Suped

Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection vs DMARC-SRG

Choose Barracuda DFP for integrated security, DMARC-SRG for self-hosted control.
DMARC-SRG
Compare to Suped
Logo
DMARC-SRG
First comparison imageSecond comparison image
Blocklist checker
Check your domain or IP against 144 blocklists.
www.spamhaus.org logoSpamhaus0spam.org logo0Spam
Blocklist icon
Abusix
Blocklist icon
Barracuda Networks
www.spamcop.net logoCisco
Blocklist icon
Mailspike
www.nosolicitado.org logoNoSolicitado
Blocklist icon
SURBL
Blocklist icon
UCEPROTECT
uribl.com logoURIBL
Blocklist icon
8086 Consultancy
abuse.ro logoabuse.rowiki.alphanet.ch logoALPHANETanonmails.de logoAnonmailsascams.com logoAscamswww.blockedservers.com logoBLOCKEDSERVERS
Blocklist icon
Brukalai.lt
dnsbl.calivent.com.pe logoCalivent Networks
Blocklist icon
dan.me.uk
Blocklist icon
DrMx
Blocklist icon
DroneBL
rbl.efnetrbl.org logoEFnet
Blocklist icon
Fabel
Blocklist icon
GBUdb
Blocklist icon
ImproWare
Blocklist icon
JIPPG Technologies
Blocklist icon
Junk Email Filter
www.justspam.org logoJustSpamwww.kempt.net logoKempt.net
Blocklist icon
Mail Baby
www.nordspam.com logoNordSpam
Blocklist icon
nsZones
Blocklist icon
Polspam
Blocklist icon
RedHawk
rv-soft.info logoRV-SOFT Technology
Blocklist icon
Schulte
www.scientificspam.net logoScientific Spam
Blocklist icon
Spam Eating Monkey
psbl.org logoSpamikazewww.spamrats.com logoSpamRATSspfbl.net logoSPFBLsuomispam.net logoSuomispamwww.usenix.org.uk logoSystem 5 Hosting
Blocklist icon
Taughannock Networks
www.team-cymru.com logoTeam Cymru
Blocklist icon
Tornevall Networks
senderscore.org logoValiditywww.blocklist.de logowww.blocklist.de Fail2Ban-Reporting Servicezapbl.net logoZapBL2stepback.dk logo2stepback.dkfaynticrbl.org logoFayntic Servicesorbz.gst-group.co.uk logoORB UKdnsbl.technoirc.org logotechnoirc.orgwww.techtheft.info logoTechTheftwww.spamhaus.org logoSpamhaus0spam.org logo0Spam
Blocklist icon
Abusix
Blocklist icon
Barracuda Networks
www.spamcop.net logoCisco
Blocklist icon
Mailspike
www.nosolicitado.org logoNoSolicitado
Blocklist icon
SURBL
Blocklist icon
UCEPROTECT
uribl.com logoURIBL
Blocklist icon
8086 Consultancy
abuse.ro logoabuse.rowiki.alphanet.ch logoALPHANETanonmails.de logoAnonmailsascams.com logoAscamswww.blockedservers.com logoBLOCKEDSERVERS
Blocklist icon
Brukalai.lt
dnsbl.calivent.com.pe logoCalivent Networks
Blocklist icon
dan.me.uk
Blocklist icon
DrMx
Blocklist icon
DroneBL
rbl.efnetrbl.org logoEFnet
Blocklist icon
Fabel
Blocklist icon
GBUdb
Blocklist icon
ImproWare
Blocklist icon
JIPPG Technologies
Blocklist icon
Junk Email Filter
www.justspam.org logoJustSpamwww.kempt.net logoKempt.net
Blocklist icon
Mail Baby
www.nordspam.com logoNordSpam
Blocklist icon
nsZones
Blocklist icon
Polspam
Blocklist icon
RedHawk
rv-soft.info logoRV-SOFT Technology
Blocklist icon
Schulte
www.scientificspam.net logoScientific Spam
Blocklist icon
Spam Eating Monkey
psbl.org logoSpamikazewww.spamrats.com logoSpamRATSspfbl.net logoSPFBLsuomispam.net logoSuomispamwww.usenix.org.uk logoSystem 5 Hosting
Blocklist icon
Taughannock Networks
www.team-cymru.com logoTeam Cymru
Blocklist icon
Tornevall Networks
senderscore.org logoValiditywww.blocklist.de logowww.blocklist.de Fail2Ban-Reporting Servicezapbl.net logoZapBL2stepback.dk logo2stepback.dkfaynticrbl.org logoFayntic Servicesorbz.gst-group.co.uk logoORB UKdnsbl.technoirc.org logotechnoirc.orgwww.techtheft.info logoTechTheftwww.spamhaus.org logoSpamhaus0spam.org logo0Spam
Blocklist icon
Abusix
Blocklist icon
Barracuda Networks
www.spamcop.net logoCisco
Blocklist icon
Mailspike
www.nosolicitado.org logoNoSolicitado
Blocklist icon
SURBL
Blocklist icon
UCEPROTECT
uribl.com logoURIBL
Blocklist icon
8086 Consultancy
abuse.ro logoabuse.rowiki.alphanet.ch logoALPHANETanonmails.de logoAnonmailsascams.com logoAscamswww.blockedservers.com logoBLOCKEDSERVERS
Blocklist icon
Brukalai.lt
dnsbl.calivent.com.pe logoCalivent Networks
Blocklist icon
dan.me.uk
Blocklist icon
DrMx
Blocklist icon
DroneBL
rbl.efnetrbl.org logoEFnet
Blocklist icon
Fabel
Blocklist icon
GBUdb
Blocklist icon
ImproWare
Blocklist icon
JIPPG Technologies
Blocklist icon
Junk Email Filter
www.justspam.org logoJustSpamwww.kempt.net logoKempt.net
Blocklist icon
Mail Baby
www.nordspam.com logoNordSpam
Blocklist icon
nsZones
Blocklist icon
Polspam
Blocklist icon
RedHawk
rv-soft.info logoRV-SOFT Technology
Blocklist icon
Schulte
www.scientificspam.net logoScientific Spam
Blocklist icon
Spam Eating Monkey
psbl.org logoSpamikazewww.spamrats.com logoSpamRATSspfbl.net logoSPFBLsuomispam.net logoSuomispamwww.usenix.org.uk logoSystem 5 Hosting
Blocklist icon
Taughannock Networks
www.team-cymru.com logoTeam Cymru
Blocklist icon
Tornevall Networks
senderscore.org logoValiditywww.blocklist.de logowww.blocklist.de Fail2Ban-Reporting Servicezapbl.net logoZapBL2stepback.dk logo2stepback.dkfaynticrbl.org logoFayntic Servicesorbz.gst-group.co.uk logoORB UKdnsbl.technoirc.org logotechnoirc.orgwww.techtheft.info logoTechTheftwww.spamhaus.org logoSpamhaus0spam.org logo0Spam
Blocklist icon
Abusix
Blocklist icon
Barracuda Networks
www.spamcop.net logoCisco
Blocklist icon
Mailspike
www.nosolicitado.org logoNoSolicitado
Blocklist icon
SURBL
Blocklist icon
UCEPROTECT
uribl.com logoURIBL
Blocklist icon
8086 Consultancy
abuse.ro logoabuse.rowiki.alphanet.ch logoALPHANETanonmails.de logoAnonmailsascams.com logoAscamswww.blockedservers.com logoBLOCKEDSERVERS
Blocklist icon
Brukalai.lt
dnsbl.calivent.com.pe logoCalivent Networks
Blocklist icon
dan.me.uk
Blocklist icon
DrMx
Blocklist icon
DroneBL
rbl.efnetrbl.org logoEFnet
Blocklist icon
Fabel
Blocklist icon
GBUdb
Blocklist icon
ImproWare
Blocklist icon
JIPPG Technologies
Blocklist icon
Junk Email Filter
www.justspam.org logoJustSpamwww.kempt.net logoKempt.net
Blocklist icon
Mail Baby
www.nordspam.com logoNordSpam
Blocklist icon
nsZones
Blocklist icon
Polspam
Blocklist icon
RedHawk
rv-soft.info logoRV-SOFT Technology
Blocklist icon
Schulte
www.scientificspam.net logoScientific Spam
Blocklist icon
Spam Eating Monkey
psbl.org logoSpamikazewww.spamrats.com logoSpamRATSspfbl.net logoSPFBLsuomispam.net logoSuomispamwww.usenix.org.uk logoSystem 5 Hosting
Blocklist icon
Taughannock Networks
www.team-cymru.com logoTeam Cymru
Blocklist icon
Tornevall Networks
senderscore.org logoValiditywww.blocklist.de logowww.blocklist.de Fail2Ban-Reporting Servicezapbl.net logoZapBL2stepback.dk logo2stepback.dkfaynticrbl.org logoFayntic Servicesorbz.gst-group.co.uk logoORB UKdnsbl.technoirc.org logotechnoirc.orgwww.techtheft.info logoTechTheftwww.spamhaus.org logoSpamhaus0spam.org logo0Spam
Blocklist icon
Abusix
Blocklist icon
Barracuda Networks
www.spamcop.net logoCisco
Blocklist icon
Mailspike
www.nosolicitado.org logoNoSolicitado
Blocklist icon
SURBL
Blocklist icon
UCEPROTECT
uribl.com logoURIBL
Blocklist icon
8086 Consultancy
abuse.ro logoabuse.rowiki.alphanet.ch logoALPHANETanonmails.de logoAnonmailsascams.com logoAscamswww.blockedservers.com logoBLOCKEDSERVERS
Blocklist icon
Brukalai.lt
dnsbl.calivent.com.pe logoCalivent Networks
Blocklist icon
dan.me.uk
Blocklist icon
DrMx
Blocklist icon
DroneBL
rbl.efnetrbl.org logoEFnet
Blocklist icon
Fabel
Blocklist icon
GBUdb
Blocklist icon
ImproWare
Blocklist icon
JIPPG Technologies
Blocklist icon
Junk Email Filter
www.justspam.org logoJustSpamwww.kempt.net logoKempt.net
Blocklist icon
Mail Baby
www.nordspam.com logoNordSpam
Blocklist icon
nsZones
Blocklist icon
Polspam
Blocklist icon
RedHawk
rv-soft.info logoRV-SOFT Technology
Blocklist icon
Schulte
www.scientificspam.net logoScientific Spam
Blocklist icon
Spam Eating Monkey
psbl.org logoSpamikazewww.spamrats.com logoSpamRATSspfbl.net logoSPFBLsuomispam.net logoSuomispamwww.usenix.org.uk logoSystem 5 Hosting
Blocklist icon
Taughannock Networks
www.team-cymru.com logoTeam Cymru
Blocklist icon
Tornevall Networks
senderscore.org logoValiditywww.blocklist.de logowww.blocklist.de Fail2Ban-Reporting Servicezapbl.net logoZapBL2stepback.dk logo2stepback.dkfaynticrbl.org logoFayntic Servicesorbz.gst-group.co.uk logoORB UKdnsbl.technoirc.org logotechnoirc.orgwww.techtheft.info logoTechTheft
Compare product functionality

Feature set

Logo
DMARC-SRG
First comparison imageSecond comparison image
Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection (DFP) is a component of the broader Barracuda Email Protection suite, so its DMARC features are integrated within a larger security ecosystem. We found it offers robust DMARC report aggregation and analysis, designed for organizations that prioritize a holistic approach to email security. Its strength lies in combining DMARC enforcement with other layers of protection, such as anti-phishing, anti-malware, and data loss prevention.
The platform provides clear visibility into DMARC compliance, helping to identify legitimate sending sources and block fraudulent emails attempting to spoof your domain. We noticed it handles advanced reporting and helps streamline the process of moving to a DMARC enforcement policy, offering guidance and tools to analyze incoming DMARC XML reports effectively. This integration means you're not just getting DMARC, but a comprehensive email security posture.
DMARC-SRG, or DMARC Summary Report Generator, is an open-source PHP tool designed for parsing, viewing, and summarizing incoming DMARC reports. It's a self-hostable solution, giving users complete control over their data and infrastructure. We see it as a fundamental tool for those who need basic DMARC reporting without the overhead of a managed service or a broader security suite. It focuses purely on DMARC data, making it straightforward for a specific use case.
Our experience shows that DMARC-SRG excels at taking raw DMARC XML reports and presenting them in a human-readable format, making it easier to understand email authentication results. While it offers essential reporting, it lacks the advanced features, automated threat detection, or user-friendly dashboards typically found in commercial DMARC platforms. It requires technical proficiency to set up, maintain, and integrate into an existing environment.
How easy is each product to use

User experience

Logo
DMARC-SRG
First comparison imageSecond comparison image
For Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection, the user experience is generally streamlined, leveraging Barracuda's established interface for its email protection suite. We found the dashboards to be intuitive for navigating DMARC reports and understanding authentication trends. It offers a more polished, enterprise-grade look and feel, designed for IT professionals who manage multiple security layers.
While the initial setup involves configuring DMARC records and integrating with the broader Barracuda platform, ongoing management of DMARC policies and report analysis is simplified through graphical representations and actionable insights. This makes it accessible even for those who are not deep DMARC experts, as the platform guides them through the process. However, the sheer breadth of the entire suite can feel overwhelming if DMARC is your only concern.
DMARC-SRG offers a very different user experience, rooted in its open-source, self-hosted nature. We found it requires a hands-on approach, starting with the installation of PHP and setting up a web server. The interface itself is functional and presents the DMARC data clearly, but it is not a slick, commercial dashboard. It's built for utility rather than extensive user-friendliness.
Users must be comfortable with command-line operations and basic web server administration. While the reports are legible once generated, there are no guided workflows or automated recommendations. This means that while you have full control, you also bear the full responsibility for managing the tool, interpreting the data, and taking action based on your analysis. It's truly a tool for the technically inclined, where you get out what you put in.
Which product has the best support

Support

Logo
DMARC-SRG
First comparison imageSecond comparison image
Barracuda, as a commercial vendor, offers professional support for its products, including Domain Fraud Protection. We've experienced their support to be responsive, with various channels available, such as phone, email, and a customer portal. They provide extensive documentation, knowledge bases, and online resources to help users troubleshoot issues and optimize their DMARC implementation.
Their support team is generally well-versed in the entire Barracuda Email Protection suite, which is beneficial given the integrated nature of DFP. For businesses that rely on vendor support for critical infrastructure, this structured approach to customer service is a significant advantage. This can be crucial when facing complex DMARC authentication failures or policy adjustments, especially for organizations without in-house DMARC specialists.
DMARC-SRG, being an open-source project, relies primarily on community support. We find that assistance is typically found through its GitHub repository, where users can report issues, suggest features, and sometimes receive help from the maintainers or other community members. There's no dedicated support team or official service level agreements.
This model suits users who are comfortable troubleshooting and finding solutions independently or leveraging their internal technical expertise. While the community can be helpful, it's not a guaranteed, on-demand support system. For critical operational needs, relying solely on community support might pose challenges, as response times and the depth of assistance can vary greatly. In essence, you are your own primary support.
Who should use each product

Suitability

Logo
DMARC-SRG
First comparison imageSecond comparison image
Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection is best suited for organizations that already use, or are looking to adopt, Barracuda's broader email security solutions. It's designed for businesses that need robust, integrated DMARC management alongside other email threat protections. We recommend it for:
Small to medium businesses (SMBs): Those seeking an all-in-one email security solution. Enterprise: Larger organizations needing comprehensive protection and established vendor support. Managed service providers (MSPs): Those looking to offer integrated email security services to their clients, leveraging Barracuda's partner programs.
DMARC-SRG is ideal for technically proficient individuals or organizations that prefer self-hosting and have the resources to manage their own DMARC reporting infrastructure. We find it perfect for those who prioritize cost-effectiveness and data control, without needing the bells and whistles of a commercial platform. It's particularly suitable for:
Technically skilled individuals: Developers or IT admins who want a free, hands-on DMARC parser. Small businesses: Those with strong technical expertise and limited budgets. MSPs: Those who are comfortable building and maintaining custom solutions for their clients, often for niche or highly specific requirements. Enterprise: Organizations with extensive in-house IT teams capable of integrating and maintaining open-source tools.

How does Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection compare with DMARC-SRG?

Logo
DMARC-SRG
DMARC report analysis
Source detection
Forward detection
Spoof detection
Notifications and alerts
Reporting
API
Multi-tenancy
SPF flattening
Hosted DMARC
BIMI
MTA-STS/TLS-RPT
Blocklists and reputation
AI copilot
DNS monitoring
Self hostable
Free trial/free tier

Drawbacks and what to watch out for

Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection, while effective, might present a slight network lag according to one user review, and its full capabilities are tied into a larger, potentially costly, email protection suite. DMARC-SRG's main drawback is its reliance on users having significant technical expertise for setup, maintenance, and interpretation, as it lacks managed support and advanced commercial features.
We have pulled the average ratings from G2 for each product, and also included the most recent negative reviews for each product in full. Positive reviews tend to have less detail and have a higher chance of being fraudulent, so negative reviews are a better signal for your decision.
Logo
DMARC-SRG
Excellent protection for a mid-sized non-profit.
What do you like best about Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection? Our school for autistic adults has benefitted immensely from the Barracuda products we use for cybersecurity, and their Domain Fraud Protection is an excellent addition to the essentials suite. It is relatively inexpensive compared to competitors and provides comprehensive DMARC services which protect our brand from being digitally impersonated and used to launch attacks. This was a real problem for us prior to purchasing Barracuda DFP, but has not been a worry in the 7+ years since we installed the software. Our IT specialist reports that their customer service is extremely responsive and that the software itself is simple to manage. Highly recommended. What do you dislike about Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection? The only downside we've experienced to Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection is a slight network lag. This has not been too noticeable, however, and the extra protection has been well worth the additional system load. What problems is Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection solving and how is that benefiting you? We used to suffer domain spoofing attacks multiple times a year, but Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection has successfully stopped virtually all of these kinds of attacks since we began using it on our network in 2015.
Jared S.
Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
No G2 reviews
G2 is the most popular review platform for DMARC products, so this is a strong signal that this product is not popular.

Pricing

Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection is part of a larger, user-based commercial suite, while DMARC-SRG is a free, self-hostable open-source solution.
Logo
DMARC-SRG
Small
Contact for pricing (part of suite, user-based pricing starts <50 users)
Free (self-hostable, requires technical expertise)
Medium
Contact for pricing (part of suite, user-based pricing for 50+ users)
Free (self-hostable, requires technical expertise)
Large
Contact for pricing (part of suite, user-based pricing for 50+ users)
Free (self-hostable, requires technical expertise)
Enterprise
Contact for pricing (part of suite, custom quote for 50+ users)
Free (self-hostable, requires technical expertise)

Suped hard sell incoming!

Still not satisfied with Barracuda Domain Fraud Protection or DMARC-SRG?
Logo
DMARC-SRG
Suped double trouble

What makes Suped different

Automated sender discovery that finds shadow IT and third-party services
DMARC copilot that pinpoints failures and prescribes the exact fix
Guided path to full p=reject enforcement, safely and quickly
Proactive alerts to prevent misconfigurations before they block your mail
Get started - free

Frequently asked questions