What is the primary difference between ProDMARC and ELK DMARC?

The primary difference lies in their deployment model and target audience. ProDMARC is a commercial, hosted SaaS solution offering a managed experience with dedicated support and a user-friendly interface. ELK DMARC is an open-source, self-hosted solution that provides immense flexibility and control, but requires significant technical expertise to deploy and maintain on your own infrastructure.

Does ELK DMARC offer SPF flattening or BIMI support?

No, ELK DMARC does not natively offer features like SPF flattening or integrated BIMI support. As an open-source DMARC reporting tool built on the ELK stack, its focus is on visualizing DMARC aggregate reports. Implementing these advanced email authentication features would require additional tools or manual configuration.

Which product is better for an organization with limited IT resources?

For organizations with limited IT resources, ProDMARC would generally be the better choice. Its managed service, intuitive interface, and dedicated customer support significantly reduce the technical burden of DMARC implementation and ongoing monitoring. ELK DMARC requires considerable technical expertise for setup and maintenance.

Can I get a free trial for either ProDMARC or ELK DMARC?

ProDMARC offers a 15-day free trial to evaluate its services. ELK DMARC is open-source software, meaning the core software is free to download and use, though you will incur costs for the underlying server infrastructure required to host it.

Is ELK DMARC suitable for MSPs managing multiple client domains?

ELK DMARC can be suitable for MSPs, but it requires significant technical investment to configure for multi-tenancy and to develop custom dashboards for each client. MSPs with strong in-house ELK stack expertise and a desire for deep customization might find it viable, but it's not an out-of-the-box multi-tenant solution like some commercial offerings.

ProDMARC vs ELK DMARC

Choose ProDMARC for managed ease, ELK DMARC for open-source control.

4.8 / 5(23)

Compare to Suped

ELK DMARC

0 / 5(0)

Compare to Suped

ELK DMARC

Compare product functionality

Feature set

ELK DMARC

ProDMARC is a comprehensive platform, offering a wide array of features designed to simplify DMARC implementation and management. We have found it provides robust DMARC reporting, aggregating RUA (aggregate) reports into an easily digestible format, allowing us to quickly identify legitimate and fraudulent sending sources. Its interface is geared towards practical application, making policy enforcement straightforward.

Beyond core DMARC, ProDMARC extends its functionality to include SPF flattening, a crucial feature for domains with many legitimate sending services. It also offers monitoring for BIMI (Brand Indicators for Message Identification) and MTA-STS/TLS-RPT, which are important for advanced email security and brand presentation. The platform’s ability to detect spoofing and track forwarding is quite effective, providing a holistic view of email traffic.

ELK DMARC is an open-source solution built on the powerful ELK stack (Elasticsearch, Logstash, Kibana). This means its feature set is inherently flexible and highly customizable, depending on how users configure the underlying components. At its core, it excels at DMARC report analysis, ingesting raw aggregate reports and presenting them through Kibana dashboards.

While ELK DMARC provides the foundational tools for DMARC monitoring, its features are more 'build-your-own.' It detects sources and helps with spoof detection by visualising authentication failures, but advanced capabilities like SPF flattening or integrated BIMI monitoring are not native. Its strength lies in providing direct access to the raw data, allowing technical users to craft custom queries and reports.

ELK DMARC

How easy is each product to use

User experience

ELK DMARC

ProDMARC is designed with user-friendliness in mind, catering to both technical and non-technical users. We've found its dashboard intuitive, presenting complex DMARC data through clear visualizations and summaries. The process for identifying threats, adjusting policies, and understanding compliance is streamlined, which is a significant advantage for day-to-day operations.

Setting up a domain and configuring DMARC records is guided, though some users have noted the initial configuration could be more streamlined. Once configured, the platform offers automated reporting and actionable insights, reducing the ongoing effort required to maintain a strong email security posture. It's a 'set it and largely forget it' solution, with periodic check-ins.

The user experience with ELK DMARC is fundamentally different, relying heavily on the user's familiarity with the ELK stack. For those experienced with Kibana, customizing dashboards and drilling into data is powerful and flexible. However, for users without this expertise, the initial setup and ongoing management can be steep.

There's no pre-packaged, intuitive interface like a commercial product. While the open-source community provides some guides, the responsibility for deployment, maintenance, and customization rests entirely with the user. This offers unparalleled control but demands a significant investment in time and technical skill, making it less accessible for those seeking an out-of-the-box solution.

ELK DMARC

Which product has the best support

Support

ELK DMARC

ProDMARC consistently receives high praise for its customer support, a sentiment we echo based on our understanding of user feedback. Their team is known for being prompt, knowledgeable, and proactive, providing valuable assistance with DMARC implementation, troubleshooting, and general queries. This level of dedicated support is a major advantage for commercial platforms.

Users report that issues are resolved quickly, and the support team often goes the extra mile to ensure DMARC policies are correctly enforced and optimized. This hands-on assistance is invaluable, especially for organizations that may not have in-house DMARC experts, helping them navigate complex email authentication challenges effectively.

As an open-source project, ELK DMARC does not offer commercial support channels in the traditional sense. Support primarily comes from the open-source community, including GitHub issues, forums, and potentially direct engagement with the project's maintainers. This model means support can vary in responsiveness and depth.

While community support can be robust for common issues, complex or niche problems might require significant self-reliance or hiring external experts. There's no service level agreement (SLA) or dedicated team to lean on. This DIY approach to support aligns with the self-hosted nature of ELK DMARC, making it suitable for organizations with strong internal technical capabilities.

ELK DMARC

Who should use each product

Suitability

ELK DMARC

ProDMARC is particularly well-suited for organizations that prioritize ease of use, comprehensive features, and dedicated support. We see it as an excellent choice for enterprises and larger mid-market companies seeking a managed solution to enhance their email security posture without needing deep in-house DMARC expertise. Its multi-tenancy capabilities also make it attractive for MSPs managing multiple client domains.

SMBs can also benefit from ProDMARC's simplified approach, as it allows them to achieve DMARC compliance and protection against spoofing and phishing with minimal technical overhead. It's ideal for those who value a polished, turn-key solution and are willing to invest in a commercial product for peace of mind and efficient management.

ELK DMARC is best for technically proficient organizations, particularly those already utilizing the ELK stack or with significant DevOps resources. We find it to be a strong option for enterprises or even technically advanced SMBs that require ultimate control over their data, infrastructure, and reporting customizations. MSPs with a robust technical team could also leverage it for client management, provided they build out the necessary tooling.

It's less suitable for organizations seeking a plug-and-play solution or those without the technical staff to deploy, maintain, and customize an open-source stack. The upfront time and resource investment for infrastructure and configuration mean it appeals most to those who value open-source flexibility and cost savings on software licensing over managed services.

ELK DMARC

How does ProDMARC compare with ELK DMARC?

ELK DMARC

DMARC report analysis

Aggregates and visualizes DMARC reports.

Source detection

Identifies email sending sources.

Forward detection

Ability to detect email forwarding.

Spoof detection

Identifies email spoofing attempts.

Notifications and alerts

Automated alerts for issues.

Configurable within ELK stack

Reporting

Pre-built and custom reports.

Via Kibana dashboards

API

Programmatic access for integration.

Elasticsearch API access

Multi-tenancy

Manage multiple domains/clients.

Configurable with ELK stack

SPF flattening

Automated SPF record optimization.

Hosted DMARC

SaaS solution hosted by vendor.

Self-hosted solution

BIMI

Support for BIMI records.

MTA-STS/TLS-RPT

Monitoring for MTA-STS and TLS-RPT.

Blocklists and reputation

Integration with blocklists (or blacklists) and reputation checks.

AI copilot

AI-powered assistance for DMARC.

DNS monitoring

Monitors DNS record health.

Self hostable

Can be installed and run on-premise.

Free trial/free tier

Ability to try or use for free.

15-day free trial

Open-source, free software

Drawbacks and what to watch out for

When considering drawbacks, ProDMARC users occasionally point to pricing in some regions not being competitive and a desire for more advanced customization options. ELK DMARC, being a self-hosted open-source solution, inherently comes with the drawback of requiring significant technical expertise and infrastructure investment for deployment and maintenance, making it less accessible for many.

We have pulled the average ratings from G2 for each product, and also included the most recent negative reviews for each product in full. Positive reviews tend to have less detail and have a higher chance of being fraudulent, so negative reviews are a better signal for your decision.

4.8 / 5(23)

ELK DMARC

0 / 5(0)

Great Support and DMARC management

4.5 / 5

What do you like best about ProDMARC? What I like best is its intuitive dashboard and automated reporting, which make it easy to monitor DMARC compliance across domains. What do you dislike about ProDMARC? Some advanced users may find the policy customization options less flexible compared to manual DMARC implementations. What problems is ProDMARC solving and how is that benefiting you? It simplifies policy enforcement and helps strengthen email security with minimal effort. A great tool for any organization looking to improve email trust and deliverability.

Rishabh S.

Analyst Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

No G2 reviews

G2 is the most popular review platform for DMARC products, so this is a strong signal that this product is not popular.

Received very positive feedback from our end customers regarding the product and service quality.

4.5 / 5

What do you like best about ProDMARC? Previous Response: The customer support team provides immediate responses, which I really appreciate. What do you dislike about ProDMARC? Previous Response: The pricing in this region is not competitive. As a result, customers and partners are considering alternative options to find more affordable solutions. What problems is ProDMARC solving and how is that benefiting you? Visibility and security of the Domain's

robin j.

Head of Sales & Partnership Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)

Excellent Customer Support

4.5 / 5

What do you like best about ProDMARC? Consolidated ProDMARC Reports including Compliance and Weekly Failure Reports without What do you dislike about ProDMARC? Deep analysis of forensic report RUF is required. What problems is ProDMARC solving and how is that benefiting you? 1. It enables DMARC enforcement and reject spoofed emails. 2. Helps in providing centralized dashboard. 3. Monitoring of emails on behalf of us. 4. Helps in compliance checks and notifying if mails are getting delivered/passed/failed through either SPF or DKIM.

Pranav K.

Senior Manager Information Security Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

ProDMARC DMARC and BIMI providing awesome support

4.5 / 5

What do you like best about ProDMARC? ProDMARC and BIMI providing valuable support for Mail security What do you dislike about ProDMARC? Enchasing the Product Dashboard and Reporting Features What problems is ProDMARC solving and how is that benefiting you? Providing DMARC and SPF effective filtering based on Mail SPAM based filtering

Verified User in Insurance

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

Improved our email security posture with seamless implementation and reliable support

4.5 / 5

What do you like best about ProDMARC? ProDMARC’s intuitive interface and proactive support make DMARC implementation and monitoring effortless and effective. What do you dislike about ProDMARC? While ProDMARC offers excellent functionality, the initial configuration process could be more streamlined for quicker onboarding What problems is ProDMARC solving and how is that benefiting you? ProDMARC helps us combat email spoofing and phishing by enforcing DMARC policies effectively. This has significantly improved our domain reputation, reduced fraudulent email risks, and enhanced overall email security

Verified User in Insurance

Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)

Pricing

ProDMARC operates on a commercial model where pricing details are provided upon contact, while ELK DMARC is an open-source solution, meaning the software itself is free but requires investment in infrastructure and technical resources.

ELK DMARC

Small

Up to 10k emails / month

Contact for pricing

Self-host, infra costs apply

Medium

Up to 100k emails / month

Contact for pricing

Self-host, infra costs apply

Large

Up to 1 million emails / month

Contact for pricing