Summary
Using animated GIFs in IP warming emails is generally acceptable, while SVG usage is more complex and less consistently supported. Experts advise caution, emphasizing the importance of high engagement and preventing negative user experiences. Key considerations include email client support (GIFs have broader support, SVG is inconsistent), file size (keep small to avoid deliverability issues), ensuring content is relevant and expected by the audience, and providing a static fallback for clients that don't support animation. It's also crucial to balance image-based emails with text-based emails during the IP warming process and avoid overwhelming subscribers, focusing on building a positive sender reputation.
Key findings
- GIF Support: Gmail and other major email clients generally support animated GIFs, though some (like Outlook) may have rendering issues with complex animations.
- SVG Support: SVG support is inconsistent across email clients, making it less reliable than GIFs.
- Engagement is Crucial: Warmup requires high recipient engagement, so content must be relevant and expected.
- File Size Matters: Large file sizes can negatively impact deliverability and engagement.
- Static Fallback is Essential: A static fallback image is needed for clients that don't support animated images.
- Mix Content Types: Balance image-based emails with text-based content during IP warming.
Key considerations
- Test Thoroughly: Test animated images (especially SVGs) across various email clients to ensure proper rendering and avoid unexpected results.
- Optimize File Size: Optimize images by reducing colors and complexity to minimize file size.
- Know Your Audience: Ensure content is relevant and expected by your target audience to maximize engagement.
- Provide a Fallback: Provide a clear and relevant static fallback image for clients that don't support animation.
- Use Judiciously: Avoid overusing animated images, especially in the early stages of IP warming, to prevent overwhelming subscribers and potentially harming sender reputation.
- Prepare Carefully: Animation requires more effort and preparation to get right; consider the potential risks, especially on new systems with tight deadlines.
- Sender Reputation: Prioritize building a positive sender reputation by sending wanted mail to real users who engage with your messages.
What email marketers say
9 marketer opinions
Using animated GIFs in IP warming emails is generally considered acceptable, while SVG usage is more complex. Key considerations include email client support (GIFs have broader support, SVG is inconsistent), file size (keep small to avoid deliverability issues), content relevance to audience engagement, and the necessity of a static fallback for clients that don't support animation. Sending sufficient text-based emails in addition to images is also recommended during IP warming.
Key opinions
- GIF Support: GIFs have widespread support across most email clients, but it's not universal.
- SVG Support: SVG support in email clients is inconsistent and less reliable than GIF support.
- File Size: Large file sizes can negatively impact deliverability and engagement due to slow loading times.
- Image Fallback: A static image fallback is crucial for email clients that don't support animated GIFs or SVGs.
- Image Use: Ensure good volume of non-image based emails are sent during IP warmup.
Key considerations
- Email Client Compatibility: Thoroughly test animated images (especially SVGs) across various email clients to ensure proper rendering.
- File Size Optimization: Optimize animated GIFs by reducing the number of colors and frames to minimize file size.
- Engagement: Make sure the content of the animated image aligns with audience interests to boost engagement.
- Static Fallback: Provide a clear and relevant static fallback image for email clients that don't support animation.
- Image overload: Ensure good volume of non-image based emails are sent during IP warmup.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Campaign Monitor explains that GIFs can be effective for capturing attention in emails, especially for promotions, but advises against overuse to prevent overwhelming subscribers. No mention of SVG.
4 Feb 2022 - Campaign Monitor
Marketer view
Email marketer from HubSpot shares that GIFs can improve click-through rates but should be used sparingly. They also recommend optimizing GIFs for email by reducing the number of colors and keeping them short.
13 Aug 2021 - HubSpot
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
Experts generally agree that animated GIFs and SVGs *can* be used in IP warming, but with caution and careful planning. The primary concern revolves around ensuring a positive sender reputation, which requires high engagement and preventing negative user experiences. Key factors include MUA support, image preparation, file size, and relevance to the audience. Overdoing it, especially on a new system or with tight deadlines, introduces unnecessary risk.
Key opinions
- Technically Feasible: There are no inherent technical barriers to using animation.
- Engagement is Key: IP warming success hinges on high recipient engagement.
- MUA Compatibility Matters: Different email clients (MUAs) render images differently.
- Preparation is Critical: Animation requires more effort and preparation to get right.
- Judicious Use Advised: Use images sparingly and ensure they are expected and relevant.
Key considerations
- Audience and Content: Ensure the animated content is relevant and appealing to your target audience.
- MUA Support: Thoroughly test across different MUAs to ensure proper rendering and a good user experience.
- Image Optimization: Optimize images for file size and ensure reliable image hosting.
- Risk Assessment: Weigh the benefits of animation against the potential risks, especially on new systems or with tight deadlines.
- Sender Reputation: Prioritize building a positive sender reputation by sending wanted mail to real users who engage.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise responds images can be used in warm-up, but be judicious. Focus on building a positive sender reputation by sending wanted mail to real users who engage with your messages. Images can slow down this engagement if they are too large or unexpected.
30 Jun 2024 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks advises considering MUA (Mail User Agent) support for the chosen animated format and how it will render in MUAs that don't support it. This is crucial during warmup to avoid issues.
31 Oct 2024 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
The documentation indicates that animated GIFs are generally supported by major email clients like Gmail and Outlook, though Outlook may have rendering issues with complex animations. SVG support is less consistent and requires careful testing. While SVG is a widely supported web standard, email clients may not fully support it, and specific configurations might be necessary for it to work in Outlook. The W3C confirms SVG's animation capabilities but highlights that email client support isn't guaranteed.
Key findings
- GIF Support: Gmail and Outlook generally support animated GIFs.
- SVG Support: Email client support for SVG is variable and less reliable than GIF support.
- Outlook Limitations: Outlook may have rendering issues with complex GIF animations and limited SVG support.
- W3C Standard: SVG supports animation according to the W3C specification.
- Widely supported: SVG is widely supported in web browsers.
Key considerations
- Testing: Thoroughly test SVG rendering across different email clients before deployment.
- Fallback Options: Provide fallback options or alternative content for clients that don't support SVG or have rendering issues with GIFs.
- Configuration: Be aware of specific configurations that may be needed to enable SVG support in certain email clients (e.g., Outlook).
- Content Complexity: Avoid overly complex GIF animations that may cause rendering issues in Outlook.
- Accessibility: Ensure animations are accessible to all users.
Technical article
Documentation from MDN Web Docs explains that SVG is a widely supported vector image format in web browsers. However, its compatibility within email clients can vary, requiring thorough testing.
25 Sep 2024 - MDN Web Docs
Technical article
Documentation from W3C details the SVG specification, confirming its capability for animation. However, email client support is not guaranteed and requires specific implementation considerations.
9 Jun 2025 - W3C
Are image-based emails a good practice, and what are the deliverability and accessibility implications?
Are image-only emails bad for deliverability?
Can I perform IP warming with single image emails?
Do images in email and PDF attachments affect email deliverability?
Do images in emails affect deliverability?
How does the image to text ratio in email affect deliverability?
