a crucial step for new IPs or when experiencing deliverability issues. They emphasize the importance of gradually increasing email volume to establish a positive sender reputation with ISPs and avoid spam filters. A consistent sending pattern is also frequently highlighted. However, some experts and marketers express skepticism, suggesting that IP warming services provide a 'fake' or temporary reputation, and it's more effective to address the root causes of deliverability problems and maintain clean sending practices. They also warn of potential penalties from ISPs for using 'shady' engagement services.
Key findings
- Essential for New IPs (Pro): Many consider IP warming essential for establishing a good sender reputation with ISPs, especially for new IPs.
- Gradual Volume Increase: A key element of IP warming is gradually increasing email volume over time.
- Improved IP Reputation: Proper IP warming improves IP reputation and overall deliverability.
- Prevents Spam Filtering: IP warming can help avoid being flagged as spam and improve inbox placement.
- Consistent Sending Pattern: Maintaining a consistent sending pattern is crucial for building a good reputation.
- Fake Reputation (Con): Some argue that IP warming services create a temporary or 'fake' reputation.
- Address Root Causes: An alternative perspective is to focus on fixing the underlying causes of deliverability issues.
- Potential Penalties: There's a potential risk of ISPs penalizing those who use 'shady' IP warming services.
Key considerations
- Assess Current Situation: Evaluate whether you're dealing with a new IP or existing deliverability problems.
- Diagnose Deliverability Issues: Identify and address the root causes of any deliverability challenges before considering IP warming.
- Choose Reputable Services: If using an IP warming service, thoroughly research and vet the provider.
- Implement Gradual Schedule: Create a consistent and gradual schedule for increasing email volume.
- Monitor IP Reputation: Regularly monitor your IP reputation using tools provided by ISPs.
- Prioritize Best Practices: Focus on sustainable email marketing practices, such as list hygiene and engagement, for long-term deliverability success.
- Start with Engaged Users: When warming up an IP, start by sending to your most engaged subscribers.
What email marketers say
12 marketer opinions
The effectiveness of IP warming services for improving email deliverability is a debated topic. Some experts and marketers believe IP warming is crucial for establishing a positive sender reputation with ISPs, especially when using new IPs or experiencing deliverability issues. This involves gradually increasing sending volume to avoid being flagged as spam and establishing trust. Others view IP warming services as 'shady' or providing only a temporary 'fake' reputation, arguing that it's better to address the underlying issues causing deliverability problems and fix sending patterns. They warn that ISPs might punish those using fake engagement services.
Key opinions
- Essential for New IPs: IP warming is generally considered essential for new IPs to establish a sender reputation with ISPs.
- Gradual Increase: The process involves gradually increasing sending volume over time.
- Fix Sending Patterns: Some argue it's better to fix underlying sending pattern issues rather than rely on warming services.
- Fake Reputation: Concerns exist that IP warming services provide a 'fake' reputation that won't last.
- Potential Penalties: There is potential risk of ISPs penalizing those using fake engagement services.
- Consistency is Key: Maintaining consistent sending habits helps establish trust with ISPs.
Key considerations
- Assess Deliverability Issues: Before using IP warming services, assess the root cause of any deliverability problems.
- Sending Practices: Ensure clean and legitimate sending practices are in place.
- Alternative Solutions: Consider alternative solutions like improving list hygiene and engagement.
- Long-Term Strategy: Develop a long-term email deliverability strategy focused on building a genuine reputation.
- Start with Engaged Subscribers: When warming up, start by sending to your most engaged subscribers.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Mailjet Blog explains that IP warming is crucial for new IPs to establish a sender reputation with ISPs. It involves gradually increasing sending volume to avoid being flagged as spam.
24 May 2024 - Mailjet Blog
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks states that IP warming services provide fake reputation that will be supplanted when real content is sent.
30 Jan 2022 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
2 expert opinions
Experts have differing views on IP warming services. One expert (Steve Linford) emphasizes IP warming's importance in establishing a good sending reputation, especially on new IP addresses, stressing gradual volume increases and clean sending practices but acknowledges 'shady practices' exist. Another expert (Laura Atkins) advises fixing underlying deliverability issues instead of relying on IP warming or similar services.
Key opinions
- Essential for Reputation (Pro): IP warming helps establish a good sender reputation, particularly when transitioning to a new IP address range.
- Focus on Root Cause (Con): Addressing the root cause of deliverability problems is a more effective long-term solution than relying on quick fixes like IP warming.
- Clean Sending Practices: Maintaining clean sending practices is crucial for successful IP warming.
- Shady Practices Exist: The landscape of IP warming services contains potentially unreliable or unethical practices.
Key considerations
- New IP vs. Existing Issues: Determine whether you're dealing with a new IP address or pre-existing deliverability problems.
- Thorough Problem Diagnosis: Investigate and resolve the underlying causes of deliverability challenges.
- Service Due Diligence: Thoroughly research and vet any IP warming service before engaging.
- Sustainable Practices: Prioritize sustainable email marketing practices for long-term deliverability success.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise (Laura Atkins) responds that the user should invest in fixing the root cause of the deliverability issues rather than looking for services to fix issues, such as IP warming.
13 Oct 2021 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource (Steve Linford) explains that IP warming is essential for establishing a good sending reputation, especially when moving to a new IP address range. It helps build trust with ISPs by gradually increasing volume and maintaining clean sending practices. He notes there's a lot of shady practices.
25 Nov 2021 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
Technical documentation from various sources including Amazon SES, Google Postmaster Tools, Microsoft SNDS, MailChannels, and M3AAWG consistently emphasizes the importance of IP warming for improving email deliverability. They agree that IP warming, involving a gradual increase in email volume from a new IP address, is a best practice to establish a positive sender reputation with ISPs and avoid spam filters. A consistent sending pattern is also highlighted as a crucial factor.
Key findings
- Essential for New IPs: IP warming is considered a best practice when starting to send email from a new IP address.
- Gradual Increase in Volume: The process involves gradually increasing the volume of email sent over time.
- Improves IP Reputation: Warming up IPs is considered the best way to improve your reputation.
- Avoids Spam Filters: It helps to build sender reputation and avoid being filtered as spam.
- Consistent Sending Pattern: A consistent sending pattern is crucial for building a solid sender reputation.
Key considerations
- New IP Implementation: IP warming is particularly important when transitioning to a new IP address.
- Consistent Schedule: Implement a consistent and gradual schedule for increasing email volume.
- Monitor Reputation: Monitor your IP reputation using tools like Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS.
- High-Volume Sending: IP warming is especially crucial if you plan to send a high volume of email.
Technical article
Documentation from MailChannels explains that IP warming is the practice of gradually increasing the volume of email sent from a new IP address. This helps establish a positive sender reputation with email providers and improves deliverability.
12 Feb 2024 - MailChannels
Technical article
Documentation from Google explains through Google Postmaster Tools that IP reputation is critical to getting emails delivered and that warming up your IP is the best way to improve your reputation.
1 Jul 2021 - Google
Are auto warming/deliverability improvement services for email marketing sketchy?
Are domain warmup tools like Lemwarm or WarmupInbox effective and safe to use?
Are email warm-up tools like Warmy.io effective and legal?
Do I need an IP warm-up when moving to a new ESP with shared IPs?
How can I automate IP warmup in Iterable?
How do I warm up a new IP address for transactional emails?
How do I warm up new IP addresses for email sending?
