Summary
SMTP smuggling exploits vulnerabilities in email server implementations, rather than the SMTP protocol itself, to bypass security measures like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. This allows attackers to inject malicious content into email streams, leading to phishing attacks, spam, malware distribution, and potentially data breaches. The issue stems from deviations from SMTP standards, complex implementations, and insufficient security authorization. Microsoft has addressed this with updates to Exchange Online Protection, but broader prevention requires rigorous input validation, stricter adherence to standards, strong authentication, encryption, regular security audits, and a possible re-evaluation of existing email authentication methods, including concerns around ARC's trustworthiness.
Key findings
- Implementation Issue: SMTP smuggling exploits email server implementations, not a fundamental flaw in the SMTP protocol.
- Security Bypass: Attackers bypass SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, allowing malicious emails to appear legitimate.
- Attack Vectors: SMTP smuggling facilitates phishing, spam, malware distribution, and potentially data breaches.
- Authorization Problems: Inadequate security authorization in inbound systems contributes to the vulnerability.
- Standards Deviation: Deviations from SMTP standards and complex implementations create exploitation opportunities.
- Authentication Concerns: A need to re-evaluate current email authentication methods is highlighted, with concerns around ARC.
Key considerations
- Input Validation: Implement rigorous input validation to prevent malicious content injection.
- Standard Compliance: Ensure strict adherence to SMTP standards to minimize vulnerabilities.
- Authentication & Encryption: Use strong authentication and encryption methods to protect email streams.
- Regular Audits: Conduct regular security audits to identify and patch potential vulnerabilities.
- Re-evaluate Authentication: Consider a re-evaluation of existing email authentication methods to address underlying issues.
- Header Validation: Implement stricter header validation in email servers to prevent exploitation.
What email marketers say
11 marketer opinions
SMTP smuggling is a technique that exploits vulnerabilities in email server implementations and message formatting to bypass security measures like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. Attackers inject malicious content into email headers and bodies, which recipient servers interpret as legitimate emails. This can lead to phishing attacks, spam, and malware distribution. The core problem isn't the SMTP protocol itself, but the security and authorization policies of inbound systems. Microsoft has patched this vulnerability, but broader solutions involve stricter adherence to SMTP standards, improved input validation, and robust email infrastructure security measures. There are also concerns about the effectiveness of ARC as a "trust me" system.
Key opinions
- Implementation Issue: SMTP smuggling is primarily an implementation issue, not a flaw in the SMTP protocol itself.
- Bypasses Security: The technique bypasses traditional email security measures like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.
- Attack Vectors: Attackers can inject malicious content, leading to phishing, spam, and malware distribution.
- Security Authorization: Inadequate security and authorization policies in inbound systems are a major contributing factor.
- ARC Concerns: There are concerns that ARC relies too heavily on trust and could be vulnerable to abuse.
Key considerations
- Strict Adherence to Standards: Organizations should ensure strict adherence to SMTP standards to prevent message manipulation.
- Input Validation: Rigorous input validation is necessary to prevent the injection of malicious content.
- Infrastructure Security: Robust email infrastructure security measures are crucial to safeguarding against SMTP smuggling.
- Security Audits: Organizations should conduct regular security audits to identify and patch vulnerabilities.
- Authentication and Encryption: Strong authentication and encryption mechanisms should be implemented to safeguard email streams.
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks explains that SMTP smuggling is an implementation issue, not a protocol issue.
30 Oct 2022 - Email Geeks
Marketer view
Email marketer from TheHackerNews explains that attackers are using SMTP smuggling to bypass traditional email security measures, such as SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, by manipulating the way email servers interpret message boundaries and headers.
29 Jan 2022 - TheHackerNews
What the experts say
4 expert opinions
The responses highlight several key aspects regarding SMTP smuggling. Firstly, stricter adherence to SMTP specifications might cause legitimate emails to fail. Secondly, there's a sentiment that email authentication methods need to be re-evaluated and potentially redesigned from the ground up. Thirdly, prevention involves rigorous input validation, strict adherence to standards, and implementing security measures. Finally, safeguarding email streams requires strong authentication, encryption, and regular security audits.
Key opinions
- Compliance Issues: Stricter enforcement of SMTP specifications may lead to legitimate emails failing.
- Authentication Rethink: There is a need to re-evaluate and potentially redesign email authentication methods.
- Prevention Strategies: Preventing SMTP smuggling involves input validation and adhering to standards.
Key considerations
- Input Validation: Implement rigorous input validation to prevent unauthorized message injection.
- Adherence to Standards: Ensure strict adherence to SMTP standards to minimize vulnerabilities.
- Authentication & Encryption: Implement strong authentication and encryption to safeguard email streams.
- Regular Audits: Conduct regular security audits to identify and patch vulnerabilities.
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks shares that it will be interesting to see how many legit emails fail when folks start requiring compliance with the SMTP spec.
18 Aug 2023 - Email Geeks
Expert view
Expert from Email Geeks shares that after 20 years, it might be time to rethink authentication from the ground up due to issues that were previously dismissed.
18 Apr 2025 - Email Geeks
What the documentation says
5 technical articles
SMTP smuggling, as highlighted by various documentation sources, presents a significant threat to email security due to deviations from SMTP standards and complex implementations across different servers. This allows attackers to manipulate message formatting and bypass security filters like DMARC, leading to potential data breaches and financial losses. Microsoft's Exchange Online Protection (EOP) has been updated with stricter header validation to mitigate these attacks.
Key findings
- Deviation from Standards: Deviations from SMTP standards create vulnerabilities exploitable by SMTP smuggling.
- DMARC Bypass: SMTP smuggling can bypass DMARC authentication by manipulating email headers.
- Security Risk: SMTP smuggling poses a significant risk, leading to data breaches and financial losses.
- Complexity of Standards: Complex SMTP standards and varying implementations create exploitation opportunities.
Key considerations
- Header Validation: Implement stricter header validation in email servers to prevent exploitation.
- Standard Compliance: Adhere strictly to SMTP standards to reduce vulnerabilities.
- Update Security: Regularly update email security measures to address evolving threats like SMTP smuggling.
- Monitor Email Traffic: Monitor email traffic for unusual patterns indicative of SMTP smuggling attempts.
Technical article
Documentation from RFC Editor explains that the SMTP protocol defines how email messages should be transmitted. Deviations from the standard can lead to vulnerabilities such as SMTP smuggling, where attackers manipulate message formatting to bypass security filters.
11 Dec 2022 - RFC Editor
Technical article
Documentation from IETF explains that the SMTP standards are complex, and variations in implementation across different email servers can create opportunities for attackers to exploit vulnerabilities like SMTP smuggling.
22 Feb 2024 - IETF
How are bad actors using Google Forms to send spam?
How can a phishing email pass SPF and DKIM authentication checks?
How can email senders and users prevent and identify phishing emails?
How can I protect my domain from being spoofed and blacklisted?
How can I use DMARC to prevent spammers from using my domain?
