Summary
The appearance of '<undefined>' in the List-Unsubscribe header within Gmail can arise from a multitude of issues, ranging from potential bugs or updates on Gmail's end to problems with the sender's email configuration and coding. These issues include improperly formatted headers, encoding errors, failures in dynamic content generation, server-side errors, DNS propagation problems, transient network issues, non-compliant sending server configurations, and a lack of proper error handling. It might also be specific to certain email addresses or Google Workspace accounts.
Key findings
- Potential Gmail Bug: The problem might stem from a recent update or bug within Gmail causing temporary parsing glitches.
- Header Format Errors: Missing or incorrectly formatted List-Unsubscribe headers can result in Gmail displaying '<undefined>'.
- Encoding Issues: Improper MIME encoding or the presence of unencoded characters can lead to parsing problems.
- Dynamic Content Generation Failures: Problems during dynamic content generation in the sender's email system can lead to the unsubscribe link not being generated properly.
- Server-Side and ESP Configuration: Configuration problems or non-compliance with modern email standards on the sending server and ESP can cause incorrect header generation.
- Transient Errors: Transient network errors or temporary unavailability of the unsubscribe endpoint may contribute to the issue.
- Domain Propagation: It is possible domain DNS is not propagated fully causing the issue
Key considerations
- Check Gmail Status: Monitor Gmail for updates or known issues that might be causing parsing errors.
- Review and Validate Header Format: Ensure the List-Unsubscribe header is correctly formatted according to RFC 2369 and RFC 8058 specifications, and contains a valid URL.
- Ensure Correct Encoding: Verify correct MIME encoding, and ensure all special characters are properly encoded according to RFC 5322.
- Examine Server-Side Logic: Review the server-side code responsible for generating the unsubscribe link to ensure it's correctly populated under all conditions.
- Implement Error Handling: Implement robust error handling to manage situations where the unsubscribe URL cannot be created, and avoid defaulting to '<undefined>'.
- Validate Rendering: Use email testing tools to validate unsubscribe URL rendering across different email clients and identify any inconsistencies.
- Server and ESP compliance: Review sending server config for compliance to standards and that the ESP is up to date.
What email marketers say
8 marketer opinions
The appearance of '<undefined>' in the List-Unsubscribe header in Gmail can stem from multiple factors. These include: issues with Gmail's processing due to updates or bugs, problems with the sender's email system generating the header (such as server-side errors, incorrect formatting, or conditional logic failures), or a lack of proper error handling when an unsubscribe URL cannot be created. It may also be specific to certain email addresses or Google Workspace accounts.
Key opinions
- Gmail Issues: Recent updates or temporary glitches within Gmail might cause incorrect header parsing.
- Server-Side Errors: Errors in the sender's server-side code could lead to the unsubscribe link not being generated correctly.
- Formatting Errors: Incorrectly formatted or missing List-Unsubscribe headers can result in Gmail displaying '<undefined>'.
- Conditional Logic: The unsubscribe URL might not be populated under certain conditions in the sender's email sending code.
- Error Handling: Lack of appropriate error handling or fallback mechanisms when an unsubscribe URL cannot be created.
- Account Specificity: The issue might be specific to certain Gmail addresses or Google Workspace accounts.
Key considerations
- Check Server Logs: Review server logs for errors related to the generation of the List-Unsubscribe header.
- Validate Header Format: Ensure the List-Unsubscribe header is present and contains a valid URL, conforming to RFC specifications.
- Review Sending Code: Check the email sending code to ensure the unsubscribe URL is always correctly populated under all conditions.
- Implement Fallbacks: Implement error handling and fallback mechanisms to manage situations where the unsubscribe URL cannot be created.
- Test Rendering: Use tools like Litmus or Email on Acid to validate unsubscribe URL rendering across different email clients.
- Check for Gmail Updates: Be aware of updates or changes on Gmail's end that could be causing temporary parsing issues.
Marketer view
Email marketer from StackExchange explains that the server might be incorrectly setting the header based on a condition that isn't being met. Check the logic in your email sending code to verify that the unsubscribe URL is always correctly populated under all conditions.
14 May 2022 - StackExchange
Marketer view
Email marketer from Quora shares that problems can arise from poorly tested or non-existent fallbacks when the unsubscribe URL isn't available. Ensure that you have a system to handle and log cases where the URL cannot be created, rather than defaulting to '<undefined>'.
7 Jun 2024 - Quora
What the experts say
3 expert opinions
The appearance of '<undefined>' in Gmail's List-Unsubscribe header points to a bug either in the sender's email system or on Google's end. Dynamic content generation issues, rendering errors in email templates, or a general failure in the software creating the email can lead to this problem. Robust error handling and continuous monitoring of the email system are essential to prevent and address these issues.
Key opinions
- Bugs Identified: The '<undefined>' value indicates a bug somewhere in the email processing pipeline.
- Dynamic Content Issues: Problems during dynamic content generation can cause the unsubscribe link to fail and display '<undefined>'.
- Rendering Errors: Errors in the email template rendering process can lead to the unsubscribe link not being properly generated.
- Google's End: Issue could be a bug with Googles end - but more likely its the sending server.
Key considerations
- Check System: Check your sending system to ensure the unsubscribe link is correctly generated.
- Implement Error Handling: Implement error handling to prevent problems such as '<undefined>' from appearing when generating an email.
- Monitor Software: Continuously monitor the software that constructs the email to catch bugs.
- Review Email Template: Review your email template, is a valid unsubscribe link being generated in code.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that seeing '<undefined>' in a List-Unsubscribe header could mean the system generating the email template has encountered an error during the rendering of the unsubscribe link. The system should be checked to ensure that the unsubscribe link is always properly generated and that proper error handling is in place to prevent such issues.
19 Sep 2023 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks states that seeing “undefined” in the list-unsubscribe header indicates a bug somewhere. While the focus should primarily be on the sender's message composition pipeline, the fact that it changes suggests there may be a bug on Google's end.
2 Jan 2024 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
6 technical articles
The '<undefined>' issue in Gmail's List-Unsubscribe header can be attributed to several technical factors related to header formatting, encoding, network issues, DNS problems, and server configurations. Ensuring compliance with RFC specifications, proper MIME encoding, error handling for transient issues, correct DNS settings, and an up-to-date sending server are crucial for resolving this problem.
Key findings
- Format Compliance: Issues are often related to the List-Unsubscribe header not conforming to RFC 2369 and RFC 8058 specifications.
- Encoding Problems: Improper encoding of special characters in the header can lead to parsing issues. Refer to RFC 5322 for encoding rules.
- Transient Network Errors: Temporary unavailability of the unsubscribe endpoint or network errors can cause the issue.
- MIME Encoding: Incorrect MIME encoding or improperly set content-type headers may be the cause.
- DNS Propagation: DNS propagation issues can prevent the header from updating correctly across different servers.
- Server Configuration: Non-compliant sending server configurations can result in incorrect header generation.
Key considerations
- Adhere to RFC: Ensure the List-Unsubscribe header conforms to RFC 2369 and RFC 8058 specifications.
- Proper Encoding: Ensure correct encoding of special characters and proper setting of the content-type header.
- Implement Error Handling: Implement error handling to retry sending the header in case of transient network errors.
- Verify DNS: Verify DNS settings and allow sufficient time for propagation.
- Update Server: Ensure your sending server and ESP are up-to-date and correctly configured to comply with modern email standards.
Technical article
Documentation from MxToolbox advises that it is possible your domain may be experiencing DNS propagation issues. The header may not be correctly updating across different servers. Verify DNS settings and allow sufficient time for propagation.
31 May 2023 - MxToolbox
Technical article
Documentation from Microsoft Learn explains that transient network errors or temporary unavailability of the unsubscribe endpoint could cause this issue. Implement error handling to retry sending the header if it initially fails.
14 Jan 2023 - Microsoft Learn
Are mailto links compliant with Google and Yahoo's one-click unsubscribe requirements?
Does Google require List-Unsubscribe for one-click unsubscribe in emails?
How are Gmail and Yahoo enforcing unsubscribe requests, and what factors do they consider for compliance?
How can I verify if my company's emails have List-Unsubscribe headers correctly configured?
How do I add an unsubscribe button to the email header and what is RFC 8058?
How do I verify multiple domains in Mailchimp to fix DMARC and DKIM issues?
