Summary
Google Workspace emails with broken DKIM records are suddenly landing in spam primarily due to the stringent new sender requirements Google implemented in early 2024. These updates mandate strong email authentication, including proper DKIM and DMARC alignment, for all senders. Previously, minor DKIM misconfigurations might have gone unnoticed, but now they lead to immediate consequences such as emails being flagged as suspicious, routed directly to spam folders, or outright rejected. This change reflects Google's increased focus on combating phishing and spam by prioritizing authenticated email and enforcing DMARC policies more rigorously. The issue is not related to client authentication methods like OAuth2, but rather to pre-existing server-side authentication setup issues that are now being strictly enforced.
Key findings
- Stricter Google Enforcement: Beginning in February 2024, Google (and Yahoo) implemented significantly stricter sender requirements, mandating robust email authentication including SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. This new enforcement explains the sudden change in deliverability.
- DKIM Failure Consequences: A broken DKIM record means an email's digital signature cannot be validated, signaling to recipient servers that the email may not be legitimate. This directly violates Google's new rules, causing emails to be flagged as suspicious and routed directly to spam or rejected.
- DMARC Policy Impact: Google's increased reliance on DMARC policies means that if an email fails DKIM validation and the domain's DMARC policy is set to 'quarantine' or 'reject,' the email will suddenly land in spam or be blocked.
- Pre-existing Issues Surfacing: Many observed deliverability issues for Google Workspace emails with broken DKIM records are not due to new system changes like OAuth requirements, but rather pre-existing misconfigurations that are now being strictly penalized by Google's tightened filters.
- Impact on Google Workspace: Numerous Google Workspace users and IT administrators have reported a sudden increase in their outgoing emails being classified as spam due to DKIM or SPF misconfigurations, directly aligning with Google's strengthened security and authentication measures.
Key considerations
- Verify DKIM and SPF: Regularly check and correct any misconfigurations in your DKIM, SPF, and DMARC records, as even minor issues that previously went unnoticed are now causing deliverability problems.
- Distinguish Auth Types: Understand that client authentication methods, such as OAuth2 for mail access, are entirely separate from server-side email authentication like DKIM, and one does not affect the other.
- Monitor Sender Reputation: Be aware that a broken DKIM record immediately damages your sender reputation with providers like Google, triggering aggressive spam filtering.
- Review Google Guidelines: Familiarize yourself with Google's updated sender requirements for 2024, as non-compliance, particularly with authentication, will lead to emails being rejected or sent to spam.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
Google Workspace emails with broken DKIM records are suddenly landing in spam primarily because Google has significantly tightened its spam filters and authentication requirements, especially since early 2024. These updates mean even minor DKIM misconfigurations, which might have previously gone unnoticed, now lead to immediate consequences like emails being flagged as suspicious or routed directly to spam. This shift reflects Google's intensified commitment to combating phishing and spam by prioritizing authenticated email and rigorously enforcing DMARC policies. The sudden deliverability issue is not linked to client authentication methods such as OAuth2, but rather stems from pre-existing server-side authentication setup flaws whose impact has dramatically escalated due to Google's updated policies.
Key opinions
- Heightened Filter Sensitivity: Google's spam filters have been significantly tightened since early 2024, causing minor DKIM misconfigurations that previously went unnoticed to now trigger immediate spam classification.
- Direct Violation of New Rules: A broken DKIM record directly violates Google's stringent new sender requirements, effective early 2024, which mandate proper email authentication for all senders, leading to emails being flagged or rejected.
- Intensified DMARC Enforcement: Google's increased enforcement of DMARC policies means that if an email fails DKIM authentication and the domain's DMARC policy is set to quarantine or reject, it will suddenly land in the spam folder.
- Widespread Admin Observations: Numerous Google Workspace administrators and IT professionals have widely reported a sudden surge in outgoing emails being sent to spam, directly attributing this to misconfigured DKIM or SPF records.
- Evolving Deliverability Standards: Email deliverability standards are in constant evolution, and Google has recently become far more stringent, making a broken DKIM record a critical failure point that causes emails to suddenly land in spam.
Key considerations
- Prioritize Authentication Health: Ensure your domain's DKIM, SPF, and DMARC records are impeccably configured and consistently aligned, as Google's heightened scrutiny means even minor misconfigurations now have significant deliverability consequences.
- Conduct Regular Audits: Perform routine checks of your email authentication records. Proactive identification and correction of any DKIM or SPF discrepancies are crucial to prevent sudden spam classification.
- Heed Google's Strict Penalties: Recognize that Google now severely penalizes unauthenticated emails. A broken DKIM record is a critical red flag, causing emails to be immediately flagged as suspicious and routed to spam.
- Stay Informed on Guidelines: Continuously monitor and adapt to Google's evolving email sender requirements, particularly those concerning authentication, to maintain consistent deliverability and avoid unexpected filtering.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks explains that requiring OAuth2 for mail access is unrelated to email authentication. Marcel states that Google and others have required email authentication and alignment for some time. He attributes broken DKIM signatures to pre-existing setup issues, suggesting the recent observation is a coincidence rather than a new change.
10 Nov 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks shares that Google's sender guidelines, while sometimes strict on paper, should be checked for any violations if emails are experiencing deliverability issues.
9 Jan 2025 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
The sudden shift of Google Workspace emails with broken DKIM records into spam folders is a direct consequence of the new, more stringent sender requirements imposed by Google and Yahoo in early 2024. These updated guidelines mandate proper email authentication via SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for all senders, particularly bulk senders. When DKIM records are misconfigured or broken, emails fail authentication checks and are subsequently rejected or relegated to spam. It is crucial to understand that client authentication methods, such as OAuth, are entirely separate from how the email server applies DKIM signatures; therefore, changes to client connection methods do not impact server-side email authentication.
Key opinions
- Stricter 2024 Mandates: Google and Yahoo's new sender requirements, effective early 2024, now strictly enforce proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication for all email senders, especially bulk senders.
- Authentication Failure Impact: Emails, including those from Google Workspace, that have broken DKIM records or are otherwise unauthenticated will no longer reach the inbox and are instead likely to be sent to spam or outright rejected.
- OAuth Not the Cause: OAuth is a protocol for client authentication to the server and is entirely distinct from the server-side process of applying a DKIM signature; thus, changes to OAuth do not affect DKIM record validity or email deliverability.
Key considerations
- Verify All Authentication: It is essential to ensure that your domain's SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correctly configured and validated to comply with current email provider requirements, as even minor issues now lead to significant deliverability problems.
- Understand Authentication Types: Differentiate between client authentication, such as OAuth for connecting a user's mail client to a server, and server-side email authentication, like DKIM, which validates the sender's domain. They are separate processes.
- Prioritize Deliverability Health: Proactively address any authentication issues, as unauthenticated emails now face severe consequences, including spam placement or outright rejection, from major inbox providers like Google and Yahoo.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains that OAuth is for authenticating an email client to the server, allowing an end-user to send and receive. She clarifies that the email server is responsible for the DKIM signature, and this process is completely separate from OAuth. Laura firmly states there is no way that changing how a mail client connects to a server can alter how the server sends outbound mail.
21 Dec 2021 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that Google and Yahoo's new sender requirements, effective early 2024, mandate proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication for bulk senders. If email, including Google Workspace emails with broken DKIM records, is not correctly authenticated, it will not be delivered to the inbox and is likely to land in spam or be rejected. This new, stricter enforcement explains why emails with broken DKIM might suddenly face deliverability issues.
18 Dec 2021 - Word to the Wise
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
The recent surge in Google Workspace emails with broken DKIM records landing in spam stems from Google's escalated enforcement of email authentication standards. Since early 2024, a fundamental change has occurred: a faulty DKIM signature, which renders an email's digital authenticity unverifiable, now severely impairs sender reputation and frequently triggers DMARC alignment failures. This heightened scrutiny means that emails previously unaffected by minor misconfigurations are now immediately flagged as suspicious, often resulting in direct placement into spam folders or rejection, as major providers intensify their efforts to combat phishing and unwanted mail.
Key findings
- Stricter Authenticity Checks: As of February 2024, Google began enforcing significantly stricter sender requirements, mandating robust email authentication including SPF and DKIM, making previously unnoticed broken DKIM records a critical failure point.
- Sender Reputation Collapse: A suddenly broken DKIM record severely damages a sender's reputation, as it indicates a lack of authenticity or potential spoofing, which immediately triggers aggressive spam filtering.
- DMARC Alignment Failure: Google's increased reliance on DMARC policies means that a broken DKIM record leads to DMARC alignment failure, causing emails to be quarantined or rejected based on the domain's DMARC policy (p=quarantine or p=reject).
- Enhanced Spam Filtering: Major email providers like Google are now more aggressively filtering unauthenticated or improperly authenticated emails to combat phishing and spam, ensuring that emails with broken DKIM are unlikely to reach the inbox.
- Invalid Digital Signature: A broken DKIM record means an email's digital signature cannot be validated, making the email appear illegitimate and immediately reducing its chances of successful delivery to the inbox.
Key considerations
- Validate DKIM Integrity: Regularly verify the integrity and proper configuration of your DKIM records, as any breakage or misconfiguration will now directly impact deliverability and lead to emails landing in spam.
- Monitor DMARC Reports: Utilize DMARC reports to identify and address email authentication failures, particularly those related to DKIM, as Google's strict enforcement means DMARC policies are now actively quarantining or rejecting failing emails.
- Maintain Sender Reputation: Understand that strong email authentication, including a valid DKIM, is fundamental to maintaining a positive sender reputation with major providers like Google, crucial for avoiding spam folders.
- Stay Current with Requirements: Continuously review and adapt to evolving sender requirements from major email providers, particularly Google's updated authentication mandates, to ensure ongoing compliance and optimal deliverability.
Technical article
Documentation from Google Workspace Admin Help explains that as of February 2024, Gmail began enforcing stricter sender requirements, including strong authentication like SPF and DKIM. Emails from senders who don't meet these requirements, especially with broken DKIM, are more likely to be rejected or sent to spam, explaining a sudden change.
27 Dec 2022 - Google Workspace Admin Help
Technical article
Documentation from Gmail Postmaster Tools highlights that strong authentication, including DKIM, SPF, and DMARC, is crucial for email deliverability. A sudden increase in emails landing in spam, particularly with broken DKIM, often indicates a failure to meet Gmail's expected authentication standards, which have been progressively tightened.
25 May 2024 - Gmail Postmaster Tools
![Don't Panic If Your Gmail Is Going To Spam [Here's a FIX!]](https://emailwarmup.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Stop-Your-Outlook-Emails-Going-To-Spam-With-An-Easy-Fix-4_11zon.png)
Why are legitimate GSuite emails going to spam after a domain impersonation attempt and DMARC policy change?
Why are my emails suddenly going to spam in Gmail?
Why are operational emails from G Suite hosted forms going to Outlook spam even after fixing SPF and DKIM?
Why are transactional emails with passing SPF, DKIM, and DMARC landing in spam?
Why has Gmail deliverability dropped recently and emails are going to spam?
Why is my customer service email being flagged as spam by Google even with DKIM and SPF?
