Summary
The consensus among email marketers, experts, and legal documentation is that email marketing opt-outs do not expire. Sending emails to individuals who have unsubscribed violates CAN-SPAM and potentially GDPR, is unethical, damages sender reputation, and increases the risk of spam complaints. While retargeting via other channels to encourage opt-in is acceptable, directly re-engaging unsubscribed users is strongly discouraged. Managing subscriber lists effectively and honoring unsubscribe requests are crucial for email deliverability and legal compliance.
Key findings
- Opt-Outs are Permanent: Email marketing opt-outs are generally considered permanent and should be honored indefinitely unless a subscriber explicitly opts back in.
- Legal Violations: Sending emails to unsubscribed users violates CAN-SPAM and may violate GDPR, leading to potential legal consequences.
- Reputation Damage: Engaging with unsubscribed users harms sender reputation, increases spam complaints, and can lead to blacklisting and delivery issues.
- Importance of List Management: Maintaining a clean, up-to-date subscriber list is essential for email deliverability and compliance with regulations.
- Alternative Retargeting: Re-engaging unsubscribed users through other channels (like social media) to encourage opt-in is an acceptable alternative to direct email contact.
Key considerations
- Comply with CAN-SPAM: Ensure all email marketing practices comply with CAN-SPAM regulations regarding opt-out requests and timelines.
- Adhere to GDPR: Respect GDPR principles of explicit consent and data privacy, particularly when handling EU residents' data.
- Maintain List Hygiene: Regularly clean email lists, removing unsubscribed users promptly to avoid deliverability issues, spam complaints, and legal risks.
- Prioritize Permission: Focus on obtaining explicit consent from subscribers and provide clear, easy-to-use unsubscribe options.
- Monitor Unsubscribe Rates: Track unsubscribe rates to identify potential problems with email content, frequency, or targeting.
What email marketers say
12 marketer opinions
The overwhelming consensus is that email marketing opt-outs do not expire. Sending emails to users who have previously unsubscribed is generally considered a violation of CAN-SPAM and other regulations, unethical, damaging to sender reputation, and likely to result in spam complaints. While alternative channel retargeting to encourage opt-in is acceptable, directly re-engaging unsubscribed users is not.
Key opinions
- Opt-outs are Permanent: Opt-out requests are generally considered permanent and should be honored indefinitely unless the subscriber explicitly opts back in.
- Legal Ramifications: Sending emails to users after they've unsubscribed is a violation of CAN-SPAM and potentially other data privacy regulations like GDPR.
- Reputation Damage: Re-engaging unsubscribed users harms sender reputation, increases the risk of spam complaints, and may lead to blacklisting.
- Alternative Retargeting: While direct re-engagement is discouraged, retargeting via other channels (e.g., social media) to encourage opt-in is an acceptable practice.
Key considerations
- CAN-SPAM Compliance: Ensure all email marketing practices fully comply with CAN-SPAM regulations regarding opt-out requests.
- Data Privacy Laws: Be mindful of global data privacy laws like GDPR, which emphasize user consent and the right to be forgotten.
- List Hygiene: Maintain clean and up-to-date email lists, promptly removing unsubscribed users to avoid deliverability issues and legal risks.
- Alternative Engagement: Explore alternative channels for re-engaging with inactive subscribers, focusing on obtaining explicit consent for email communication.
Marketer view
Email marketer from Reddit user shares that emailing someone who has unsubscribed will most likely result in spam complaints and could result in your IP address being blocked. They do not mention anything about opt-outs expiring.
18 Jan 2024 - Reddit
Marketer view
Marketer from Email Geeks shares a quote from the FTC from 2008 which states that Congress has not imposed a time limit on opt-out requests.
10 Mar 2022 - Email Geeks
What the experts say
2 expert opinions
Both sources emphasize the importance of managing subscriber lists and honoring unsubscribe requests. While neither explicitly states that email marketing opt-outs expire, they highlight the necessity of having a clear unsubscribe process, managing requests appropriately, and focusing on permission-based marketing.
Key opinions
- List Management is Key: Maintaining a clean and well-managed subscriber list is crucial for email deliverability.
- Clear Unsubscribe Process: Providing a clear and easy-to-use unsubscribe process is essential for respecting subscriber preferences and legal compliance.
- Permission-Based Marketing: Focusing on permission-based marketing, where subscribers actively opt-in, is a best practice for building trust and ensuring engagement.
- Legal Requirement: Managing unsubscribe requests appropriately is a legal obligation for senders.
Key considerations
- Review Unsubscribe Process: Ensure your unsubscribe process is clear, easily accessible, and promptly honors requests.
- Implement List Hygiene Practices: Regularly clean your email list by removing inactive or unengaged subscribers.
- Obtain Explicit Consent: Prioritize obtaining explicit consent from subscribers before sending marketing emails.
- Stay Informed on Regulations: Keep up-to-date with email marketing regulations, such as CAN-SPAM, to ensure compliance.
Expert view
Expert from Word to the Wise explains that managing subscriber lists is a key element to ensuring email deliverability. Laura advocates for a clear unsubscribe process and permission passes. She does not specifically mention that opt-outs expire.
20 Aug 2023 - Word to the Wise
Expert view
Expert from Spam Resource explains that you should always include an unsubscribe link and manage requests appropriately as this is a legal requirement. They do not mention anything about opt-outs expiring.
7 Mar 2024 - Spam Resource
What the documentation says
3 technical articles
The provided documentation from the FTC, CAN-SPAM Act, and GDPR collectively indicates that email marketing opt-outs do not have an expiration date. CAN-SPAM requires honoring opt-out requests promptly, implying indefinite validity unless the recipient opts back in. GDPR reinforces this by requiring explicit consent, suggesting that withdrawn consent (opt-out) remains in effect until new consent is provided.
Key findings
- No Expiration Under CAN-SPAM: The CAN-SPAM Act mandates honoring opt-out requests without specifying an expiration date.
- Prompt Opt-Out Compliance: Senders must cease sending commercial emails within 10 business days of receiving an opt-out request, as per CAN-SPAM.
- GDPR Reinforces Consent: GDPR's emphasis on explicit consent implies that withdrawn consent (opt-out) remains valid until new consent is given.
- Implied Indefinite Validity: Both CAN-SPAM and GDPR suggest that opt-outs remain in effect indefinitely unless the subscriber actively opts back in.
Key considerations
- Ensure CAN-SPAM Compliance: Adhere strictly to CAN-SPAM regulations regarding opt-out requests and timelines.
- Respect GDPR Principles: Comply with GDPR's requirements for explicit consent and data handling, ensuring respect for user choices.
- Implement Robust Opt-Out Handling: Establish a robust system for processing and managing opt-out requests to ensure prompt compliance.
- Review Consent Mechanisms: Regularly review and update consent mechanisms to ensure they meet GDPR standards and best practices.
Technical article
Documentation from Federal Trade Commission explains that the CAN-SPAM Act requires honoring opt-out requests and provides no specific expiration date for such requests. Senders must stop sending commercial emails to recipients within 10 business days of receiving their opt-out request.
22 Feb 2025 - Federal Trade Commission
Technical article
Documentation from CAN-SPAM Act shares that senders must honor opt-out requests promptly. While the Act doesn't specify an expiration date for opt-outs, the implication is that they remain in effect indefinitely unless the recipient explicitly opts back in.
13 Apr 2025 - CAN-SPAM Act
Are abuse reports and feedback loops (FBLs) still useful in email marketing, and how do they work with different email clients?
Are re-engagement email subject lines and practices deceptive and how should you deal with engaging with old leads and unsubscribes?
Do email unsubscribes negatively affect sender reputation?
How are Gmail and Yahoo enforcing unsubscribe requests, and what factors do they consider for compliance?
How do mailbox providers handle re-subscribes after list-unsubscribe and how long does it take to process unsubscribe requests?
How long should I exclude unengaged email subscribers to improve deliverability?
