Summary
While long URLs are generally not a primary cause for emails being marked as spam, they can contribute to a higher spam score, especially if they contain unusual characters, excessive parameters, or personally identifiable information (PII). The reputation of the domain within the URL and the relevance/trustworthiness of the linked content are more critical factors. Email authentication protocols (DKIM, SPF) help establish trust, independent of URL length. Using URL shorteners can be a solution, but branded or reputable short domains are preferred. Monitoring how ESPs rewrite URLs is also important. The potential for reverse-engineering and creating malicious URLs is another consideration.
Key findings
- Length Not Primary Trigger: URL length itself is not the main reason for emails being marked as spam.
- Suspicious Characteristics: Long URLs with unusual characters, excessive parameters, or PII raise red flags.
- Domain Reputation Key: The reputation of the domain within the URL is crucial for deliverability.
- Content Relevance Matters: The relevance and trustworthiness of the linked content influence spam filtering.
- Authentication Boosts Trust: DKIM and SPF enhance email deliverability by authenticating the sender, independent of URL length.
- Security Risks: Long URLs can pose security risks due to the potential for reverse-engineering and malicious use.
Key considerations
- Keep URLs Concise: Minimize URL length to reduce suspicion from spam filters.
- Protect PII: Avoid including PII or email addresses within URLs.
- Use Reputable Domains: Prioritize URLs from reputable domains with good sending reputations.
- Implement Email Authentication: Implement DKIM and SPF records to validate sender identity and improve deliverability.
- Choose URL Shorteners Wisely: If using URL shorteners, opt for branded or reputable services.
- Monitor ESP Rewrites: Check how ESPs rewrite URLs to ensure they remain concise and don't add suspicious elements.
- Consider Security Implications: Evaluate the potential security implications of long URLs.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
While URL length is not a primary trigger for spam filters, excessively long, obfuscated, or parameterized URLs can raise suspicion and contribute to a higher spam score. The reputation of the domain within the URL and the relevance of the content are more critical factors. Using URL shorteners can help, but branded or reputable short domains are preferred over generic ones. Checking how ESPs rewrite URLs is also advisable.
Key opinions
- Length Isn't Primary: URL length, by itself, is not the main determinant of whether an email is marked as spam.
- Suspicious URLs: Excessively long URLs with unusual characters or encodings can appear suspicious to spam filters.
- Domain Reputation: The reputation of the domain used in the URL is more important than the length of the URL itself.
- Content Relevance: The relevance and trustworthiness of the content linked to by the URL influence spam filtering.
- ESP Rewriting: Email Service Providers (ESPs) often rewrite URLs for tracking, which can affect the final URL length.
Key considerations
- Keep URLs Concise: Aim to keep URLs as short and clean as possible to minimize potential spam flags.
- Use Branded Shorteners: If using URL shorteners, opt for branded ones to build trust and avoid generic, potentially blacklisted services.
- Check ESP Rewrites: Monitor how your ESP rewrites URLs to ensure they don't become excessively long or obfuscated.
- Prioritize Domain Reputation: Ensure the domain used in your URLs has a good reputation to improve deliverability.
- Ensure Content Relevance: Make sure the content linked to is relevant, trustworthy, and aligned with the email's subject.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Litmus reports that URL shorteners can negatively impact deliverability if abused or used with untrusted services. Using a branded short domain or full URLs from a reputable domain is preferred.
18 Apr 2022 - Litmus
Marketer view
Email marketer from GMass shares that the reputation of the domain within the URL is far more critical than the length. A trustworthy domain will fare better in spam filters, regardless of URL length, while a suspicious domain will struggle even with short URLs.
21 Dec 2021 - GMass
What the experts say
5 expert opinions
While long URLs themselves may not be the primary trigger for spam filters, they can contribute to a higher spam score, especially if they contain unusual characters or encodings. The presence of Personally Identifiable Information (PII) or email addresses in URLs can also be problematic. Furthermore, long URLs can raise security concerns, such as the potential for reverse-engineering and the creation of malicious links. Ultimately, the reputation of the domain within the URL is more significant than its length.
Key opinions
- Long URLs Contribute: Very long URLs can contribute to triggering spam filters, especially with unusual characters.
- Domain Reputation Matters Most: The reputation of the domain in the URL is more important than the URL's length.
- PII and Email Addresses: URLs containing Personally Identifiable Information (PII) or email addresses can be problematic.
- Security Concerns: Long URLs can raise concerns about reverse-engineering and creation of malicious links.
Key considerations
- Minimize Length: Minimize URL length whenever possible to reduce spam scoring.
- Protect PII: Avoid including PII or email addresses in URLs.
- Ensure Domain Reputation: Use URLs from reputable domains to enhance deliverability.
- Consider Security: Evaluate potential security risks associated with long URLs, especially concerning reverse-engineering.
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that very long URLs can be a factor in triggering spam filters, especially if they contain unusual characters or encodings. While not a definitive cause, they contribute to the overall spam score.
1 Oct 2024 - Spam Resource
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks raises a concern about the possibility of reverse-engineering the link to create a malicious URL.
8 Apr 2024 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
4 technical articles
While HTTP/1.1 doesn't specify a URL length limit, focusing on server support, Google recommends simple URLs for better crawlability. DKIM and SPF are crucial for email authentication, building sender trust and reducing spam flags, independent of URL length. These mechanisms protect against spoofing and validate sender legitimacy, directly impacting deliverability more than URL length.
Key findings
- No HTTP Limit: HTTP/1.1 doesn't enforce a maximum URL length, emphasizing server support.
- Simple URLs for Crawling: Google recommends simple, logical URLs for improved web crawling, indirectly aiding spam filter comprehension.
- DKIM Authentication: DKIM authenticates the sender's domain, boosting email deliverability regardless of URL length.
- SPF Validation: SPF validates sending sources, enhancing deliverability and protecting against spoofing, irrespective of URL length.
Key considerations
- Ensure Server Support: Ensure servers can handle URLs of a reasonable length (at least 255 characters).
- Keep URLs Simple: Strive for simple and logical URL structures to aid search engine and spam filter understanding.
- Implement DKIM: Implement DKIM for domain authentication to enhance trust and deliverability.
- Implement SPF: Implement SPF records to validate sending sources and protect against spoofing.
Technical article
Documentation from Google Search Central shares that, while focused on web crawling, Google recommends keeping URLs simple and logical. Although they don't explicitly mention spam filters, a complex URL structure can make it harder for search engines (and potentially spam filters) to understand the page's content.
23 Jul 2024 - Google
Technical article
Documentation from openspf.org explains that implementing Sender Policy Framework (SPF) records to authenticate email sending sources. This improves deliverability by validating the sender's legitimacy, independent of URL length. It protects against sender spoofing.
24 Dec 2023 - openspf.org
Are Bitly links bad for email deliverability?
Are HTTP links penalized by spam filters in email marketing?
Are URL shorteners like bit.ly bad for email deliverability?
How do multiple or long links affect email deliverability?
How do URL shorteners and domain reputation impact email deliverability?
How does URL length affect email deliverability?
