Summary
The '5.7.1 Email rejected due to transformation error' when sending to Apple's privaterelay.appleid.com addresses has multiple potential causes. A primary factor is the necessity for senders to register their domains with Apple. Compliance with Apple's program rules, sending from registered email addresses, and ensuring valid user IDs are crucial. The transformation failure can also stem from Apple's private email relay service experiencing server-side issues, revoked or disabled relay addresses, or simply sending to invalid addresses. Best practices include validating email addresses before sending, regularly cleaning mailing lists to remove invalid addresses, adhering to Apple's guidelines, maintaining a good sender reputation, and monitoring Apple's service status. In some cases, manual verification of affected users' relay addresses and contacting Apple support may be necessary. Ultimately, issues could also stem from your domain authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC).
Key findings
- Domain Registration: Sending domains *must* be registered with Apple to avoid these bounces.
- Validity of Addresses: Transformation errors often arise from sending to invalid, revoked, or disabled Apple relay addresses.
- Apple's Infrastructure: Problems within Apple's Private Email Relay infrastructure can cause widespread transformation errors.
- Authentication: Proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication is a core requirement
Key considerations
- Proactive Validation: Implement robust email validation processes *before* sending to minimize bounces.
- Mailing List Hygiene: Regularly clean your mailing lists, removing invalid or deactivated Apple relay addresses.
- Adherence to Apple's Guidelines: Strictly adhere to Apple's specific guidelines for sending to their private relay addresses, including sender reputation and content.
- Monitoring: Monitor Apple's service status for any known issues. If there are wider problems at Apples end there may not be a fix you can implement yourself.
- Manual Checks: Consider manually checking with affected users to confirm the status of their relay addresses.
- Contact Support: If problems persist, contact Apple support and provide them with a sample of the failures.
What email marketers say
9 marketer opinions
The '5.7.1 Email rejected due to transformation error' when sending to Apple's privaterelay.appleid.com addresses can stem from several issues. Primarily, it's crucial to ensure your sending domain is registered and properly authenticated with Apple, including correct SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records. The error can also arise when Apple users revoke or disable their private relay addresses, necessitating regular list cleaning. In some instances, the issue is on Apple's end, stemming from internal server problems or an inability to transform the relay address; in such cases, contacting Apple support or monitoring the situation is advised. Adhering to Apple's sending guidelines, maintaining a good sender reputation, and manually verifying the status of affected user's relay addresses can also mitigate these bounces.
Key opinions
- Domain Registration: Ensure your sending domain is registered and authenticated with Apple.
- List Hygiene: Regularly check for and remove revoked or disabled Apple relay addresses.
- Apple-Side Issues: Transformation errors can be caused by issues on Apple's servers.
- Domain Authentication: Properly configured SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are essential for sending to Apple private relay addresses.
Key considerations
- Apple Guidelines: Adhere to Apple's specific guidelines for sending to private relay addresses.
- Sender Reputation: Maintain a good sender reputation to avoid being flagged by Apple's systems.
- Manual Verification: Manually check with affected users to confirm the status of their private relay addresses.
- Contact Apple: If the issue persists and you have followed domain authenication steps and keep getting the error then contact Apple support to assist.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Quora shares that these bounces can result from Apple having internal server issues. If you've checked your domain registration and email practices, the issue may be on Apple's side and resolve itself in time.
6 Mar 2024 - Quora
Marketer view
Email marketer from LinkedIn explains that to avoid 'transformation error' bounces, ensure you adhere to Apple's guidelines for sending to private relay addresses, including maintaining good sender reputation and avoiding spam triggers in your email content.
17 Sep 2023 - LinkedIn
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
The '5.7.1 Email rejected due to transformation error' when sending to Apple's privaterelay.appleid.com addresses is caused by a few factors. Primarily, sender addresses may not be registered with Apple. Additionally, the issue might stem from an invalid user ID or a failure in the encrypted ID's transformation into a valid email. In some cases, Apple's Private Email Relay service itself experiences server-side problems, which are often widespread and require monitoring rather than direct intervention by the sender. Ensuring compliance with Apple's program rules and sending from registered email addresses are key preventative measures.
Key opinions
- Registration Required: Sender addresses must be registered with Apple to avoid rejections.
- Invalid User IDs: Transformation errors may occur if the user ID is not currently valid or if the encrypted ID fails to transform.
- Server-Side Issues: Apple's Private Email Relay service can experience server-side problems leading to widespread bounces.
Key considerations
- Compliance with Rules: Ensure compliance with Apple's program rules for sending emails.
- Registered Addresses: Always send emails from addresses registered with Apple for this purpose.
- Monitoring is key: When wide spread monitoring is key, If the error is wide spread the problem is most likely at apples end and there is no remediation you can perform.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks clarifies that the sender addresses need to be registered to prevent bounces.
12 Sep 2022 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks explains there was a problem a few days ago causing rejections from the privaterelay.appleid.com servers and Apple is aware and working on a fix.
5 Dec 2022 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
3 technical articles
The '5.7.1 Email rejected due to transformation error' bounces from Apple's privaterelay.appleid.com are often linked to issues with Apple's private email relay service or the validity of the relay addresses themselves. Specifically, these errors can occur when users have revoked or disabled their Apple ID email relay addresses or are trying to send to invalid or deactivated addresses. Best practices to mitigate these issues involve checking the validity of email addresses before sending, regularly validating email addresses, and removing invalid ones from mailing lists. Monitoring Apple's service status for known issues is also advisable.
Key findings
- Relay Service Issues: Problems within Apple's private email relay service can cause transformation errors.
- Revoked/Disabled Addresses: Users revoking or disabling their Apple ID email relay addresses is a common cause.
- Invalid Addresses: Sending to invalid or deactivated Apple relay email addresses contributes to the errors.
Key considerations
- Address Validation: Implement robust email address validation processes before sending.
- Regular List Cleaning: Regularly remove invalid or deactivated Apple relay email addresses from mailing lists.
- Service Monitoring: Monitor Apple's service status for any known issues affecting the private email relay.
Technical article
Documentation from Apple Developer Documentation explains that the 'transformation error' can occur if there are issues with the private email relay service, especially when users have revoked or disabled their Apple ID email relay addresses. Ensure your application properly handles these scenarios by checking the validity of the email address before sending.
24 Jun 2024 - Apple Developer Documentation
Technical article
Documentation from SparkPost Documentation highlights that the '5.7.1 transformation error' is often seen when sending to Apple's private relay addresses. This could be because the user has disabled the address, or there is an issue with Apple's service. Check the user's email validity and monitor Apple's service status for any known issues.
8 Sep 2021 - SparkPost Documentation
Are there any current issues with Yahoo FBL emails?
Can I email users who have Apple's private relay email addresses?
How can I resolve blocks affecting iCloud 2FA notifications and what is the typical response time from Apple support?
How do I fix Apple Mail DMARC failure when sending from Gmail with a non-Gmail domain?
How does Apple Private Relay encode email addresses and how does domain whitelisting affect deliverability?
What are Apple's privaterelay.apple.com and hide my email and how should they be handled in email marketing?
