Suped

What are the alternatives to Return Path for deliverability certification?

Summary

Alternatives to Return Path for deliverability certification are varied and encompass a range of strategies, tools, and best practices. Some experts initially suggest a lack of direct replacements, pointing to the necessity of Return Path or highlighting niche certifications like CSA. However, numerous ESPs and email marketing professionals propose alternative solutions such as utilizing platform-specific deliverability tools (SparkPost, Mailchimp), engaging in consistent sender reputation management (Spam Resource, SendGrid), employing seedlist testing and inbox placement monitoring (Word to the Wise), leveraging free tools like Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS, and adopting a combination of these approaches (EmailToolTester, Email Marketing Forum). These alternatives focus on authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), list hygiene, feedback loop engagement, and proactive monitoring to achieve and maintain high deliverability.

Key findings

  • Conflicting Opinions: There are conflicting opinions on whether true alternatives to Return Path exist.
  • Emphasis on Reputation: Sender reputation management is a consistent and prominent alternative.
  • Combination of Tools: Using a combination of deliverability tools and practices is frequently recommended.
  • Platform-Specific Solutions: ESPs like Mailchimp and SparkPost offer integrated deliverability features.
  • Free Resources: Free tools like Google Postmaster Tools and Microsoft SNDS offer valuable insights.
  • Niche Certifications: CSA certification can be a viable option in specific regions like Germany.

Key considerations

  • Resource Requirements: Implementing and maintaining many alternatives requires dedicated resources and time.
  • Technical Expertise: Effectively utilizing deliverability tools and interpreting data necessitates technical knowledge.
  • Holistic Monitoring: Ensuring comprehensive deliverability across multiple ISPs requires a multifaceted approach.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Evaluate the costs associated with various paid tools and services against potential benefits.
  • Geographic Relevance: Some alternatives are more relevant in specific regions and may not be universally applicable.

What email marketers say

12 marketer opinions

Several alternatives to Return Path for deliverability certification exist, encompassing various strategies and tools. These include exploring options like Validity, 250ok (now part of Validity), and Inbox Tracker. Other suggested alternatives include GlockApps, MailMonitor, and Sender Score. Some recommend using a combination of tools like Litmus for testing and dedicated IP warming strategies or leveraging GlockApps and Mail-Tester.com. Additionally, engaging with feedback loops, managing suppression lists, utilizing built-in deliverability tools in platforms like Mailchimp, and carefully managing sender reputation through best practices such as warming up IPs, authenticating emails, and segmenting lists are also recommended.

Key opinions

  • Tool Combinations: Many suggest combining multiple tools to achieve comprehensive deliverability insights.
  • Platform Integration: Email marketing platforms like Mailchimp and Validity offer built-in tools as alternatives.
  • Reputation Management: Proactive sender reputation management is a recurring theme.
  • CSA certification: CSA certification may be a valid alternative in Germany.
  • ItaliaOnline: ItaliaOnline has a pay to play model but is still in beta.

Key considerations

  • Tool Costs: Evaluate the costs associated with various tools and platforms.
  • Implementation Effort: Consider the time and resources required to implement and manage different strategies.
  • Specific Needs: Tailor your approach based on your specific sending volume, target audience, and technical capabilities.
  • Geographic Reach: Some solutions might be more relevant in specific geographic regions.

Marketer view

Email marketer from Litmus responds by recommending focusing on proactive email testing and monitoring, using tools within Litmus to analyze email placement across different inboxes, and optimizing content and code to improve deliverability.

31 Dec 2022 - Litmus

Marketer view

Email marketer from EmailVendorSelection.com suggests exploring options like Validity (formerly Return Path), 250ok (now part of Validity), and Inbox Tracker for deliverability monitoring and certification-related services.

13 Oct 2024 - EmailVendorSelection.com

What the experts say

4 expert opinions

The responses regarding alternatives to Return Path for deliverability certification are mixed. One source initially states there aren't any alternatives, suggesting paying Return Path is the only option. However, another source acknowledges the CSA certification as a possibility. Other experts suggest focusing on sender reputation management through consistent practices, proper email authentication, and active list hygiene. Additionally, the use of seedlist testing and inbox placement monitoring tools like 250ok and GlockApps are recommended to gain insight into inbox placement across various ISPs.

Key opinions

  • Conflicting Opinions: There are conflicting viewpoints, with some claiming no direct alternatives exist, while others suggest viable options.
  • Reputation Management: Maintaining strong sender reputation is consistently highlighted as a crucial factor.
  • CSA Certification: CSA certification is noted as a potential alternative.
  • Seedlist Testing: Seedlist testing provides insight on inbox placement across ISPs

Key considerations

  • Resource Allocation: Evaluate the time and resources required for sender reputation management.
  • Testing tools: Assess whether the cost of seedlist testing tools align with available budget and needs.
  • Geographical Relevance: Determine if CSA certification is relevant for your target audience.

Expert view

Expert from Word to the Wise responds by recommending the use of seedlist testing and inbox placement monitoring using tools like 250ok (now part of Validity) and GlockApps. These provide data on inbox placement across various ISPs, offering insight similar to Return Path’s certification.

13 Mar 2023 - Word to the Wise

Expert view

Expert from Email Geeks explains there aren’t any alternatives to Return Path for deliverability certification. ISPs aren’t offering their own version of whitelisting any more, either. You pay RP or nothing.

16 Aug 2023 - Email Geeks

What the documentation says

4 technical articles

Email service providers and tools offer alternatives to Return Path's certification by emphasizing comprehensive deliverability features, best practices, and reputation monitoring. SparkPost provides deliverability tools and analytics within its platform. Mailjet highlights the importance of clean lists, email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), and bounce rate monitoring. Google Postmaster Tools enables domain reputation, spam rate, and feedback loop monitoring. Microsoft SNDS allows users to monitor IP reputation and identify deliverability issues specifically for Outlook.com and Hotmail.

Key findings

  • Platform Features: Email platforms often include built-in tools for deliverability management.
  • Best Practices: Adhering to email sending best practices is consistently recommended.
  • Free Tools: Free tools like Google Postmaster Tools provide valuable deliverability insights.
  • Specific Monitoring: Microsoft SNDS helps monitor deliverability issues specific to Microsoft email services.

Key considerations

  • Platform Dependency: Deliverability tools within a platform are limited to that platform's ecosystem.
  • Implementation Time: Implementing and maintaining best practices requires ongoing effort.
  • Holistic view: Consider the need for a holistic view across multiple ISPs and email services.
  • Technical expertise: Leveraging monitoring tools requires some level of technical understanding.

Technical article

Documentation from SparkPost explains that while they don't offer a direct replacement for Return Path's certification, they provide comprehensive deliverability tools and analytics within their platform to help users monitor and improve their sending reputation.

26 May 2024 - SparkPost Documentation

Technical article

Documentation from Google Postmaster Tools shares that using their platform to monitor domain reputation, spam rates, and feedback loops is a free alternative to understand and improve deliverability to Gmail users, replacing some functions of Return Path.

20 Oct 2021 - Google Postmaster Tools

Start improving your email deliverability today

Sign up
    What are the alternatives to Return Path for deliverability certification? - Knowledge Base - Suped