Summary
Identifying bot user agents in email click data is a multifaceted process involving analysis of user agent strings, behavioral patterns, and network characteristics. A common starting point involves filtering out known bot user agents, particularly those not starting with 'Mozilla' or associated with TOR networks. Resources like useragent.me, explore.whatismybrowser.com, and deviceatlas.com aid in identifying valid user agents. Suspicious activities such as unusually high click rates, multiple clicks from the same IP in a short period, and clicks outside of normal business hours are red flags. Techniques like JavaScript-based human behavior checks, honeypot traps, rate limiting, CAPTCHAs, anomaly detection, and IP reputation scoring further enhance bot detection. Advanced approaches involve bot management systems, device fingerprinting, reputation analysis, and blocking at the server level. Documentation from OWASP, Imperva, Google, Amazon AWS, and DataDome emphasize multi-layered strategies, JavaScript challenges, and analyzing HTTP headers.
Key findings
- User Agent Analysis: Filtering known bot user agents and analyzing user agent strings for invalid patterns is crucial.
- Behavioral Monitoring: Monitoring for suspicious click behavior, such as high click rates and out-of-hours clicks, helps identify bots.
- JavaScript Checks: Using JavaScript to verify human-like behavior improves detection accuracy.
- Multi-Layered Approach: Combining multiple techniques, including network analysis and honeypot traps, is essential for comprehensive bot detection.
- External Resources: Leveraging external resources like user agent databases enhances detection capabilities.
- Amazon CloudFront Indicator: The presence of the 'Amazon CloudFront' user agent can suggest association with domains pointing to protection.outlook.com.
- Python Requests Indicator: The 'python-requests' user agent might indicate a script is running.
- Blocking Known Bots: Blocking bots at the server level can help prevent them from accessing your site.
- Bot Management System: Bot management system uses machine learning to identify likely bots.
Key considerations
- Balance Detection and User Experience: Ensure bot detection methods don't negatively impact legitimate user experience.
- Continuous Monitoring: Regularly monitor and update bot detection strategies to adapt to evolving bot tactics.
- False Positives: Minimize false positives to avoid blocking genuine user traffic.
- Resource Intensive: Advanced techniques like device fingerprinting can be resource-intensive and require careful implementation.
- TOR Network Traffic: While traffic from TOR networks can indicate bots, it may also include legitimate users seeking privacy.
- Honeypot Traps: Using honeypot traps to catch bad bots can be a useful method to prevent traffic.
What email marketers say
12 marketer opinions
Identifying bot user agents in email click data involves a multi-faceted approach. Analyzing user agent strings for known bot patterns and non-Mozilla strings is a common starting point. Additionally, monitoring for suspicious behavior like rapid clicks, unusual traffic patterns, and clicks outside of normal hours can help detect bots. Employing techniques like JavaScript-based human behavior checks, honeypot traps, rate limiting, and CAPTCHAs can further enhance bot detection. Utilizing bot management systems and blocking known bot user agents at the server level are also effective strategies. External resources like user agent databases and bot protection services offer valuable information and tools for bot identification and mitigation.
Key opinions
- User Agent Analysis: Analyzing user agent strings for non-Mozilla patterns and known bot identifiers is a fundamental technique.
- Behavioral Monitoring: Monitoring for rapid clicks, unusual traffic patterns, and off-hour activity helps identify suspicious bot behavior.
- JavaScript Checks: Using JavaScript to verify human-like behavior (mouse movements, typing) can improve detection accuracy.
- Server-Level Blocking: Blocking known bot user agents and headless browsers at the server level prevents access and skewed analytics.
- External Resources: Utilizing external user agent databases and bot protection services can enhance detection and mitigation efforts.
- Bot Management Systems: Bot management systems use machine learning to indentify likely bots.
- Amazon CloudFront: Traffic from 'Amazon CloudFront' user agent is often associated with domains pointing to protection.outlook.com.
- Python Requests: Python Requests user agent can mean someone is running a script.
Key considerations
- Multi-Layered Approach: Effective bot detection requires combining multiple techniques for comprehensive coverage.
- Resource Utilization: Leverage external resources, such as user agent databases and bot protection services, to stay updated on bot patterns.
- Potential Legitimate Traffic: Be mindful of potential false positives when blocking user agents, ensure legitimate traffic is not accidentally blocked.
- Maintenance: Continuously update bot detection rules and techniques to adapt to evolving bot tactics.
- Honeypot Traps: Using honeypot traps to catch bad bots can be a useful method to prevent traffic.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Reddit recommends using JavaScript to check for human-like behavior (e.g., mouse movements, typing) and then send this data to the server for bot detection, which can complement user agent analysis.
28 Jun 2023 - Reddit
Marketer view
Email marketer from Reddit suggests blocking known bot user agents at the server level to prevent them from accessing your site and skewing your analytics, and he also suggests blocking common headless browser user agents.
19 Mar 2024 - Reddit
What the experts say
2 expert opinions
Spam Resource experts recommend identifying bot user agents in email click data by filtering out known bot user agents, analyzing the click source data, and monitoring for suspicious activities. Invalid user agents, those from TOR networks, unusually high click rates, multiple clicks from the same IP in short periods, and clicks outside of normal business hours are indicators of bot activity.
Key opinions
- Filter Known Bot User Agents: Filter out known bot user agents as a primary step in identifying bot traffic.
- Analyze Click Source Data: Analyze the data of the click source, identifying invalid user agents and those from TOR networks.
- Monitor Suspicious Activities: Monitor for unusually high click rates, multiple clicks from a single IP address in a short period, and clicks occurring outside normal business hours.
Key considerations
- TOR Network Identification: Identify and filter traffic originating from TOR networks as these are often associated with bot activity.
- Time Zone Awareness: Consider the recipient's time zone when analyzing click times to accurately identify out-of-business-hours activity.
- IP Address Analysis: Implement systems to track and analyze IP addresses for repetitive clicking patterns indicative of bots.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that you can monitor for suspicious activities like unusually high click rates, multiple clicks from a single IP in a short period, or clicks happening outside of normal business hours to discover bot activity.
15 Dec 2021 - Spam Resource
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource suggests filtering out known bot user-agents and analyzing the data of the click source. User agents that are not valid or those from TOR networks can be deemed bots.
30 Apr 2024 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
Documentation from OWASP, Imperva, Google, Amazon AWS, and DataDome outline comprehensive bot detection and prevention strategies. These strategies include analyzing HTTP headers (user agent, referrer), employing JavaScript challenges and CAPTCHAs, performing behavioral analysis (request rates, navigation patterns), implementing device fingerprinting and reputation analysis, filtering invalid traffic (IVT), utilizing tools like AWS WAF Bot Control, and employing Javascript bot detection to differentiate bots from human users. Advanced bot protection requires a multi-layered approach due to sophisticated bots mimicking human behavior.
Key findings
- HTTP Header Analysis: Analyzing HTTP headers like user agent and referrer is a common bot detection technique.
- JavaScript Challenges: Using JavaScript challenges to test browser capabilities helps differentiate bots from genuine users.
- Behavioral Analysis: Analyzing request rates and navigation patterns provides insights into bot behavior.
- Device Fingerprinting: Device fingerprinting helps identify bots by analyzing unique device characteristics.
- Reputation Analysis: Reputation analysis aids in identifying bots based on known bot IP addresses or activity patterns.
- Javascript bot detection: Javascript can be used to differentiate between bots and human users.
Key considerations
- Multi-Layered Approach: A multi-layered approach is necessary due to sophisticated bots mimicking human behavior.
- False Positives: Ensure bot detection methods minimize false positives to avoid blocking legitimate traffic.
- IVT Filtering: Filtering invalid traffic is crucial for accurate analytics and advertising campaign performance.
- Regular Updates: Bot detection strategies should be regularly updated to address evolving bot technologies.
- WAF Bot Control: Consider using Web Application Firewall (WAF) bot control features for automated bot protection.
Technical article
Documentation from Google defines invalid traffic (IVT) as clicks or impressions generated by illegitimate means, including automated bots and crawlers, and discusses filtering IVT to improve data accuracy in analytics and advertising platforms.
16 May 2023 - Google
Technical article
Documentation from Amazon AWS explains how to prevent bot access to your websites, APIs, and mobile applications. Includes recommendations for using AWS WAF Bot Control.
18 Aug 2021 - Amazon AWS
How can I detect and segment bot clicks in email campaigns?
How can I identify and handle bot clicks and opens, particularly from Microsoft/Outlook domains, in email marketing campaigns?
How can I identify and handle suspicious bot clicks in email marketing campaigns?
How can I identify and mitigate the impact of bot clicks on email marketing metrics?
How can I identify and prevent spam/bot traffic at email subscription points?
How can I minimize bot clicks in email marketing and what are the best methods for identifying and filtering them?
How can I prevent bot clicks from hurting my email reputation?
