Summary
The overall sentiment is that paying for IP certification for email deliverability is *not* a guaranteed solution and its value is highly dependent on the sender's existing practices and specific circumstances. While some sources acknowledge potential benefits like improved relationships with certain ISPs, access to feedback loops, and enhanced data insights, the vast majority emphasize that strong foundational elements, such as responsible list management, proper authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), engaging content, and adherence to email marketing best practices, are far more crucial and cost-effective. It is mostly recommended for those with complex setups, persistent deliverability issues despite following best practices, or those targeting specific ISPs that favor certified senders. Thorough research and monitoring are always advised before investing. Certifications should be seen as a supplement to, not a replacement for, good email marketing hygiene.
Key findings
- Best Practices are Primary: Solid sending practices (list hygiene, authentication, engagement) are overwhelmingly considered more important than IP certification.
- Certification is Conditional: The value of IP certification is contingent on existing sending practices, target ISPs, and specific deliverability issues.
- Not a Substitute for Good Practices: IP certification is not a replacement for proper authentication, responsible list management, and engaging content.
- Data and Feedback Benefits: IP certification can provide valuable data insights and feedback loops for troubleshooting deliverability problems.
- Complex Setups Might Benefit: Organizations with complex sending infrastructures might find IP certification more helpful.
Key considerations
- Assess Current Practices: Thoroughly assess your existing sending practices and address any fundamental issues before considering IP certification.
- Define Objectives Clearly: Clearly define your deliverability goals and determine if IP certification aligns with and helps achieve them.
- Research Programs Diligently: Research different IP certification programs and carefully consider their specific requirements and benefits.
- Monitor Results Consistently: Implement deliverability monitoring tools and continuously track the impact of IP certification on your email performance.
- Alternative Solutions First: Explore alternative solutions, such as improving list management, content, and authentication, before investing in IP certification.
What email marketers say
12 marketer opinions
The value of paying for IP certification for email deliverability is widely debated. While it can offer benefits like improved reputation with some ISPs, access to feedback loops, and data insights, it's not a guaranteed fix and its effectiveness depends heavily on the sender's existing practices. Most experts agree that implementing fundamental deliverability best practices, such as list hygiene, authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), engaging content, maintaining low complaint rates, and consistent sending policies, are more crucial and often more cost-effective. Certification is most beneficial for senders with complex setups, deliverability issues that persist despite best practices, or those targeting specific ISPs that favor certified senders. Thorough research, understanding certification program requirements, and continuous monitoring are essential before investing.
Key opinions
- Best Practices First: Fundamental deliverability practices (list hygiene, authentication, engagement) are more crucial than IP certification.
- Not a Guaranteed Fix: IP certification is not a substitute for poor sending habits; it complements, rather than replaces, best practices.
- Variable Effectiveness: The value of IP certification depends on the sender's existing practices, target ISPs, and specific deliverability goals.
- Data and Feedback: A key benefit of IP certification is access to data and feedback loops for troubleshooting deliverability issues.
Key considerations
- Define Objectives: Clearly define your deliverability goals and assess whether IP certification aligns with them.
- Research Programs: Thoroughly research different certification programs and understand their specific requirements and benefits.
- Assess Existing Practices: Evaluate your current sending practices and address any fundamental issues before considering IP certification.
- Monitor Results: Use deliverability monitoring tools to track the impact of IP certification and make data-driven decisions.
- Alternative Solutions: Consider alternative solutions such as improved list management, better content, and enhanced authentication before investing in IP certification.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Email Geeks shares his experience of using Validity, IAPP Surety Mail and CSA, noting that success varies depending on the sender's practices. He suggests defining objectives and needs before investing in certification.
17 Nov 2021 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from StackOverflow shares their experience that IP certification can be beneficial if struggling with deliverability despite following best practices. They stress that its value lies in the data and feedback loops it provides.
23 Oct 2023 - StackOverflow
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
Experts generally suggest caution regarding IP certification for email deliverability. The consensus is that while it *might* provide some benefits or be helpful in complex situations, a solid sending reputation is primarily built on responsible list management, sound sending practices, engagement, authentication, list hygiene, and obtaining consent. It is not a substitute for these foundational elements; therefore, for many, the cost isn't justified.
Key opinions
- Not Always Worth It: The value of paying for IP certification is not always justified.
- Foundational Elements Matter More: Responsible list management, strong sending practices, and recipient engagement are more critical for a solid sending reputation.
- Not a Fix for Bad Practices: IP certification is not a substitute for addressing underlying issues in sending practices.
- Complexity Factor: IP Certification might be helpful for complex setups.
Key considerations
- Prioritize Fundamentals: Ensure you have solid list management, engagement strategies, and proper authentication in place first.
- Assess Complexity: Evaluate the complexity of your sending setup to determine if certification might be beneficial.
- Reputation First: Focus on building and maintaining a strong sending reputation through ethical practices rather than relying solely on certification.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that IP certification might be useful for organizations with complex sending setups, but advises that focusing on authentication, list hygiene and consent are more important for good deliverability.
4 Mar 2024 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Spamresource explains that IP certification offers some benefits but emphasizes that a good sending reputation relies more on responsible list management, sending practices and engagement. Certification is not a solution for bad practices.
16 Sep 2024 - Spamresource
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
Technical documentation emphasizes that a strong sender reputation, built on solid sending practices and adherence to established guidelines and standards (like SPF, DKIM, DMARC), is paramount for email deliverability. While IP certification might offer some advantages (as claimed by Validity), it is not a replacement for good practices or a guaranteed solution. Major players like Microsoft and Google prioritize sender reputation based on engagement, user feedback, and adherence to their guidelines, underscoring the importance of focusing on these fundamental aspects rather than solely relying on certifications.
Key findings
- Reputation is Key: Sender reputation is the most crucial factor for email deliverability.
- Standards Matter: Implementing email authentication standards (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) improves deliverability and builds trust.
- Good Practices First: Improving sending practices and adhering to guidelines are essential for a good reputation.
- Certification Not a Substitute: IP certification is not a replacement for good practices or a guaranteed solution for deliverability issues.
Key considerations
- Implement Authentication: Prioritize implementing SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to authenticate your emails.
- Follow Guidelines: Adhere to the guidelines provided by major email providers like Google and Microsoft.
- Focus on Engagement: Prioritize practices that improve user engagement and reduce negative feedback.
- Assess Certification Value: Carefully assess the value of IP certification in the context of your overall deliverability strategy, recognizing its limitations.
Technical article
Documentation from RFC explains the importance of email authentication standards such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for improving deliverability and preventing spoofing. They recommend implementing these standards to build trust with ISPs and enhance sender reputation, which is more important than IP certification.
5 Jan 2022 - RFC
Technical article
Documentation from Google Postmaster Tools highlights the importance of sender reputation for email deliverability. They advise focusing on improving sending practices and adhering to Google's guidelines rather than relying solely on certifications, as Google prioritizes sender reputation based on engagement and user feedback.
3 Sep 2022 - Google Postmaster Tools
Do SuretyMail and Validity Sender Certification increase inbox reach, and how do they work?
How important is IP certification for email deliverability?
Is Return Path certification worth it for improving email deliverability at Gmail?
Is ReturnPath Certification worth the investment for email deliverability?
Is Validity IP Certification worth the cost for email deliverability?
What are the benefits and costs of email certifications like CSA, Signal Spam, and M3AAWG for ESPs?
