Summary
Combating spam and bot traffic at email subscription points requires a layered approach. Standard practices like CAPTCHA and double opt-in are foundational, but increasingly sophisticated bots necessitate advanced techniques. These include capturing signup audit trails, using tiered CAPTCHAs, implementing honeypot fields (hidden forms), performing reverse DNS lookups, and analyzing signup behavior for suspicious patterns. Server-side validation (using PHP) is crucial as bots often bypass client-side JavaScript. Rate limiting, bot management tools (like Cloudflare), and blocking known spam IPs/countries provide additional layers of defense. Integrating with services like Project HoneyPot and maintaining strong transactional relationships are also beneficial. However, the effectiveness of CAPTCHA is diminishing due to captcha farms, and reliance on ESPs for subscription checks is essential, requiring proactive communication with their abuse desks.
Key findings
- Layered Security: A multi-layered security approach combining standard practices with advanced techniques is essential.
- Server-Side Validation: Server-side validation is crucial to prevent bots from bypassing client-side JavaScript.
- Behavioral Analysis: Analyzing signup behavior (location, time, referrer) helps identify suspicious patterns.
- Honeypot Effectiveness: Honeypot fields (hidden form fields) can trap bots without affecting legitimate users.
- Third-Party Tools: Tools like Google reCAPTCHA, Cloudflare's bot management, and Project HoneyPot offer advanced bot detection capabilities.
- Proactive ESP Engagement: Engaging with the ESP's abuse desk is critical for proactive defense against subscription bombing.
- DNS Lookups: Performing reverse DNS lookups helps to verify the sources.
Key considerations
- CAPTCHA Limitations: CAPTCHA's effectiveness is declining due to the rise of captcha farms and advanced bot techniques.
- ESP Dependence: The success of subscription checks relies heavily on the ESP's capabilities and responsiveness.
- False Positives: Advanced risk analysis systems may occasionally flag legitimate users as bots, requiring careful monitoring and adjustments.
- Maintenance: The bot landscape is ever changing, requiring regular maintenance.
What email marketers say
14 marketer opinions
To combat spam and bot traffic at email subscription points, marketers employ various techniques. Standard practices include CAPTCHA and double opt-in, with some suggesting hidden form fields (honeypots) in the HTML to deter automated sign-ups. Analyzing signup behavior, such as location, time, and referrer, can flag suspicious activity. While Mailchimp supports hidden fields, some advocate for server-side PHP solutions to validate forms. Restricting role-based accounts (abuse@, postmaster@) is also recommended. CAPTCHA's effectiveness is questioned due to captcha farms. Utilizing IP address blocking, JavaScript validation, analyzing form completion time, and blocking specific countries add further layers of defense.
Key opinions
- Standard Practices: CAPTCHA and double opt-in are commonly used to verify human subscribers.
- Honeypot Fields: Hidden form fields can effectively trap bots without impacting user experience.
- Behavioral Analysis: Analyzing signup patterns (location, time, referrer) can identify suspicious behavior indicative of bots.
- Server-Side Validation: Using PHP for form validation on the server-side ensures bots cannot bypass checks.
- Account Restrictions: Blocking role-based email addresses (abuse@, postmaster@) prevents abuse.
- Analytics: Analysing signup behaviour can flag suspicious behaviours for manual inspection.
- Country blocking: Blocking countries that are not likely to be the right target audience
Key considerations
- CAPTCHA Limitations: Captcha farms can circumvent CAPTCHA, diminishing its effectiveness.
- Hidden Field Effectiveness: Hidden fields are not as effective.
- PHP Implementation: PHP on the server-side is best as javascript validation is not always effective.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks suggests that depending on scale, one can run analytics based on typical sign-up behaviour to flag suspicious behaviours for manual inspection, using data-points like location, time, referrer, etc.
25 Oct 2023 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from Reddit suggests analysing the time it takes a user to fill out the form, and identify if it is quicker than a human could reasonably do so.
21 Sep 2023 - Reddit
What the experts say
7 expert opinions
Experts recommend a multi-faceted approach to identifying and preventing spam and bot traffic during email subscription. Capturing a detailed audit trail (timestamp, IP, browser data), employing tiered CAPTCHAs, and performing reverse DNS lookups are crucial. Hidden form fields act as traps, particularly with JavaScript. Server-side ESP checks are necessary as many bots bypass client-side validation. A strong transactional relationship is important. Consulting with the ESP's abuse desk is advised before involving the development team.
Key opinions
- Audit Trails: Detailed signup audit trails (timestamp, IP, browser data) aid in identifying suspicious signups.
- Tiered CAPTCHAs: Tiered CAPTCHAs balance security with user experience by presenting increasingly complex challenges.
- Reverse DNS Lookups: Reverse DNS lookups help verify the legitimacy of subscriber IP addresses.
- Hidden Form Fields: Hidden form fields can deter bots
- ESP Checks: Server-side checks performed by the ESP are critical.
- Transactional Relationship: A strong transactional relationship helps.
Key considerations
- ESP Dependence: The effectiveness relies on the ESP's capabilities to handle subscription checks and abuse reports.
- Development Involvement: Consulting the ESP's abuse desk is crucial before involving the development team.
Expert view
Expert from SpamResource suggests performing reverse DNS lookups on the IP addresses of subscribers. If the IP address doesn't have a valid reverse DNS record, or if it resolves to a dynamic hostname, it could be a sign of a bot or spammer.
14 Jan 2024 - SpamResource
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks states that ESPs that can't handle subscription checks are a problem, and that subscription checks need to be server side, as most dumber bots aren't handling JS.
2 Jun 2024 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
Technical documentation emphasizes using advanced tools and techniques to identify and prevent bot traffic at email subscription points. Google reCAPTCHA employs risk analysis, OWASP recommends rate limiting, Cloudflare advocates bot management tools, and Project HoneyPot offers a distributed system for identifying malicious networks.
Key findings
- Risk Analysis: Google reCAPTCHA uses advanced risk analysis to differentiate between humans and bots.
- Rate Limiting: OWASP suggests rate limiting to restrict the number of requests from a single IP address.
- Bot Management Tools: Cloudflare recommends using bot management tools to analyze traffic patterns.
- Network Identification: Project HoneyPot provides a system for identifying malicious bot networks.
Key considerations
- Integration Complexity: Implementing these solutions may require technical expertise and integration with existing systems.
- False Positives: Advanced risk analysis and bot management tools may occasionally flag legitimate users as bots.
- Maintenance: These systems require ongoing maintenance and updates to remain effective against evolving bot techniques.
Technical article
Documentation from Project HoneyPot provides a distributed system for identifying malicious bot networks, you can use a tool like this to identify networks of bots signing up.
12 Mar 2022 - Project HoneyPot
Technical article
Documentation from OWASP explains that implementing rate limiting on signup forms restricts the number of requests from a single IP address within a specific timeframe, preventing bots from flooding the system with spam subscriptions.
25 Jul 2021 - OWASP
Are email list cleaning services useful for improving email deliverability, and how do they work?
How can I identify and prevent suspicious or bot-generated email addresses in my lists?
How can I prevent bot signups on my email newsletter form?
How can I prevent bots from attacking my email database?
How can I prevent bots from signing up for my newsletter and marking it as spam?
How can I prevent nefarious email signups using rate limiting, reCAPTCHA, and double opt-in?
How can I prevent spam bot signups on my website?
How can I use an API to suppress or reject fake emails on my signup form?
